The Commentariat -- December 1, 2015

Internal links removed.

Angela Keane & Justin Sink of Bloomberg: "The U.S. will meet commitments to help finance developing nations' efforts to reduce carbon pollution, President Barack Obama said, challenging congressional Republicans who have fought most of his environmental policies.... 'My expectation is that we will absolutely be able to meet our commitments,' Obama said Tuesday at a news conference in Paris. 'This is part of American leadership, by the way. This is part of the debate that we have to have in the United States more often. Too often American leadership is defined by sending troops somewhere.'" ...

... Sylvie Corbet & Angela Charlton of the AP: "... leaders of poor nations most affected by climate change are sharing their stories of global warming with leaders of some of the richest on Tuesday. The encounters -- French President Francois Hollande met African leaders and President Barack Obama was meeting envoys from island nations -- highlighted one of the biggest debates among delegates negotiating an international climate agreement: how much rich countries should help poor ones cope adapt to global warming and reduce their emissions." ...

... AP: "U.S. House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy says the House will not go along if President Barack Obama tries to commit taxpayer money to support a climate accord reached in Paris.... McCarthy suggested that a must-pass year-end spending bill currently in the works could become the vehicle for language blocking any such expenditure." ...

... Gardiner Harris of the New York Times: "President Obama told world leaders who gathered northeast of Paris on Monday for a climate conference that the United States is at least partly to blame for the life-threatening damage that environmental change has wrought, and he urged world leaders to join him in fixing the problem.... Mr. Obama also repeated an argument, lampooned by some Republicans, that the climate conference was a fitting response to the terrorist attacks that cost the lives of 130 people in and around Paris on Nov. 13. 'What greater rejection of those who would tear down our world than marshaling our best efforts to save it,' he said." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) CW: Can hardly wait for the GOP response to Obama's admitting U.S. culpability on climate change: "Weak!" "Hates America!" _______Fill in______

     ... As the World Burns. Eliza Collins of Politico: "Republican presidential candidates and their allies made fun of President Barack Obama's comments about climate change in Paris on Monday. Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, during a town hall in Iowa, said Obama 'apparently thinks having an SUV in your driveway is more dangerous than a bunch of terrorists trying to blow up the world.'" Et-cetera.

... The Times has a running commentary on the Paris talks. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)

Devin Henry of the Hill: "The White House is pushing congressional Republicans to formally authorize military action against the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and institute new rules to prevent terrorism in the United States.... Speaking in Paris, White House press secretary Josh Earnest said Monday that Congress needs to implement a series or proposals rather than engage in politically motivated posturing that is 'wrong, dangerous and falls far short of what the America people deserve.'" ...

... Michael Dougherty of the Week: "Conservatives today are incensed that President Obama didn't plunge America deeply into a needless war in Syria two years ago.... But two years ago, it was conservative opposition to a needless war in Syria that stopped Obama from plunging in. This history is clear. It is undeniable. But many of my fellow conservatives, when faced with the choice of acknowledging reality or deriding a Democratic president as weak and feckless, will always and infallibly choose the latter."

Greg Sargent: "It looks increasingly likely that some time in the next few days or weeks, the GOP Congress may realize a longtime dream of Republicans: Pass something that seriously guts Obamacare. The health law won't actually be repealed, of course, since President Obama will veto such a measure. But that alone -- forcing Obama to veto a repeal bill -- is deemed a worthy goal in and of itself."

The New York Times editors call for the resignations of Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, Police Superintendent Garry McCarthy & Cook County Prosecutor Anita Alvarez over their self-interested cover-up of the (alleged) police murder of Laquan McDonald. "Around the time the freelance journalist Brandon Smith filed suit for release of the dash-cam video, on Aug. 5, 2015, the Chicago Police Department told him that it had already received, and rejected, 14 other Freedom of Information Act requests for the evidence." ...

     ... CW: Let's hear from President Obama on his support for & employment of Rahm Emanuel. Now would be a very good time for him to get over the "Chicago-style politics" his critics accuse him of practicing. ...

... Bill Ruthhart of the Chicago Tribune: "On Tuesday, Emanuel will seek to quell some of the growing chorus of criticism by announcing a task force his administration says 'will review the system of accountability, oversight and training that is currently in place for Chicago's police officers,' according to a brief news release issued late Monday. Appointing a committee to look into an issue is a tried-and-true tactic elected officials long have employed to buy time and breathing room when faced with a scandal or crisis." ...

     ... CW Note: The Trib has nixed my link above, but I got there via a link in Item 10 of this Mother Jones story by Brandon Patterson. Patterson provides a quick rundown of recent news regarding the case.

CBS/AP: "Fifty-seven-year-old Robert Lewis Dear appeared before a judge in a brief video hearing on Monday, standing next to public defender Daniel King. He's the same lawyer who represented Colorado theater shooting gunman James Holmes.... Judge Stephen J. Sletta has sealed court documents in this case. The order was made available Monday after being issued Friday, the day of the attack. Such documents detail evidence gathered by investigators that justify arresting suspects and searching property."

Sarah Ferris of the Hill: Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) who head the special committee designed to convict investigate Planned Parenthood is not even about Planned Parenthood because the resolution establishing the committee does not specifically mention Planned Parenthood even those others -- including Speaker Ryan -- have said the committee is specifically charged to look into federal dollars Planned Parenthood receives.

     ... CW: So here's my question. Do they take lessons on how to tell whoppers with a straight face before or after they're elected to Congress? ...

