The Commentariat -- Sept. 20, 2015

Internal links removed.

** "The Black Family in the Age of Mass Incarceration." Ta-Nehisi Coates writes the Atlantic's cover story: "American politicians are now eager to disown a failed criminal-justice system that's left the U.S. with the largest incarcerated population in the world. But they've failed to reckon with history. Fifty years after Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s report 'The Negro Family' tragically helped create this system, it's time to reclaim his original intent." ...

... CW: One thing Coates doesn't mention in this long & worthy essay is a peculiar lack of impact incarcertation has on the black community. That is, if incarceration becomes so common that every family has a son or nephew or brother in jail -- as is currently the case -- there is no shame to it. Yes, there are all the downsides Coates enumerates, but there is little or no social ostracism or embarrassment associated with incarceration. And why would there be? As Li'l Randy pointed out in the GOP debate (in one of its few high points), when Jeb! smoked weed, there were no consequences. And you can bet if Jeb! was dealing to his posh friends (and I have no reason to think he was), the consequences would have been minimal, too. Not so for a black kid living in an impoverished area. When a white guy tells me he's been in jail, I assume he did something bad. When a black man tells me he's served time, I figure there's about a 50-50 chance he did something bad, & I give him the benefit of the doubt. (I heard these admissions dozens of times when I was registering voters in Florida in 2008.) ...

... David Margolick, in the New York Times Book Review, pans Wil Haygood's book Showdown, about the appointment of Thurgood Marshall to the Supreme Court. I would give Margolick's review a good review, however, as it's quite informative.

David Sanger of the New York Times: "The United States and China are negotiating what could become the first arms control accord for cyberspace, embracing a commitment by each country that it will not be the first to use cyberweapons to cripple the other's critical infrastructure during peacetime, according to officials involved in the talks." ...

... CW: Sen. Tom Cotton (RTP-Ark.) immediately dashed off an open note to China's President Xi Jinping telling him he needed to understand that in our constitutional system, the POTUS is essentially powerless, so any so-called agreement his government might reach with the Obama administration is not worth the rice paper it's written on. Cotton told reporters it was a snap to write his missive to Xi. "I just changed the name of the addressee in the letter I wrote to the Iranian ayatollahs. International diplomacy is much easier than you might think."

Mimi Whitefield, et al., of the Miami Herald: "Pope Francis began his historic trip to Cuba with a message of solidarity and reconciliation. After his flight from Rome touched down Saturday afternoon at Jose Martí International Airport in Havana, the pontiff greeted the Cuban people by noting that this year marks the 80th anniversary of establishing diplomatic ties between Cuba and the Holy See." ...

... Jim Yardley, et al., of the New York Times: "... as he arrived in Havana on Saturday, the first stop of a nine-day papal trip to Cuba and the United States, Francis faced a new challenge altogether: Having helped open up Cuba to the world, the first Latin American pope must now try to fully open up Cuba to the Roman Catholic Church.... Francis was greeted at the airport by President Raúl Castro and children who welcomed him with flowers."

Presidential Race

Mario Trujillo of the Hill: "Democratic National Committee Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz repeatedly attempted on Saturday to quiet an audience of 4,000 in New Hampshire who called for more Democratic primary debates. During her opening speech at the New Hampshire Democratic Party Convention, she interrupted her prepared remarks on at least two occasions to address chants of 'more debates' and 'we want debates.'... C-SPAN cameras broadcasting live panned to audience members holding posters that called for more that half a dozen debates in the 2016 presidential primary."

Jordan Fabian of the Hill: "President Obama is throwing more punches at the Republicans vying to take his place in the White House as the 2016 campaign enters a busy fall. Obama this week went after GOP front-runner Donald Trump, as did Vice President Biden, who is considering his own presidential bid.... A White House official said there are not yet any major strategic discussions underway about Obama's role in the 2016 campaign. But the aide also expects the president to defend his record against GOP attacks and boost the Democratic nominee."

Kyle Cheney of Politico: "Vice President Joe Biden's last-minute decision to score some facetime with powerful black leaders may do little to shake their strong inclination toward Hillary Clinton. But among the rank-and-file attendees at Saturday's prayer breakfast hosted by the Congressional Black Caucus Foundation, the Democratic primary is still a wide open fight. Biden earned several warm ovations from the admiring crowd, and he held court for 20 minutes while breakfast was served, posing for selfies with dozens of fans and turning on his classic, toothy charm as he clasped hands with well-wishers and slapped the backs of strangers angling to get close to him." ...

... Matthew Speiser of Business Insider: "Vice President Joe Biden's aides have begun suggesting to donors that he's more inclined to run for president than not, The Wall Street Journal reports, citing anonymous sources familiar with the matter. The aides say their talks have shifted largely from whether he's going to run to when he's going to announce, sources told the Journal, noting that he could still change his mind if his grief over his recent son's death becomes overwhelming."

Bernie Sanders appeared on Stephen Colbert's show Friday night. You can watch a clip here. The entire segment is here, beginning about 25 min. in. You'll have to watch quite a few capitalist commercials before the segment begins. ...

... Missed this, which aired Sept. 16:

Worse Than Trump. Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: "GOP presidential candidate Ben Carson says in an interview airing Sunday that he doesn't believe the United States should have a Muslim president because Islam is inconsistent with the Constitution."

Muchas Gracias, Don Donaldo. Eliza Collins of Politico: "Hispanic activists have two words for Donald Trump -- thank you.... While many activists find his comments downright offensive, they also see an opportunity. Trump has managed to get Latinos engaged with the 2016 race, and activists plan to exploit that to the fullest extent possible.

Am I morally obligated to defend the president every time somebody says something bad or controversial about him? I don't think so! -- Donald Trump tweet, Saturday, in response to across-the-board criticism of his response to a man who said President Obama was a Muslim & "not an American," then asked how we could "get rid of" Muslims in this country

... Update. Trump Discovers First Amendment Prohibits Disagreement with Others. Trip Gabriel of the New York Times: "In front of several hundred evangelical Christians on Saturday, Donald J. Trump took a dig at Senator John McCain for a well-known incident in which Mr. McCain took away a microphone from a woman to correct her after she said that Barack Obama was an Arab.... He told the Iowa crowd that if he had ... corrected the man..., he would have been attacked for violating the man's right to free speech." ...