... digby: "Hey, if you don't want to get shot, don't go to a Planned Parenthood clinic. That's pretty much what these anti-abortion leaders told Irin Carmon at MSNBC.... They just think that Planned Parenthood is dismembering living babies for profit and that it's perfectly natural for someone to want to kill them. And if someone happens to be there to support a friend it's unfortunate collateral damage. You can decide for yourself whether it matters that one of our major political parties is completely cowed by these terrorists." ...

... Rebecca Traister of New York: "That Democratic politicians are daring to draw connective lines between Republican language -- [Sen. Bernie] Sanders's 'bitter rhetoric' -- and the violence enacted this weekend represents a bold strategic shift. It could be the beginning of a reversal that has been a long time coming: the association of 'life' -- as in [Sen. Barbara] Boxer's evocation of the 'life-saving health care' provided by Planned Parenthood -- with reproductive-rights activism, and violence as the domain of those who stand between women and access to legal, high-quality health services, including abortion."

Jordain Carney of the Hill: "The Senate on Monday signed off on a new administrator for the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) amid a growing Syrian humanitarian crisis. Senators voted 79-7 to confirm Gayle Smith to lead the agency, seven months after President Obama nominated her for the post.... Despite the bipartisan consensus around her nomination, Smith was delayed over partisan fighting on unrelated issues. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) ... said earlier this year that he would block all State Department nominations because of his opposition to the Iran nuclear deal."

Politico: "House Speaker Paul Ryan on Monday officially invited President Barack Obama to deliver his State of the Union address to a joint session of Congress on Tuesday, Jan. 12."

Thomas Gibbons-Neff of the Washington Post: "The United States has delivered more than $260 million in non-lethal military equipment to help the government of Ukraine in its fight against a Russian-backed insurgency, but some of the U.S.-supplied gear meant to protect and transport Ukrainian military forces is little more than junk.... It is unclear how much of the material sent to Ukraine is secondhand and antiquated. The U.S. government has also sent new equipment, such as night vision and first-aid kits. Troops there have also received advanced equipment such as counter artillery, counter mortar radars, and communications gear."

Keith Bradsher of the New York Times: "The International Monetary Fund on Monday designated the Chinese renminbi as one of the world's elite currencies, a major milestone that underscores the country's rising financial and economic heft. The decision will help pave the way for broader use of the renminbi in trade and finance, securing China's standing as a global economic power. Just four other currencies -- the dollar, the euro, the pound and the yen -- have the I.M.F. designation." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)

Jim Tankersley of the Washington Post: Economist Thomas Piketty says "Inequality is a major driver of Middle Eastern terrorism, including the Islamic State attacks on Paris earlier this month -- and Western nations have themselves largely to blame for that inequality.... Within [Middle East] monarchies, he continues, a small slice of people controls most of the wealth, while a large -- including women and refugees -- are kept in a state of 'semi-slavery.' Those economic conditions, he says, have become justifications for jihadists, along with the casualties of a series of wars in the region perpetuated by Western powers."

Will Hobson & Steven Rich of the Washington Post: "... at many of America's largest public universities, athletic departments making millions more every year from surging television contracts, luxury suite sales and endorsements continue to take money from tens of thousands of students who will never set foot in stadiums or arenas. Mandatory student fees for college athletic departments are common across the country. Often small line items of a couple hundred dollars on long, complex tuition bills, these fees make millions for athletic departments at larger colleges.... Some smaller schools charge more than $2,000 per year in athletic fees...."

Paresh Dave of the Los Angeles Times: "By doing little more than taking a photo and swiping across their smartphone screen a few times, Snapchat users on Tuesday can raise as much as $3 million to combat AIDS. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation plans to donate $3 to the nonprofit group (RED) for each use of a decorative 'World AIDS Day' banner on Snapchat.... The Gates Foundation expects to close donations after 1 million uses of the geofilter. But it will donate an additional $1 million if a music video on YouTube -- starring Scarlett Johansson, Barry Manilow and Jimmy Kimmel -- is shared more than 333,000 times." ...

... CW: Evidently reporter Paresh Dave thinks this is a lovely, generous plan. Pardon me for disagreeing. Here are these billionaires announcing, "If you will jump through a hoop for me, I will give you $3. Also, you have to be rich enough to have a smartphone, & have enough time to figure out how to use Snapchat (a commercial operation) & get that banner across your photo. Here's another idea, Bill & Melinda: write a check for $3MM & send it in. Oh, wait, no publicity for you.

Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. New York Times public editor Margaret Sullivan says her paper should quit presenting as fact claims made by Donald Trump & his campaign. CW: Seems pretty obvious. ...

... CW: The dogged reporting of independent journalist Brandon Smith & the stenographic "reporting" of New York Times reporter Alan Rappeport makes a nice contrast, doesn't it? (And yes, I know the Times often sues to obtain documents under the FOIA.)

Presidential Race

Liz Kruetz of ABC News: "One by one [Monday] night, 13 female Democratic senators took the stage inside the packed ballroom at the Hyatt Regency in Washington, DC to raise money and announce their support for Hillary Clinton. But it was the person missing from the group who stood out most. Elizabeth Warren, the progressive lawmaker from Massachusetts, was the only female Democratic senator who wasn't at the endorsement event and fundraiser for Clinton's presidential campaign.... Clinton's campaign said it invited the 13 female senators who have endorsed Clinton to attend tonight's event, but would not say whether or not they invited Warren. They also would not comment about Warren's absence." ...

... Amy Chozick of the New York Times: "Evoking the investment in American infrastructure by Presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt and Ronald Reagan, Hillary Clinton on Monday unveiled the most sprawling -- and costliest -- government program of her campaign to date. Mrs. Clinton said her five-year, $275-billion federal infrastructure program was aimed at creating middle-class jobs while investing heavily in improving the country's highways, airports and ports. Bridging the 'infrastructure gap' between the United States and developing nations like China would also eliminate red tape and fuel overall economic growth, she said." ...