... How is Donald Trump like George W. Bush? Neither one can think of any mistakes he's made. ...

... Update. M. J. Lee & Noah Gray of CNN: "Donald Trump on Saturday responded to a question from CNN about whether Muslims pose a danger to the country, saying: 'I love the Muslims. I think they're great people.'... During a question-and-answer session with students..., one student ... asked whether the billionaire businessman would consider putting a Muslim in his Cabinet or on his ticket. 'Oh, absolutely,' Trump responded. 'No problem with that.'"

How to Lose Wacko AND Sane Voters. Sean Sullivan of the Washington Post: "Jeb Bush responded Friday night to Donald Trump's decision this week not to correct a questioner who said President Obama is a Muslim who is 'not even an American.' 'Barack Obama is a talented man -- and by the way he's an American, he's a Christian -- his problem isn't the fact that he was born here or what his faith is,' said Bush in a speech here. 'His problem is that he's a progressive liberal who tears down anybody that disagrees with him.'" ...

     ... CW: Meanwhile, it's okay for Jeb! to claim President Obama is "incompetent," a failed leader, has created "chaos" in the world, lost the Iraq War that Dubya won, capitulated to Iran, threatened Israel's security, enabling ISIS, causing Washington gridlock, etc. etc., and also too uses too many "big-syllable words." See, that's not "tearing down" Obama; it's just stating facts.

... Do as I Say, Not as I Do. Eli Stokols of Politico: "Jeb Bush ... vowed in his first policy speech as a presidential candidate last June to halt the 'revolving door' between Congress and K Street.... But the promise was undercut both by the audience to which Bush spoke -- which included numerous lobbyists from his days as governor -- and by the intensity with which Bush replenished his personal bank accounts upon leaving office by cashing in on the connections he had made.... After two terms as governor, Bush left office in 2007 with a net worth of just $1.3 million -- but within seven years, according to a Politico analysis of his financial disclosure forms, he had built it up to $24.89 million. His new wealth was driven by income from consulting work and a dozen board seats on the firms of people with significant business interests before the state while he was governor -- including more than $12 million from firms that earned millions in fees when Bush redirected $350 million of Florida public workers' retirement funds into venture capital investments run by major donors to his brother and his campaigns." ...

... All My Delusions. Chas Danner of New York: "In a speech kicking off the Mackinac Republican Leadership Conference, Jeb first criticized Hillary Clinton's foreign policy record, asking the crowd to 'name a country in the world where our relationship is better today than the day that Hillary of Clinton became secretary of state.' He then claimed that he would be able to lead a stronger foreign policy for the nation, and that 'I know how to do this because, yes, I am a Bush. I happened to see two really good presidents develop relationships with other countries.'"

Andrew Prokop of Vox: "Over the last few weeks, the news for Scott Walker's presidential campaign has been getting grimmer and grimmer..... Word of money problems often serves as the canary in the coal mine -- signifying an imminent campaign collapse.... If Walker already isn't paying his consultants, fundraising has likely fallen well short of expectations, and the campaign has committed to much more spending than it can afford.... In person, Scott Walker simply isn't compelling or attention-grabbing. I argued nearly a year ago that Walker's lack of charisma would be his biggest problem 'in a world where primary candidates rise and fall in the polls based partly on their performance in televised debates.'" ...

... CW: It isn't so much his lack of "charisma," but his lack of intelligence & competence that defeated Scott Walker. Voters may or may not want a president they'd like to have a beer with, but they'd like one who doesn't take three days to come up with three different answers to a simple yes-or-no question, then deny he ever gave the first two answers. How Walker ever succeeded in Wisconsin, I'll never know, because besides being dumb & incompetent, he's a nasty piece of work.

Beyond the Beltway

Adam Beam of the AP: "In a court filing Friday, the attorney for one of [Kim] Davis' employees said he believes Davis has again violated a federal court order by altering marriage license forms.... In a separate court filing on Friday, attorneys for the gay couples who sued Davis appear to agree and say they are 'exploring legal options.'... When she returned to work, Davis altered the marriage forms by removing her name, making deputy clerk Brian Mason initial the form instead of sign it, and then requiring the form to be notarized.... Mason's attorney, Richard Hughes, told The Associated Press on Friday after filing a status report with the judge ... it was 'really bizarre' that Davis would alter the forms. 'Unless she's got a really good reason, and I'll certainly be patient and wait to hear it, the only inference I personally can draw from it is she is trying to circumvent the court's order,' he said.... Also Friday, the attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union said in a court filing that the changes on the form require Mason to issue the licenses 'in his capacity as a "notary public" rather than a deputy clerk of the Rowan County Clerk's Office,' changes that 'do not comply' with the court's order to not interfere with her employees who issue the licenses."

Post Script. It Was a Hoax! Anthony, in ArtVoice, takes a close look at young Ahmed Mohamed's clock & discovers that "Ahmed Mohamed didn't invent his own alarm clock. He didn't even build a clock." Instead, he took apart an old Radio Shack clock & put it in a pencil box. ...

     ... CW: I didn't link to this story when I first read about it because I thought it was much ado about nothing. Then the President, Hillary Clinton & others weighed in, & I felt obligated to cover it. Now we're back to my original take: it's much ado about nothing. Even I could take the clockworks out of a 1980s fake-woodgrain box & insert it in a cooler-looking pencil box. (I actually did something similar last week. I have not been arrested & the President has not invited me to his place.) I think Ahmed has talent, but at this point his talent is artistic, not technological.

Way Beyond

Sewell Chan & Palko Karasz of the New York Times: "Thousands of migrants poured into Austria on Saturday after being bounced around countries overwhelmed by their arrival and insistent that they keep moving. Hungary -- which had taken the most draconian and visible measures to turn back the exodus, notably the construction of a razor-wire fence along its border with Serbia -- partly caved Friday evening. It grudgingly allowed at least 11,000 migrants to enter from Croatia, and then sent them by bus and train to processing centers along its border with Austria."

Addendum:

D. C. Clark reckons this clip is essential to today's Comments discussion:

News Ledes

New York Daily News: "A senior White House advisor was struck and killed by a car when he lost control of his bicycle while participating in a charity bike ride raising money for cancer. Jacob Thomas Brewer, 34, was entering a sharp bend in Mt. Airy, Md., when the married father and senior policy advisor crossed into an oncoming car's lane late Saturday afternoon, Howard County police said." ...

... Hill: "President Obama on Sunday mourned the loss of a top White House staffer who was killed in a bicycle crash."

The Commentariat -- Sept. 19, 2015

Internal links removed.

Michael Gordon & Eric Schmitt of the New York Times: "As the first Russian combat aircraft arrived in Syria, the Obama administration reached out to Moscow on Friday to try to coordinate actions in the war zone and avoid an accidental escalation of one of the world's most volatile conflicts. The diplomatic initiative amounted to a pivot for the Obama administration, which just two weeks ago delivered a stern warning to the Kremlin that its military buildup in Syria risked an escalation of the civil war there or even an inadvertent confrontation with the United States. Last week, President Obama condemned Russia's move as a 'strategy that's doomed to failure.'" CW: I was thinking earlier today that the only possibility of a solution to the Syrian crisis would come via an agreement between Russia & Western powers. What that solution might be, however, escapes me as the Syrian population itself is fanatically fractured. ...

... Dan Bilefsky of the New York Times: "As key nations tighten their borders, thousands of migrants and asylum seekers hoping to enter Western Europe are now bottled up in the Balkans, placing precarious new burdens on a region of lingering sectarian divisions that is exceptionally ill prepared to handle the crisis that has been shunted to it. More than 17,000 migrants have entered Croatia since Wednesday, and were essentially trapped there, having been blocked from Hungary, sent packing from Serbia and unable to move on to Slovenia. The migrants have become a sloshing tide of humanity, left to flow wherever the region's conflicting and constantly changing border controls channel them."

Jonathan Soble of the New York Times: "In a middle-of-the night vote that capped a tumultuous struggle with opposition parties in Parliament, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe of Japan secured final passage of legislation on Saturday authorizing overseas combat missions for his country's military, overturning a decades-old policy of reserving the use of force for self-defense." CW: Not a great day for peace.

White House: "In this week's address, the President discussed the significant progress we have made in our economy since the financial crisis seven years ago this week, and the steps we can take to build on that momentum and strengthen the economy for the long term":

Helene Cooper of the New York Times: "President Obama is nominating Eric K. Fanning, a close civilian adviser to Defense Secretary Ashton B. Carter, to be the secretary of the Army, an appointment that would make him the first openly gay secretary of a military branch. Mr. Fanning has been the acting under secretary of the Army as the current secretary, John McHugh, prepares to leave his post." CW: Sooner or later, a person's sexual orientation will not appear in a lede. ...

... Oh, or in the headline, as it appears in the WashPo: "Obama to nominate first openly gay service secretary to lead the Army."

Dan Lamothe of the Washington Post: "The Army general who carried out an investigation last year into the alleged desertion of Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl believes that a jail sentence would be 'inappropriate,' despite the massive search caused by him walking away from his unit's outpost in Afghanistan. Maj. Gen. Kenneth Dahl testified Friday in Bergdahl's case that he found the soldier 'unrealistically idealistic' about other people and remorseful for the massive search his actions caused."

Mike DeBonis of the Washington Post: "The House passed two abortion-related bills Friday, including one that would strip federal health-care funding from Planned Parenthood for one year, but it remains unclear whether the votes would appease conservatives who have threatened a government shutdown over the organization." ...

... Gail Collins on the confederates' fight for unplanned parenthood.

Joe Nocera on the GOP jobs-killing extremists who refuse to allow a vote to reauthorize the U.S. Export-Import Bank "... led by the House Financial Services Committee's chairman, Jeb Hensarling.... The Ex-Im Bank, which insures and sometimes finances export sales, had to stop making deals at the end of June, when its reauthorization deadline came and went."

Coral Davenport & Stewart Ewing of the New York Times: "The Obama administration on Friday directed Volkswagen to recall nearly a half-million cars, saying the automaker illegally installed software in its diesel-power cars to evade standards for reducing smog."

** Wendell Berry, in the Louisville Courier-Journal (Sept.10): "Obama's election has brought about a revival of racism.... The President must be opposed, not on this or that issue, but upon all issues. This opposition is often expressed in tones of contempt, not only of the President himself, but of the office he holds so long as it is held by him.... Elected officials or candidates seeking the support or the votes of racists do not need to question the authenticity of Mr. Obama's birth certificate or to call him a Muslim, a communist, a nazi, or a traitor. They need only to stand silently by while such slurs and falsehoods are loudly voiced in public by others.... Their silence declares that no truth or dignity is worth as much as a vote.... This subtilized racism is not only a perhaps unignorable lure to Republican politicians; it can also be noticeably corrupting to Democrats. In Kentucky, for example..., if the President comes into the state to visit, some Democratic candidates ... become conspicuously busy elsewhere.... The paramount fact of this moment in the history of racism is that you don't have to denominate the President by a recognized racial slur when his very name can be used as a synonym." CW: Many thanks to contributor Janice for bringing Berry's essay to our attention. ...

... CW: I continue to think the virulent opposition to President Obama is about tribalism. Racism, sexism, homophobia, Christianism (all all the other "ism"s are subsets of tribalism. Tribalism itself is a function of individuality, a group affirmation of our own selves. The more people are like me, the better they are. Each of us needs to feel special & laudable, even if we are fairly ordinary. Simply being unique, which each of us is, is not enough. We seek out others who will affirm our superiority. So when a celebrity like Donald Trump says of a completely reprehensible asshole, "I like this guy," as he did of the fellow who wanted to "get rid of" Mooslums -- including Obama -- Trump knew what he was doing. Trump was affirming that jerk's personal excellence. Right now that jerk is at home boasting to his fellow jerks that a prominent presidential candidate is "looking into" ways to deal with the "problems" the civic-minded jerk brought to the fore. The jerk is momentarily special within his own tribe. For Trump, as for the the jerk, mission accomplished. An ideal transaction has occurred, wherein both parties "won." That we as a nation lose every time such a transaction occurs, is immaterial to both of them. ...