... Julian Hattem of the Hill: "The State Department released its largest batch yet of Hillary Clinton's emails on Monday, part of a gradual process to put all of the messages that she claimed were work-related out for the public to see. The department released 7,800 pages of the former secretary of State's emails, including one email that the Office of the Director of National Intelligence had originally flagged as potentially containing classified information before deciding it did not contain intelligence agency information. Monday's document dump was the seventh of the process."

Alan Rappeport of the New York Times: "Senator Bernie Sanders stepped off the campaign trail on Monday to have a procedure to repair a hernia. Mr. Sanders, the independent from Vermont and Democratic presidential candidate, had an outpatient procedure at George Washington University Hospital and was expected return to his Senate duties on Tuesday." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)

Amy Davidson of the New Yorker has the first fair report of presidential candidates' reactions to last week's Planned Parenthood murders. "Do the Republican candidates think that nobody is listening to them? Are they even listening to themselves?"

Maggie Haberman & John Corrales of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump met privately on Monday with black pastors and religious figures at Trump Tower in Manhattan, where he was expected to hold preliminary discussions to seek their endorsements." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...

... Trump thinks the fiasco was the fault of BlackLivesMatter. Nick Gass of Politico: "'I think what happened, probably, it gets publicity, unfortunately, as everything I do gets publicity, and probably some of the Black Lives Matter folks called them up and said, "oh, you shouldn't be meeting with Trump because he believes that all lives matter,'" Trump remarked." CW: It seems MSNBC's "Morning Joe" is using Trump for critical commentary on the climate summit. Good work, Joe! ...

... Here are some things Donald Trump thinks are funny: Hernia operations, physical disabilities, calling the President a dumbass. If you don't think hernias & other physical impairments are funny, you're like those media critics who can't take a joke & are just trying to make an excellent humorist "look bad." ...

... Hadas Gold of Politico: "Donald Trump threatened to boycott the next Republican debate on Monday night, unless hosting network CNN donated $5 million to a charity. 'How about I tell CNN, who doesn't treat me properly I'm not gonna do the next debate, okay,' Trump said at a rally in Georgia. 'How about we do this for CNN: I won't do the debate unless they pay me five million dollars, all of which money goes to the Wounded Warriors or goes to vets?'"

Chris Christie Will Not Be Ready on Day One. But Maybe on Day Seven. If Provoked Enough. Katherine Krueger of TPM: "New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R) on Monday gave a stronger rebuttal to ... Donald Trump's claims that Muslims Americans were cheering the attacks on 9/11, saying 'that didn't happen.'...The clarification comes a week after the governor said he didn't 'recall' Muslims cheering, in part because he was concerned about family and friends who were close to the attacks.... Christie's remarks came the same day Trump hit the governor on Twitter for his record of running the 'deeply troubled' state."

Ted & Marco Accuse Each Other of Once Doing Their Jobs. Ryan Lizza of the New Yorker: It now appears that we are entering a period of the campaign in which the two Republican senators who may have the best shot at unseating the front-runner, Donald Trump, and winning their party's nomination are veering into a potential murder-suicide pact over who was more complicit in actually trying to get something accomplished in Washington."

Dana Milbank: "Just days before the shooting [in Colorado Springs], [Ted] Cruz trumpeted an endorsement from an antiabortion activist who once called killing an abortion doctor a 'justifiable defensive action' and who leads a group, Operation Rescue, where a colleague did prison time for a conspiracy to bomb an abortion clinic. The activist whose endorsement Cruz celebrated, Troy Newman, is also on the board of the Center for Medical Progress, which made the surreptitious Planned Parenthood videos that prompted Cruz and many other conservatives to accuse the organization of selling 'baby parts' -- the phrase Dear allegedly used." Cruz has suggested that, according to media reports, The (alleged) shooter Robert Dear might be a "transgendered leftist activist." ...

... Here's the Rachel Maddow segment which Victoria D. links in the Comments below. The portion concerning Ted Cruz begins at about 13 min. in. The whole segment is worth watch:

Last I checked we don't have a rubber shortage in America. When I was in college we had a machine in the bathroom, you put .50 cents in and voila! So yes, anyone who wants contraceptives can access them, but it's an utterly made-up nonsense issue. -- Ted Cruz, outlining his reproductive rights program

Hillary Clinton embraces abortion on demand in all circumstances up until the moment of birth. Partial-birth abortion with taxpayer funding, with no notification for parents in any circumstances -- 91% of Americans say that's nuts. -- Ted Cruz, outlining Clinton's reproductive rights program

CW Translation: Contraceptive choices should be left to the man & I can lie wildly about Clinton's position on abortion. P.S. Thanks, CNN, for not bothering to fact-check Ted's remarks.

McKay Coppins of BuzzFeed: "Jeb and his team recognized the threat posed by Rubio nearly a year ago, and took aggressive action to knock him out of 2016 contention -- with some in Bush's circle trying to smear the senator by allegedly circulating lurid, unsubstantiated rumors of infidelity.... Ever since he began to make a name for himself in Tallahassee, Rubio had been trailed by a persistent series of unsubstantiated rumors about his sex life. Jilted mistresses, sordid affairs, secret love children.... No one in the staid, starchy D.C. press corps was willing to explicitly lay out the rumors dogging Rubio -- but they gestured toward them all the time...." Adapted from a segment of a book by Coppins. CW: Let's hope the sleaziest part of the story is not that Jeb!'s people do sleazy oppo research. What this election cycle is missing is sex. ...