... CW BTW: Nobody, including Trump, said a word about the next questioner Trump called on; he described CNN as the "Clinton News Network." Sexism, if just subtle enough, is so common that it does not merit comment. ...

... ** Catherine Thompson of TPM: "White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest on Friday spoke out forcefully against Republican presidential frontrunner Donald Trump's failure to correct a voter who called President Barack Obama a Muslim, turning his criticism into a harsh indictment of Republicans at large":

... Amy Davidson of the New Yorker: "Trump ... went well beyond not defending the President: he affirmed an attack on the millions of Muslim Americans who are as much a part of the national community as anyone else." ...

... Brian Beutler: "There's no sense in giving Trump a pass on this, but it's worth keeping in mind that this isn't a Trump problem. It's ... a Republican politician problem. The Republican interest in Trump's dishonorable conduct is deeply selective.... These outbursts spill over into racist conspiracy theories frequently enough that the politicians really ought to have pat reprimands at the ready.... And Trump isn't even close to the only politician who fails this test...."

... Philip Bump of the Washington Post provides some background on those Islamic "terrorist training camps." CW: I found Bump's report pretty interesting, because for many years I owned a cottage in the same town as the "national headquarters" of Muslim terrorism, & the only times I felt in any sort of danger was when white murderers escaped from local prisons (which they did with some regularity). That is, the scary people around Deposit, New York, look a lot more like that Trump fan than like the Muslim terrorists of his imagination.

... when the Pope chooses to act and talk like a leftist politician, then he can expect to be treated like one. -- Rep. Paul Gosar (RTP), a Roman Catholic

... Mike DeBonis: "Rep. Paul Gosar (R-Ariz.) said in an op-ed published Friday on Townhall.com that he" is boycotting Pope Francis's address to Congress. Because climate change, Islam, persecuted Christians, etc. CW: I'm sure Gosar will be missed. Thanks, Arizona! ...

... CW: It won't matter to Gosar (who asked for & was denied a private audience with the Pope for the purpose of scolding His Holiness & giving him Gosar-vetted talking points), but for the hell-bent infidels who are interested in knowing what Francis will be doing in the U.S., the New York Times has published his general schedule here. ...

... Gosar reminds Hunter of Daily Kos that "... all the elements for the ascension of true fascism are now in place among the top ranks of the American right. The adaptation of pseudo-'Christian' rhetoric to promote movement goals (expansionist interventionism, hyper-nationalism, xenophobia, a focus on 'true' members of the nation versus the undesirable intellectual, political, religious and ethnic 'others') while actual Christian thought is marginalized as "leftist" and even dangerous...." CW: The scariest people in the U.S. are not Mooslums living in the countryside; they are so-called Christians wielding power in Washington, D.C.

Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. Erik Wemple of the Washington Post: In the person of Jeffrey Lord, a former Reagan political operator, CNN has its very own paid Trump supporter. Lord doesn't think Trump should apologize for letting that jerk claim that President Obama was a foreign Muslim until Barack Obama apologizes for not leading his congregation to fire the Rev. Jeremiah Wright. CW: That doesn't even makes sense. But then, why should a Trump supporter make sense? It's not his job. And why should CNN suddenly stop hiring political hacks? That would completely upend their "news" model.

Presidential Race

Lisa Mascaro & Evan Halper of the Los Angeles Times: "Hillary Rodham Clinton's rivals in the Democratic primary have been demanding for weeks that the party hold more presidential debates than the scant six that are planned, and on Friday they got a big boost when House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco said she agrees with them.... When asked about the schedule, Clinton campaign officials have repeatedly said it is not up to them, that it is controlled by the Democratic National Committee. DNC Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz has repeatedly said the issue is closed. But Pelosi's comments put more pressure on the DNC to reopen it."

Washington Post Editors: "Instead of the responsible discussion one would hope to hear from those asking to be entrusted with the fate of the country, the candidates [at Wednesday's GOP presidential debate] by and large exacerbated the threat of a shutdown with inflammatory pandering on the subject of Planned Parenthood. Sen. Ted Cruz (Tex.), New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie and Carly Fiorina all seemed willing to force a government shutdown based on invective and deceptive claims.... Mr. Cruz labeled the family planning provider an 'ongoing criminal enterprise' and said the videos show Planned Parenthood officials 'bartering and selling the body parts of human beings ... essentially [confessing] to multiple felonies.' Mr. Christie referred to the 'systematic murder of children in the womb to preserve their body parts.' Ms. Fiorina challenged President Obama and Hillary Clinton to view the tapes and 'watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking, while someone says we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.' Those characterizations are false."

Emily Atkin of Think Progress: "Donald Trump imagines a world where regular citizens can buy automatic weapons; where gun owners can hide their weapons in any state; where there are no expanded background checks for gun purchases; and where citizens fight crime with their own assault rifles. That's at least according to Trump's position statement on guns, which he released on Friday. In it, the Republican presidential candidate laid out a vision on the Second Amendment similar to the one held by the National Rifle Association, which opposes new gun control measures and advocates instead for stricter enforcement of existing laws."

Mark Hensch of the Hill: "Donald Trump canceled his appearance Friday evening at a major campaign stop for the GOP presidential field in South Carolina as he faces criticism from both Republican and Democratic candidates over his failure to address claims that President Obama is a Muslim and 'not even an American.'" Trump's campaign claimed "a significant business transaction" prevented him from attending the event.

Patrick Healy of the New York Times: Donald "Trump said in an interview that he was prepared to spend $100 million or more to become the Republican nominee and that most of it would go to galvanizing voter support in states with early nominating contests. While he boasted last month that he would spend $1 billion if need be, he said that a realistic amount would be far less and that he would count on the national Republican Party for financial help if he became the nominee." ...

... Benjamin Wallace-Wells of New York: Donald "Trump's pledge, remarkably modest, is simply to replace one terrible set of elites with another, amazing one.... Trump is a candidate of fury in a time when, relatively speaking, no one in his base really has it too bad." ...

... Dana Milbank earns his Village People creds: "Probably the most encouraging development [during Wednesday's debate] was the candidates' willingness to support each other in calling out Trump's boorishness.... It raises hope that Trump will indeed succeed in making America great again -- by motivating Americans, even fellow conservatives and Republicans, to repudiate his nonsense." CW: Yes, won't it be grand to get back to talking about how big a tax break we should give the rich?

Jeb! The One Honest Politician Donald Trump Could Not Buy! Rosalind Helderman of the Washington Post on Donald Trump's unsuccessful efforts to change Florida gaming laws: "Trump, who has made his successful business negotiations central to his presidential campaign, has never won the legal right to build a casino in Florida.... Trump has said he knows most elected officials have been bought by donors -- because he used to be the one doing the buying. But in Florida, [Jeb] Bush remained a steadfast opponent of expanded gambling [even tho Trump held a fundraiser for him]. That outcome ... highlights Trump's tendency to obscure his business failures as he portrays himself as a perpetual winner.... Trump's interest in a casino in Florida, however, has not faded. He hired a lobbyist to press for the idea again after he purchased the Doral Resort & Spa in Miami in 2012. For the past two years, Trump has backed bills in the Florida legislature that would allow the creation of 'destination resorts,' high-end casinos at a handful of luxury Miami hotels."

Michael Tomasky of the Daily Beast: "... uh... did anybody listen to the substance of what [Carly Fiorina] said [during the debate]?... Fiorina's military buildup would add $500 billion to an already historically huge Pentagon budget. But it's far worse than that. This woman is a crackpot warmonger who would start World War III. No -- III and IV. I could barely believe what I was hearing.... She's an absolute madwoman." ...

She's the face of income inequality and the face of corporate greed... She makes Mitt Romney look like a Democrat.... I've had 11 consecutive victories. I have run against Democrats, Republicans, men, women, people of all ages. She was by far the most mean-spirited opponent I ever had. -- Sen. Barbara Boxer, on Carly Fiorina

... Seema Mehta of the Los Angeles Times: "Sen. Barbara Boxer lashed out at Republican presidential candidate Carly Fiorina on Friday, saying that the woman she defeated in 2010 is a 'mean-spirited,' failed business leader who cared more about enriching herself than about working Americans." ...

... Sarah Kliff of Vox tried twice to get Fiorina's campaign to show her those Planned Parenthood videos Fiorina claimed during the debate she had seen, & twice failed. The campaign sent her other footage of other videos unrelated to Planned Parenthood & not necessarily of aborted fetuses. "'Rest assured, I have seen the images I talked about last night,' [Fiorina] told Good Morning America Thursday morning. If these images Fiorina says she's seen do exist, she still has not shared them." ...

... Hannah Levintova of Mother Jones (and others) found it amusing that Marco Rubio, Ted Cruz & Donald Trump suggested Rosa Parks become the first woman to appear on U.S. currency inasmuch as Parks was a board member of Planned Parenthood....

     ... CW: But their choice of Parks was even more amusing when you consider that Parks was a lifelong political activist, & hardly the meek but principled seamstress who must occupy the empty minds of Rubio, Cruz & Trump. Jeanne Theoharis in the Huffington Post (February 2013):

She worked alongside the Black Power movement, particularly around issues such as reparations, black history, anti-police brutality, freedom for black political prisoners, independent black political power, and economic justice.... She was an early opponent of the Vietnam War in the early 1960s, a member of The Women's International League for Peace and Freedom..., she protested apartheid and U.S. complicity..., and opposed U.S. policy in Central America.

News Lede

AP: "Jackie Collins, the bestselling author of dozens of novels including 'Hollywood Wives' that dramatized the lives of the rich and treacherous, has died. Publicist Melody Korenbrot says Collins died of breast cancer on Saturday in Los Angeles. She was 77."

The Commentariat -- Sept. 18, 2015

Internal links & defunct video removed.

Binyamin Appelbaum of the New York Times: "The Federal Reserve announced on Thursday, after a two-day meeting of its policy-making committee, that it would keep interest rates near zero as officials assess the impact of tighter financial conditions and slower global growth on the domestic economy. Janet L. Yellen, the Fed's chairwoman, described the decision as a close call." ...

... Neil Irwin of the New York Times: "What comes through in both the written materials the Fed released Thursday, and in Ms. Yellen's comments in a news conference, is the sense that they want just a little more assurance ... that their underlying assumptions are correct."

Danielle Ivory & Bill Vlasic of the New York Times: "General Motors went a long way on Thursday toward clearing the legal morass stemming from its decade-long failure to disclose a deadly safety defect in millions of older small cars. In simultaneous announcements, the automaker said it had resolved two substantial avenues of litigation: a criminal investigation by the Justice Department, and hundreds of private lawsuits filed by victims of a faulty ignition switch that has been linked to at least 124 deaths."

Peter Baker of the New York Times: "By any measure, President Obama's effort to train a Syrian opposition army to fight the Islamic State on the ground has been an abysmal failure. The military acknowledged this week that just four or five American-trained fighters are actually fighting. But the White House says it is not to blame. The finger, it says, should be pointed not at Mr. Obama but at those who pressed him to attempt training Syrian rebels in the first place -- a group that, in addition to congressional Republicans, happened to include former Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton."

Julia Preston of the New York Times: "White House officials announced the start of a nationwide campaign on Thursday to encourage legal immigrants to become American citizens, which could add millions of voters to the electorate in time for the presidential election next year. With about 8.8 million legal residents in the country who are eligible to become citizens, White House officials said they were trying to make it easier to complete the final steps to citizenship.... Federal figures [show] that about 60 percent of immigrants eligible to naturalize are Latino and about 20 percent are Asian, both groups that voted overwhelmingly for President Obama. Nearly a third of legal permanent residents eligible to naturalize are Mexican." CW: Hey, hand 'em voter registration cards & maps to their polling places with those citizenship certificates. Seriously, Democratic voter registrars should station themselves outside naturalization offices.

Jordain Carney of the Hill: "Senate Democrats blocked a resolution disapproving the Iran nuclear deal for a third time Thursday, sealing a major foreign policy victory for President Obama. Senators voted 56-42 against ending debate on the resolution of disapproval, falling short of the 60 votes needed on the procedural motion." ...