... Andrew Prokop of Vox: "Since there's no evidence that these rumors about Rubio have any truth to them, the mainstream press has tended not to mention them in print. But a whisper campaign like this could well lead GOP elites to be hesitant to fall behind Rubio for fear of a looming scandal."

Andy Borowitz: "Calling criticism of her misrepresentations about Planned Parenthood 'typical left-wing tactics,' ... Carly Fiorina said, on Sunday, 'I will not be bullied into telling the truth.'"

Beyond the Beltway

Benjamin Weiser & Susanne Craig of the New York Times: "Sheldon Silver, who held a seemingly intractable grip on power for decades as one of the most feared politicians in New York State, was found guilty on Monday of federal corruption charges, ending a trial that was the capstone of the government's efforts to expose the seamy culture of influence-peddling in Albany. Mr. Silver, 71, a Manhattan Democrat, was convicted on all seven counts against him. The charges of honest services fraud, extortion and money laundering stemmed from schemes by which he obtained nearly $4 million in exchange for using his position to help benefit a cancer researcher and two real estate developers.... As a result of the conviction, he must automatically forfeit the Assembly seat to which he was first elected nearly 40 years ago." ...

... David Klepper & Larry Neumeister of the AP: "The conviction of former Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver has shaken New York politics down to the granite foundations of the state Capitol, provoking fresh calls to overhaul a system that has stubbornly clung to its long history of corruption."

Brian Lyman of the Montgomery (Alabama) Advertiser: "Alabama would pay just over $51,000 in legal fees to settle a lawsuit brought by Planned Parenthood Southeast over Gov. Robert Bentley's attempt to cancel the organization's Medicaid contract, under an agreement filed in federal court Monday morning.... The draft agreement, which still needs approval from U.S. District Judge Myron Thompson, says that Medicaid restored PPSE's contract after Thompson ruled against Bentley last month."

Nicky Woolf of the Guardian: "Officials have filed charges today against four men accused of shooting into a crowd of protesters in Minneapolis a week ago. Protests have been ongoing outside the precinct building since police shot Jamar Clark, an unarmed black man, just a few hundred yards down the road on 15 November. He died in hospital a day later." (Also linked yesterday.) ...

... Sarah Kaplan of the Washington Post: "Allen 'Lance' Scarsella, the man charged with shooting five people at a Black Lives Matter demonstration in Minneapolis last week," has been identified as an adherent to the "sovereign citizens" philosophy, "a strange subculture united by little more than anti-government ideology and a sense of desperation.... According to the criminal complaint, Scarsella, who is white, spoke derogatorily about African Americans and stored racist images on his cellphone."

This is my only warning. At 10 a.m. on Monday mourning (sic) I am going to the campus quad of the University of Chicago. I will be armed with a M-4 Carbine and 2 Desert Eagles all fully loaded. I will execute aproximately (sic) 16 white male students and or staff, which is the same number of time (sic) Mcdonald (sic) was killed. I then will die killing any number of white policemen that I can in the process. This is not a joke. I am to do my part to rid the world of the white devils. I expect you to do the same. -- Jabari Dean, online posting (allegedly) ...

... Michael Pearson & Dana Ford of CNN: "A 21-year-old man was arrested Monday, accused of threatening to kill students and staff at the University of Chicago in an apparent attempt to avenge the death of Laquan McDonald, authorities said. Jabari Dean, 21 was arrested without incident. He is expected to appear in court later in the day."

Lately There Seem to be Quite a Number of Cop Stories Like The One. ...

... Denver Post, Nov. 9: "Commerce City[, Colorado] police have issued a Blue Alert as they search for the man who shot an officer in the torso Sunday.... The officer's ballistic vest stopped the bullet, and he is being treated for injuries that are not life-threatening." ...

... Denver Post, Nov. 30: "A Commerce City police officer was formally charged Monday with falsely accusing a non-existent motorist of shooting him."

Way Beyond

Ellen Nakashima of the Washington Post: "The Chinese military scaled back its cybertheft of American commercial secrets in the wake of Justice Department indictments of five officers, and the surprising drawdown shows that the law enforcement action had a more significant impact than is commonly assumed, current and former U.S. officials said.

News Lede

Washington Post: "A former wife of the Islamic State's leader was released Tuesday after more than year in custody in Lebanon as part of a prisoner swap involving Lebanese security forces held captive by militants in Syria. Lebanese authorities handed over Saja al-Dulaimi, an Iraqi who was briefly married to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, the presumed head of the Islamic State. Along with Dulaimi was a group of mostly Islamist detainees, according to officials in Lebanon's military."

The Commentariat -- Nov. 30, 2015

Internal links removed.

Afternoon Update:

Gardiner Harris of the New York Times: "President Obama told world leaders who gathered northeast of Paris on Monday for a climate conference that the United States is at least partly to blame for the life-threatening damage that environmental change has wrought, and he urged world leaders to join him in fixing the problem.... Mr. Obama also repeated an argument, lampooned by some Republicans, that the climate conference was a fitting response to the terrorist attacks that cost the lives of 130 people in and around Paris on Nov. 13. 'What greater rejection of those who would tear down our world than marshaling our best efforts to save it,' he said." CW: Can hardly wait for the GOP response to Obama's admitting U.S. culpability on climate change: "Weak!" "Hates America!" _______Fill in______

... The Times has a running commentary on the Paris talks.