... Burgess Everett of Politico: "Mitch McConnell should have taken Harry Reid's deal on Iran, GOP Sen. Jeff Flake said in an interview Thursday. The Arizonan said that it 'does not make sense' to hold repeated procedural votes on Iran that are sure to fail, as the Senate is doing on Thursday with amendments that would require Iran to recognize Israel and release Americans held in Iran."

Jordain Carney: "Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) on Thursday officially teed up an initial vote for next week on legislation to restrict abortions after 20 weeks. The Republican leader filed cloture on a motion to proceed to the House-passed legislation. Under Senate rules, the Senate will take a procedural vote on the proposal on Tuesday."

Rebecca Shabad & Peter Sullivan of the Hill: "House GOP leaders are trying to convince their rank and file it would be a bad move to risk a government shutdown over blocking funding for Planned Parenthood. At a closed-door conference meeting on Thursday morning, leadership presented their members with polling from the House GOP's campaign arm showing Republicans would be blamed for a government shutdown."

You People Are Even Crazier than I Am. Lauren French of Politico: Winger California Republican Rep. Tom McClintock announced Wednesday he was resigning from the conservative House Freedom Caucus, saying the group's hardball tactics had undermined conservative goals rather than advancing them. The departure comes as the group is locked in a heated battle with Republican leaders about the direction of the party and is threatening to attempt to strip Rep. John Boehner of his speakership."

Sarah Ferris of the Hill: "A federal appeals court on Thursday ruled against ObamaCare's birth control mandate in a decision that could invite a Supreme Court review. The 8th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that four Christian nonprofits should not have to comply with the ObamaCare rule that all employer healthcare plans include contraception options or face a fee. While employers can seek exemptions to the law, the court argued that doing so poses a 'substantial burden; on that organization's religious rights. The decision is particularly important because it directly contradicts another federal court's ruling."

Mary Hudetz of the AP: "The Obama administration has agreed to pay hundreds of Native American tribes nearly $1 billion to settle a decades-old claim that the government failed to adequately compensate tribes while they managed education, law enforcement and other federal services. The Interior Department announced the proposed $940 million agreement in Albuquerque on Thursday along with leaders from the Oglala Sioux Tribe, Zuni Pueblo and Ramah Chapter of the Navajo Nation."

Darren Sands of BuzzFeed: "Black Lives Matter activists, including select members of Campaign Zero, met with top White House officials on Wednesday, a senior administration official confirmed to BuzzFeed News. Activists met with senior adviser Valerie Jarrett, as well as Roy Austin, the deputy assistant to the president for urban affairs, and a collection of White House officials. The meeting focused on law enforcement and community policing with an emphasis on how to increase public safety locally. ....

... Charles Pierce seems to think wingers will find this outrageous. ...

... CW: I'd say this is an example of what Pierce had in mind.

Michael Memoli of the Los Angeles Times: "President Obama hailed the courage and quick thinking of three high school friends who helped avert tragedy on a Paris-bound train last month as they came to the White House on Thursday, where he labeled them 'the very best of America'":

Richard Oppel of the New York Times: "Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who faces a possible life sentence for endangering the troops who searched for him after he left his Afghanistan base in 2009, at the time had a 'severe mental disease or defect,' one of his lawyers said Thursday. The diagnosis was made later by an independent Army psychiatry board, said the defense lawyer, Lt. Col. Franklin D. Rosenblatt of the Army. Because of his psychological problems, Sergeant Bergdahl washed out of Coast Guard basic training three years earlier, Colonel Rosenblatt said, and had to obtain a waiver to join the Army."

Presidential Race

I would hope that the Republicans -- and particularly the Republicans in the House, led by Speaker Boehner -- would not put our country and our economy in peril pursuing some kind of emotionally, politically charged, partisan attack on Planned Parenthood to shut our government down.... If they want to shut down the legal provision of abortion services, then they've got a bigger problem, because obviously Planned Parenthood does not use federal dollars to do that. -- Hillary Clinton, to Wolf Blitzer yesterday

Russell Berman of the Atlantic: "The Republican National Committee is not ready to commit to having an undercard debate the next time around, spokesman Sean Spicer said on Thursday. RNC officials will be watching the race unfold over the next few weeks to see if any candidates drop out, and how many."

"The Hunger Games." Brian Beutler of the New Republic: "In addition to the fact that [Republicans] have no obvious candidate to consolidate behind, the fractured field is leaving each favored contender vulnerable to other dark horses who are happy to maul and obstruct them.... The biggest victim of this phenomenon is Jeb Bush, who not only has to fend off minor threats, but is also engaged in a clearly unwinnable rhetorical war with Trump.... Over and over again during the debate, Bush attempted to assert himself against Trump, as if to demonstrate by example that Trump has mischaracterized his lack of vigor. He failed every time."

Paul Krugman: "... all of the G.O.P. candidates are calling for policies that would be deeply destructive at home, abroad, or both. But even if you like the broad thrust of modern Republican policies, it should worry you that the men and woman on that stage are clearly living in a world of fantasies and fictions.... If the discussion of economics was alarming, the discussion of foreign policy was practically demented.... The only candidate who seemed remotely sensible on national security issues was Rand Paul, which is almost as disturbing as the spectacle of Mr. Trump being the only voice of economic reason." ...

... New York Times Editors: "It felt at times as if the speakers were no longer living in a fact-based world where actions have consequences, programs take money and money has to come from somewhere. Where basic laws -- like physics and the Constitution -- constrain wishes. Where Congress and the public, allies and enemies, markets and militaries don't just do what you want them to, just because you say they will."...

... Charles Pierce: "What we saw ... was the triumph of fiction over fact, of fantasy over reality. In other words, what we saw was the most fitting tribute to Ronald Reagan ever produced. Congratulations, one and all. The final fealty of the Republican Party to total and complete bullshit has been sworn.... If Carly Fiorina is adjudged to be the winner of a debate simply because of how 'crisply' she delivered lies about Planned Parenthood, or how 'forcefully' she responded to a cartoon like Donald Trump, or how 'sharply' she presented her nonsense about reining in Vladimir Putin with 'aggressive military maneuvers' on his borders, then there is a problem in the political process that is metastasizing by the hour. Ronald Reagan was the index patient for that problem." .../p>

... Tim Egan: Carly Fiorina "is the embodiment of the unfairness, the rigged game that hurts so many average working people.... [Jeb!] Bush did expose [Donald] Trump for what should be his greatest weakness, something that's been largely overlooked by the surface-obsessed press. The guy is a casino operator. He made a lot of money separating suckers from their money. And then, through his bankruptcies, he eventually failed at that -- one of the most rigged schemes in the world. He lost in his own game of loser's poker."

Adele Stan of the American Prospect: "While [debate moderator Jake] Tapper, with an occasional assist from his colleague Dana Bash and radio host Hugh Hewitt, did hit the hot buttons -- Planned Parenthood funding, immigration, Iran, same-sex marriage, Donald Trump's remarks about Carly Fiorina's face -- the questions read more like a greatest hits list of GOP bloviation points than prompts for serious discussions of issues.... And as is too often the case in such debates, blatant lies uttered by candidates were left unchallenged.... The evil genius of Fiorina ... is her uncanny ability to play the gender warrior within the GOP while promoting the party's misogyny."

I dare Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, to watch these tapes. Watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking while someone says, 'We have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.' -- Carly Fiorina, making up stuff during the debate

... ** digby, in Salon: "... much of what Fiorina says is either untrue or incoherent, which her polished style of rapid-fire answers containing long lists of memorized specifics obscures.... Considering her very loose relationship with the truth, her failed record as a businesswoman which left thousands of people's lives in ruins and her cavalier attitude about paying her debts, it's awfully ironic that the lines she delivers with the most righteous passion are harsh criticisms of Hillary Clinton's honesty and trustworthiness. That's something else she has in common with Trump -- chutzpah." ...

... Steve Benen: "... as a substantive matter, Fiorina, who's running for president despite never having held public office, spoke with great confidence and poise, but generally seemed clueless. Her rhetoric about Planned Parenthood was plainly at odds with reality. She said it takes 'two-thirds of the states' to ratify a constitutional amendment, but it actually takes three-fourths. Her comments about the criminal justice system were simply untrue. She insisted that Democrats, who've been pleading with Republicans for years to pass immigration reform, 'don't want' to pass immigration reform. Her defense of her failed tenure at HP was hard to take seriously. Her rhetoric about foreign policy was 'bizarre.'... By some measures, a candidate who gets caught making so many bogus claims over the course of just one debate should wake up to brutal headlines about a disqualifying performance. But by contemporary rules, presidential hopefuls are judged less like candidates for the White House and more like performers...." ...

... Nick Gass of Politico: "Fiorina, appearing on ABC's 'Good Morning America' earlier Thursday, responded to numerous media fact-checks (including from Politico) by saying that 'rest assured,' she had seen what she described during the debate. [CW: Because everybody except Carly is delusional.]...Planned Parenthood Action Fund shot back with a memo and a letter to Fiorina on Thursday. 'The images show nothing like what Carly Fiorina said they do, and they have nothing to do with Planned Parenthood. The video footage that she claims exists -- and that she 'dared' people to watch -- does not exist,' Planned Parenthood spokesman Eric Ferrero said in a memo released via email Thursday. 'We have a word for that: It's a lie. And it's not the first time Carly Fiorina has lied.'" ...

... Chris Cillizza of the Washington Post: Carly "Fiorina's past political history suggests that her struggles at HP could be a campaign killer. In 2010, Fiorina was running surprisingly close to California Sen. Barbara Boxer (D), who was struggling in a strong election cycle for Republicans nationally. Then, Boxer ran this ad focused on Fiorina's time at the helm of HP.... The ad functioned as a sort of knock-out punch for Boxer even in a year where Republicans claimed victories all across the country:

Words Fail Me (Amended Below):

     ... The Ethnic-Cleansing Candidate. Juan Cole: "The corporate media focused more on the statements about Obama and Trump's unwillingness to challenge them than on the demand for ethnic cleansing of millions of US citizens. They even twisted themselves in pretzels with their headlines about Trump 'failing to challenge' the man. That allegation is an abject lie, since Trump very clearly reacted to the charge with approval by saying that 'we need' this question.... More important than the birther allegations is that Trump accepted the premise of the man that Muslim-Americans might be conducting terrorist training camps on US soil for the purpose of training to kill Americans, and that a campaign of ethnic cleansing against Americans of Muslim faith is required ('get rid of'). He promised to look into the issue." ...

     ... The P. T. Barnum Candidate. CW: There is an alternate reading here, & it relies on the way Trump says, "We need this question." He laughs when he says it. Let's stipulate that Trump is a racist. He's a real-life Archie Bunker (like Donald, a Queens character), albeit a richer one. But I think what you see in that laugh (13 seconds in) is a fleeting failure to stay in character. Almost immediately, Trump catches himself & pretends the jerk has made intelligent remarks & asked a worthy question. Trump says his people will be looking into the guy's insane charges & (maybe) into how to "get rid of" Muslims. One could argue that Trump no more endorses the guy's remarks than you endorse your Uncle Fred's Thanksgiving dinner harangue when you just roll your eyes instead of wasting your time telling Fred he's a jackass. Trump does not, as Cole suggests, endorse a Muslim Holocaust the way he has promised a Central American Trail of Tears. What we've been witnessing lo these many months is performance completely devoid of conviction. Why doesn't Trump go into detail about how he's going to deport 11 million people? Because he has no intention of doing so. When he originally made the statement, his only plan was to garner more publicity. But since he is preternaturally unable to back down from any of his ludicrous remarks, as his poll numbers rose & a Trump presidency began to seem vaguely possible, he's had to stick with statements he knows are ridiculous. That horrifying little jerk who is willing to say in public that we need to "get rid of" Muslims is, in a way, a lot more scary than Donald Trump. Trump is a joker. He is laughing at all of us. That guy is real, & he (figuratively) lives next door to me. The problem, of course, is that Trump's Big Joke encourages him.

Bradford Richardson of the Hill: "Ben Carson holds the top spot in the Michigan GOP primary, according to a poll released by Marketing Resource Group (MRG) on Wednesday. Carson, who was born in Detroit, draws 24 percent in the Great Lake State, followed by Donald Trump at 22 percent, former Florida governor Jeb Bush at 8 percent and former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee at 6 percent. The retired neurosurgeon polls particularly well with women voters in the state...." CW: Toljaso. That soothing bedside manner is a hit with the ladies.