Keith Bradsher of the New York Times: "The International Monetary Fund on Monday designated the Chinese renminbi as one of the world's elite currencies, a major milestone that underscores the country's rising financial and economic heft. The decision will help pave the way for broader use of the renminbi in trade and finance, securing China's standing as a global economic power. Just four other currencies -- the dollar, the euro, the pound and the yen -- have the I.M.F. designation."

Alan Rappeport of the New York Times: "Senator Bernie Sanders stepped off the campaign trail on Monday to have a procedure to repair a hernia. Mr. Sanders, the independent from Vermont and Democratic presidential candidate, had an outpatient procedure at George Washington University Hospital and was expected return to his Senate duties on Tuesday."

Maggie Haberman & John Corrales of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump met privately on Monday with black pastors and religious figures at Trump Tower in Manhattan, where he was expected to hold preliminary discussions to seek their endorsements." See links to related news under Presidential Race below.

Nicky Woolf of the Guardian: "Officials have filed charges today against four men accused of shooting into a crowd of protesters in Minneapolis a week ago. Protests have been ongoing outside the precinct building since police shot Jamar Clark, an unarmed black man, just a few hundred yards down the road on 15 November. He died in hospital a day later."

*****

Maria St. Louis-Sanchez & Michelle Karas of the Colorado Springs Gazette: "Family members have confirmed to the Gazette's news partner KKTV that a man named Ke'Arre Stewart was one of the victims killed in Friday's Planned Parenthood shooting. On Facebook his sister, Leyonte Chandler, wrote that Stewart was an Army veteran who served a tour in Iraq. He leaves behind two young daughters." ...

... Jakob Rodgers of the Gazette: "Another civilian victim killed Friday in the attack at a Planned Parenthood clinic in west Colorado Springs has been identified as Jennifer Markovsky of Colorado Springs, her father confirmed to The Gazette. Markovsky was married and had a son and a daughter, said John Ah-King, Markovsky's father in a telephone conversation from his home in Honolulu, Hi." CW: Probably just a coincidence that both victims are racial minorities. ...

... Ashley Southall of the New York Times: "The governor of Colorado [John Hickenlooper (D)], where a gunman killed three people and wounded nine others in a rampage at a Planned Parenthood clinic last week, called the shooting a 'form of terrorism' on Sunday and said that the country needed to ask why such shootings were happening so frequently.... 'I think as a state, but as a country, we have got a lot more thinking about this,' Mr. Hickenlooper said, 'of how to make sure we keep guns out of the hands of people that are unstable.' Colorado has been the site of two other mass shootings.... Several other guests on Sunday talk shows called the shootings domestic terrorism, including Mike Huckabee...; the mayor of Colorado Springs; and the head of Planned Parenthood of the Rocky Mountains. Many, including Mr. Hickenlooper, also suggested that it was time to begin discussing how to tone down rhetoric that 'is inflaming people to the point where they can't stand it, and they go out and they lose connection with reality in some way and commit these acts of unthinkable violence.'" ...

This is so typical of the left to immediately begin demonizing a messenger because they don't agree with the message. The vast majority of Americans agree what Planned Parenthood is doing is wrong. -- Carly Fiorina ...

... Sandhya Somashekhar of the Washington Post: "During his arrest, Dear referred to 'baby parts,' a law enforcement official said. Abortion rights advocates say the connection is clear. Over the summer, a little-known antiabortion group called the Center for Medical Progress released a series of covertly filmed videos purporting to show that Planned Parenthood illegally sells fetal tissue, or 'baby parts,' as abortion foes refer to it, for research.... State and congressional investigations have so far failed to produce proof supporting the allegations.... On 'Fox News Sunday'..., Carly Fiorina [said,] 'nothing justifies this.' In the past, she has accused Planned Parenthood of 'butchering babies for body parts.'... 'Politicians need to stop escalating the rhetoric against Planned Parenthood, and that means by and large the Republican Party," said Laura Chapin, a pro-abortion rights ... consultant and former press secretary to former Colorado governor Bill Ritter (D). 'Right-wing politicians need to back off.'" CW: Thanks for the she-said/she-said report, WashPo! ...

... Still, we might want to give Jackie Calmes of the New York Times First Prize in Both-Siderism: "Congressional supporters and opponents of Planned Parenthood were uncharacteristically subdued over the weekend." And so forth. "On Saturday, one Democrat, Senator Barbara Boxer of California, called on Mr. Ryan to disband the special House committee investigating Planned Parenthood. 'It is time to stop the demonizing and witch hunts against Planned Parenthood, its staff and patients, and the lifesaving health care it provides to millions every day,' she said." Cue Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.), chair of the "Select Investigative Panel on Infant Lives": Boxer "should stop 'playing politics with this tragedy.'" You have to read Calmes' report with a fine-toothed-comb & a commitment to Planned Parenthood to find any suggestion -- other than the organizations own denials -- that Planned Parenthood is not guilty of "selling baby parts for profit." ...

     ... Calmes does manage to illustrate why Foxbots & their ilk are ready to kill anyone associated with Planned Parenthood: "Representative Trey Gowdy ... on Fox News in July said the videos showed Planned Parenthood to be 'barbaric,' 'depraved' and 'right on the precipice of discussing homicide.'"

... Sabrina Siddiqui of the Guardian: "... Donald Trump said the shooting was 'terrible' but focused on the mental state of the alleged gunman. Ben Carson deplored the killings but said, when asked if the attack was a form of domestic terrorism, as a Planned Parenthood official has claimed, 'there is no saint in this equation'." CW: That is, Planned Parenthood is partially (or equally?) at fault. ...

... Karen Tumulty of the Washington Post: "The Republican presidential field, which for much of the year has been full-throated in its denunciations of Planned Parenthood, has been nearly silent about the shooting in Colorado at one of its facilities that left a police officer and two others dead.... It was suspected, according to a law enforcement official, that heated rhetoric surrounding the issue of abortion influenced Dear's actions.... Many Republicans have also accused Planned Parenthood of selling such tissue, which would be illegal and which the organization vehemently denies.... Republican [Sen.] Cory Gardner [Colorado] -- who defeated incumbent Mark Udall last year in an election that Democrats tried to make a referendum on reproductive rights -- issued a statement Saturday night that did not mention the site of the killings." (Published prior to airing of the Sunday showz.) ...

... Patrick Svitek of the Texas Tribune: Ted "Cruz rejected a potential connection between anti-abortion activism and the shooting, instead taking issue with 'some vicious rhetoric on the left blaming those who are pro-life.'... When a reporter reminded Cruz it has been reported Dear made a comment about 'baby parts' while being apprehended, Cruz retorted, 'It's also been reported that he was registered as an independent and a woman and a transgendered leftist activist. If that's what he is, I don't think it's fair to blame on the rhetoric on the left. This is a murderer.'"

... Steve M.: "There was an ever-thinning line between the GOP and the lunatic fringe, and Ted Cruz just erased it." ...

... Steve has a nice catch, too, on how Fox "News" is covering the "no more body parts" remark by the (alleged) killer. Instead of attributing the leaked quote to officials, their headline is "Planned Parenthood Official Claims Colo. Gunman Opposed Abortion." Way down in the story, Foxbots who read that far will find that an official relayed to media that Dear had made the "no more body parts statement." More careless readers, quite naturally, will assume that Planned Parenthood is offering up an unfounded opinion.

Joe Davidson of the Washington Post: "The Obama administration is preparing an executive order designed to bolster the government's Senior Executive Service (SES) with increased compensation, a streamlined hiring process and greater diversity in assignments."

Curt Stager in a New York Times op-ed: "Roughly one-eighth of the carbon in your flesh, hair and bones recently emerged from smokestacks and tailpipes. We are not only a source of air pollution -- we are air pollution, and our waste fumes will henceforth be woven into the bodies of our descendants, too.... By running our civilization on fossil fuels, we are both creating and destroying climates that our descendants will live in tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of years from now."

Paul Krugman: "... in this age of [urban] gentrification, housing policy has become much more important than most people realize.... New York City can't do much if anything about soaring inequality of incomes, but it could do a lot to increase the supply of housing, and thereby ensure that the inward migration of the elite doesn't drive out everyone else."

Presidential Race

Abby Phillip of the Washington Post: "To unionized workers, Boston Mayor Marty Walsh is one of their own. And so his endorsement of ... Hillary Clinton on Sunday at a rally in his city's historic Faneuil Hall served as a call to action for union members nationwide who are the foot soldiers of the Democratic Party.

Ben Schreckinger of Politico: "After prematurely announcing the endorsements of 100 black pastors -- prompting several to protest they were not, in fact, supporters -- Donald Trump's campaign abruptly cancelled a press conference with the group scheduled for Monday afternoon at Trump Tower.... Some of those listed as invitees quickly took to social media to condemn the billionaire businessman. Detroit pastor Corletta Vaughn called Trump 'an insult and embarrassment' in a Wednesday Facebook post. On Friday, Los Angeles-based Bishop Clarence McClendon announced that he would not attend the meeting, writing on Facebook, 'The meeting was presented not as a meeting to endorse but as a meeting to engage in dialogue.'" ...

... Reuters: "Donald Trump insisted on Sunday he was '100% right' when he said he saw Muslims in Jersey City, New Jersey, cheering the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center -- even though fact-checkers have debunked his claim.... He quickly rejected NBC anchor Chuck Todd's assertion that 'this didn't happen in New Jersey'. 'It did happen in New Jersey,' Trump said. 'I have hundreds of people that agree with me.'" ...

... Bradford Richardson of the Hill: "Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) said Donald Trump's divisive rhetoric is only serving to turn the international Muslim community against the U.S. 'Oh, I think it has an interesting effect of turning Muslims all over the world against the United States of America, which is 99.44 percent people who practice an honorable religion,' the Arizona senator said of Trump on CBS's 'Face the Nation' on Sunday."

A Nice Place to Visit.... Sabrina Siddiqui: "After spending Thanksgiving weekend visiting refugees in Jordan, Ben Carson called on the US to support Syrians displaced by the war there, where he said facilities in the camps were 'really quite nice', rather than bring them to America." CW: I wonder how much Doc Ben would enjoy living there, what with their being few walls to on which to hang his plaques & Jesus-Loves-Ben pictures. ...

AP photo, September 2015.

... Omar Akour & Steve Peoples of the AP: "'I did not detect any great desire for them to come to the United States,' Carson told The Associated Press in a phone interview from Jordan. 'You've got these refugee camps that aren't completely full. And all you need is the resources to be able to run them. Why do you need to create something else?'"

Martin Pengelly of the Guardian (via the Raw Story): "Jeb Bush would support Donald Trump if the real-estate billionaire were to win the Republican presidential nomination, 'because anybody is better than Hillary Clinton'."

Beyond the Beltway

Mitch Smith of the New York Times: "Lawyers for the family of Tamir Rice, the 12-year-old boy fatally shot last year by the Cleveland police, have presented Ohio prosecutors with two outside reports that call an officer's decision to shoot the boy 'unreasonable.' The reports, made public on Saturday night, are at odds with three previous investigations commissioned by the prosecutor's office that labeled the shooting as tragic but reasonable. Grand jurors are expected to consider all those reports in deciding whether the police should face criminal charges."