Burgess Everett: "Many of the Republican candidates on the debate stage Wednesday night joined in a full-throated endorsement of Ted Cruz's damn-the-torpedoes strategy to defund Planned Parenthood, even if it means shutting down the federal government. But two candidates who'll soon be casting votes on the matter were noticeably silent: Sens. Marco Rubio and Rand Paul."

... Jonathan Chait: "... the most frightening and consequential fallout from the debate was the near-consensus that George W. Bush had, in fact, handled his duties as commander-in-chief splendidly. Jeb Bush's most passionate and crowd-pleasing moment came when he insisted, in the face of Trump's criticism of the Iraq War, that his brother had 'kept us safe.' Bush's campaign considered this rallying moment of the party faithful so successful that, [Thursday], it leaned into that moment and made it the centerpiece of Bush's post-debate message.... It is bizarre to center your defense of Bush having 'kept us safe' with a photograph of him standing on the rubble from the worst domestic mass-casualty attack in American history, one that took place under his watch." ...

... CW: As someone else pointed out (sorry, I can't recall who), in the photo, Dubya is standing atop the dead bodies of some of the people he "kept safe." I have never understood why pundits right & left considered his bullhorn moment a brilliant, moving expression of the American character, our modern-day equivalent to Shakespeare's St. Crispin's Day speech.

The Doofus Sawbuck.... Peter Alexander & Carrie Dann of NBC News: "Jeb Bush might be changing his mind about his statement that he'd like to see former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher on the $10 bill.... Bush instead said that he'd like to see the American people decide which woman deserves to be on U.S. currency, suggesting that a question about the bill during the second GOP presidential debate Wednesday night was not 'the most relevant thing in the world.'" CW: Because women, especially American women, are not very "relevant." I mean, who cares? This is the same Doofus who said in August, "I'm not sure we need half a billion dollars -- for women's health issues." ...

... "Wallets Full of Women." Ann Friedman of New York on all the candidates' choices. Funny, as long as you forget one of these anti-feminists (& that definitely includes Carly) could become president.

Beyond the Beltway

AP: "A friend of the alleged Charleston church shooter was arrested Thursday, more than a month after authorities told him he was under federal investigation for lying to them and failing to report a crime, an official close to the probe said. Joey Meek, 21, was arrested Thursday, the official told the Associated Press, speaking only on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to publicly talk about the case." ...

... Avery Wilks of the (South Carolina) State reports here.

Dan Barry of the New York Times: "More than six years after their rescue from virtual servitude, in which they worked for little pay in a turkey processing plant while living in a decrepit Iowa schoolhouse, more than two dozen men with intellectual disabilities will share nearly $600,000 owed to them, after a federal court order issued Thursday in Dallas. The ruling, by Chief Judge Jorge A. Solis of United States District Court, overrode a confidential arrangement that would have redirected hundreds of thousands of dollars owed to the men, in unpaid court judgments, to the heirs of their former employers, the owners of a Texas-based company called Henry's Turkey Service." ...

Chris Geidner of BuzzFeed: "Mississippi Gov. Phil Bryant [R] and Attorney General Jim Hood [D] believe the state's ban on adoptions by same-sex couples remains constitutional -- even in the aftermath of the Supreme Court's recent marriage rulings -- the two men asserted in federal court late last week." CW: Apparently every single discriminatory statute, ordinance & administrative regulation will have to get a Supreme Court reading before it becomes unconstitooshunal.

Cristian Farias of the Huffington Post: "A federal appeals court on Thursday turned away a request filed by lawyers for Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis, and chastised Davis' attorneys for not adhering to the rules of the court.

Nicole Hensley of the New York Daily News: "What appears to be a viral Tide commercial spoofing religious freedom advocates such as Kentucky's Kim Davis is only an advertising company's pitch to Procter & Gamble.... The 30-second spot directed by TinyGiant's Mark Nickelsburg appears to be a hat tip to a whirlwind of legal sparring in Rowan County as Davis repeatedly refused to grant same-sex couples marriage licenses, but it's only a coincidence. The idea behind the commercial, however, was conceived in January and wasn't taped until weeks before the Supreme Court’s ruling in June, Nickelsburg told the Daily News. 'Kim Davis did not inspire it at all,' Nickelsburg said, but 'there's truth to comedy,' he added."

Dave Blanton of the Kings Mountain (North Carolina) Herald: "Eugene Holmes, who is running for mayor of Kings Mountain, bluntly states that he doesn't want the job. 'I don't want to be mayor no more than I want to fly,' said Holmes, who on the ballot lists his first name as 'Sherlock.'... 'In my administration I would do just like Mrs. Davis did in Kentucky,' said Holmes, referring to Kim Davis, the Rowan County, Ky., clerk.... (The City of Kings Mountain does not issue marriage licenses.)... ''I would get the D.A. to swear out a warrant on any man who says he's gay. Sodomy is a crime, a felony in the state of North Carolina. What's wrong with eradicating homosexuals? We should jail them, throw them all in jail!' said Holmes.... 'I don't know about my chances in this thing,' said Holmes...." CW: No shit, Sherlock. Via the Raw Story.

Way Beyond

Amer Cohadzic & Danica Kirka of the AP: "Croatian Prime Minister Zoran Milanovic said Friday his nation is overwhelmed by a huge influx of migrants and will redirect people toward Hungary and Slovenia as they move north in hopes of reaching more prosperous European countries. It wasn't immediately clear how Croatia's move would solve the situation since both Hungary and Slovenia are taking steps to keep migrants out, deepening a crisis as people seek a route to refuge."

William Booth, et al., of the Washington Post: "European nations once friendly to refugees abruptly yanked their welcome mats Thursday, as Germany considered slashing its benefits and Croatia announced it was closing most of its road links with Serbia 'until further notice.'... In a 128-page draft law produced by the German Interior Ministry..., the government would speed asylum procedures, cut cash benefits, hasten deportations and punish those with false claims and phony paperwork.... Croatia's decision to close roads across its border with Serbia raised the risk of pushing asylum seekers into the area's fields and forests, which are littered with land mines left over the 1990s Balkan War."