Way Beyond

Karia Adam of the Washington Post: "... tens of thousands of people worldwide hit the streets [of London, England,] this weekend for a global climate march, pressing world leaders to push for a bold international agreement at the upcoming climate summit in Paris. The center for the demonstrations was supposed to be Paris, where nearly 150 world leaders are gathering for a U.N. global summit on climate change that kicks off Monday. But after the terrorist attacks there more than two weeks ago that killed at least 130 people, French police banned large protests.... On Sunday, they sought to enforce that ban, firing tear gas in the afternoon on an unauthorized gathering at Place de la Republique, a focal point for protests, and detaining about 100 people."

James Kanter & Andrew Higgins of the New York Times: "Under heavy pressure from Germany to get a grip on the migrant crisis in the Continent after months of dithering, the European Union agreed to a deal on Sunday with Turkey that aims to slow the chaotic flood of asylum seekers into the 28-nation bloc. Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany, speaking to reporters late Sunday, acknowledged that the agreement, under which Europe will provide 3 billion euros, about $3.2 billion, and other inducements in return for Turkish help on migrants, would not immediately halt the flow of asylum seekers from the Middle East and elsewhere. But Ms. Merkel said it would help 'keep people in the region' and out of Europe."

David Kirkpatrick, et al., of the New York Times: "When the Libyan arm of the Islamic State first raised the group's black flag over the coastal city of Surt[, Libya,] almost one year ago, it was just a bunch of local militants trying to look tough. Today Surt is an actively managed colony of the central Islamic State, crowded with foreign fighters from around the region, according to residents, local militia leaders and hostages recently released from the city's main prison."

The Commentariat -- Nov. 29, 2015

Internal links removed.

CW: My postings will probably be rather sketchy over the next couple of days, but I'm hoping to be back in the saddle by early Tuesday.

Kyle Balluck of the Hill: "Colorado Springs, Colo., Mayor John Suthers said in an interview Sunday [on ABC's 'This Week'] that the fatal shooting spree at a Planned Parenthood clinic in his town appears to be an act of domestic terrorism." CW: That's a fairly gutsy admission for a Republican. (Suthers is a former Colorado attorney general & U.S. attorney who headed up the state's anti-terrorism unit after 9/11.) Maybe he didn't get the memo that he was just supposed to talk about the guy's mental illness & too bad the Planned Parenthood ladies weren't all armed with pretty pearl-handled pistols to shoot the killer. ...

... Alleged Colorado Gunman Cites Republican Talking Points,
Sources Say ...

... ** Pete Williams & Andrew Blankstein of NBC News: "In one statement, made after the suspect was taken in for questioning, Dear said 'no more baby parts' in reference to Planned Parenthood, two law enforcement sources with knowledge of the case told NBC News. But the sources stressed that Dear said many things to law enforcement and the extent to which the 'baby parts' remark played into any decision to target the Planned Parenthood office was not yet clear. He also mentioned President Barack Obama in statements." CW: (A neighbor of Dear's has said, according to several reports, Dear approached him with anti-Obama literature. CW: What we need now is for national news outlets to print headlines like the one above. But of course they won't. ...

... AP: "Attorney General Loretta Lynch is calling the shootings in Colorado Springs a crime against women receiving health care services at Planned Parenthood." ...

... ** Valerie Tarico: "On November 27, a mass shooting left three dead and nine wounded at a Planned Parenthood clinic just miles from the headquarters of the Religious Right flagship, Focus on the Family. Was the shooting exactly what conservative Christian presidential candidates and members of congress wanted? Maybe, maybe not. But it is what they asked for. Republican members of the Religious Right incited violence as predictably as if they had issued a call for Christian abortion foes to take up arms. Inciting violence this way is called stochastic terrorism: 'Stochastic terrorism is the use of mass communications to incite random actors to carry out violent or terrorist acts that are statistically predictable but individually unpredictable. In short, remote-control murder by lone wolf.'” Thanks to asa watcher for the link. Also see commentary in yesterday's Comments thread. ...

... The Ultimate Inequality. Peter Holley of the Washington Post: Another white (alleged) murderer emerges alive after a shootout with police, while police gun down innocent black people like 12-year-old Tamir Rice & John Crawford III (shot by police in a WalMart while not pointing a toy gun at anybody). ...

... Emily Atkin of Think Progress: "Approximately 10 hours after a gunman went on a shooting rampage at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado Springs, Colorado, only two presidential candidates have issued statements expressing support for either the three victims or the women’s health organization. Of the 17 candidates, only former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) have put out public statements in response to the massacre, which lasted approximately five hours and resulted in the deaths of one police officer and two civilians." Meanwhile, at 8 pm ET Friday, hours into the siege, Marco Rubio sent a tweet that read, "Stay warm this winter with our new cold-weather bundle. Shop now and save!"In an update, Atkin notes that Ted Cruz sent out a "prayers" tweet Saturday morning. Meanwhile, at 8 pm ET, Marco Rubio sent a tweet that reads, "Stay warm this winter with our new cold-weather bundle. Shop now and save!" ...

... Yeah BUT, at least one Republican spoke out. Daniel Politi of Slate: "While police officers were still engaging with the shooter at the Planned Parenthood in Colorado Springs on Friday, one Republican lawmaker apparently thought the best thing to do was criticize the organization during an interview on CNN. 'We saw these barbaric videos, and that was something that many of us have a legitimate concern about,' Rep. Adam Kinzinger [Illinois] said. He was, of course, referring to the widely discredited videos that claim to show Planned Parenthood executives profiting from harvesting fetal tissue. Kinzinger also criticized Planned Parenthood for issuing a statement on the incident that broadly criticized 'extremists' and 'a poisonous environment that feeds domestic terrorism.'" He also demanded an apology from Planned Parenthood if it turned out the shooter was not targeting the organization. "Many were quick to blast not only Kinzinger but also CNN for inviting a known Planned Parenthood critic while police were still trying to apprehend the gunman." ...

... Kevin Sullivan, et al., of the Washington Post: Robert Lewis "Dear, 57, the man in custody in connection with Friday’s shooting at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado Springs, appears to have been a malcontent who drifted from place to place. In the past couple of years, in addition to [a] shack [in Black Mountain, North Carolina], he also lived in a mobile home in another town in North Carolina and a camper in Colorado, which he shared with a woman who moved with him from the East Coast.... He had a history of run-ins with neighbors and police, including arrests for cruelty to animals and being a 'peeping Tom.' He was not convicted in either case." ...

... Kevin Mitchell of the Denver Post has more on Dear's background. The New York Times story, by Julie Turkewitz & Benjamin Mueller, is here. The Times story also has reactions from residents who were in the vicinity of the shooting & stand-off. ...

... Josiah Hesse & Martin Pengelly of the Guardian: "On Saturday, Colorado Springs mayor John Suthers told reporters authorities were not ready to discuss a possible motive for the shooting, but said people could make 'inferences from where it took place'.” ...

... The Colorado Springs Gazette: "Robert Lewis Dear ... is in jail on a no-bond hold. Dear’s first court appearance scheduled for Monday at 1:30...."

Coral Davenport of the New York Times: "... on Sunday night [President Obama] arrives in Paris, hoping to make climate policy the signature environmental achievement of his, and perhaps any, presidency.... In Paris, Mr. Obama will join more than 120 world leaders to kick off two weeks of negotiations aimed at forging a new climate change accord that would, for the first time, commit almost every country on Earth to lowering its greenhouse gas pollution. All year, Mr. Obama’s negotiators have worked behind the scenes to fashion a Paris deal.... During the course of the Paris talks, Republicans in Congress are planning a series of votes to fight Mr. Obama’s climate agenda. More than half the states are suing the administration on the legality of his climate plan. And all the Republican presidential candidates have said that they would undo the regulations if elected."

Katie Williams of the Hill: "President Obama and his daughters on Saturday visited an independent Washington bookstore as the first family marked Small Business Saturday...."

Presidential Race

Abby Phillip of the Washington Post: "Hillary Clinton will unveil the largest plank of her economic agenda in the coming weeks, proposing hundreds of billions of dollars in spending, primarily on infrastructure projects, according to campaign aides."

Politico: "New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie's campaign for the Republican nomination gained some traction late Saturday with an endorsement from New Hampshire's Union Leader, traditionally the most respected newspaper voice in the first-in-the-nation primary state.... The Union Leader endorsed Newt Gingrich in 2012, and John McCain in 2008."

The New, "Diplomatic Donald." Reuters: "... Donald Trump on Saturday reframed his claim that he saw Muslims in Jersey City, New Jersey, cheering the attacks on the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center in Manhattan on Sept. 11, 2001 by asserting the sentiment was shared worldwide. 'Worldwide, the Muslims were absolutely going wild,' the real estate mogul said at a campaign rally in Sarasota, Florida.... 'I would never mock a person that has a disability,' Trump told the cheering crowd.... [He] urged his audience to be polite to a heckler who briefly brought the Sarasota event to a halt. 'Be nice to the person. Don’t hurt the person,' he instructed the crowd, which cheered him loudly when he told security personnel to escort the heckler from the room. 'Do you see how diplomatic I’ve become?'... In the past five days, he dropped 12 points from 43 percent to 31 percent [in a Reuters/Ipsos], although he continues to hold a wide lead over his competitors.”

CarsonCare! Doc Ben's Excellent Plan. Isaac Arnsdorf & Kyle Cheney of Politico: "Long before he considered a presidential bid..., [Ben Carson] envisioned building [a charity] into an endowment that would generate enough interest income to cover uninsured patients expenses for neurological surgeries and other medical costs. He even pitched the idea to a congressional subcommittee in 2006.... But ... the national fund did not materialize, and over nine years of operation, Angels of the OR [Operating Room] generated less than $150,000 for patient care.... Angels of the OR spent $1.03 million during its life span, and at least 53 percent of its funds went to salaries and fundraising costs, according to Politico’s review of its records.... Experts in nonprofit management ... said Angels of the OR never developed a sound business plan and spent much of its early income on fundraising and personnel rather than patients." CW: So another Ben Carson scam.

Beyond the Beltway

Nicholas Confessore of the New York Times: "... a small group of rich [people] — not just from Chicago, but also from New York City and Los Angeles, southern Florida and Texas — have poured tens of millions of dollars into the state [of Illinois], a concentration of political money without precedent in Illinois history. Their wealth has forcefully shifted the state’s balance of power. Last year, the families helped elect as governor Bruce Rauner..., who estimates his own fortune at more than $500 million. Now they are rallying behind Mr. Rauner’s agenda: to cut spending and overhaul the state’s pension system, impose term limits and weaken public employee unions.... The families remaking Illinois are among a small group around the country who have channeled their extraordinary wealth into political power, taking advantage of regulatory, legal and cultural shifts that have carved new paths for infusing money into campaigns. Economic winners in an age of rising inequality, operating largely out of public view, they are reshaping government with fortunes so large as to defy the ordinary financial scale of politics."