The Commentariat -- August 20, 2015
Internal links removed.
Afternoon Update:
Bill Barrow of the AP: "As part of her promise to address rising college costs, Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Rodham Clinton is calling to expand the AmeriCorps service program launched under her husband's administration. Clinton calls for spending about $20 billion over 10 years on the expansion, increasing the number of civil service volunteers from 75,000 to 250,000 and more than doubling the educational grant that enrollees can receive."
*****
Abby Phillip of the Washington Post: "Former president Jimmy Carter said that the cancer doctors discovered earlier this year has spread to his brain and that he will receive his first radiation treatment for the disease Thursday afternoon. 'I'm perfectly at ease with whatever comes,' Carter, 90, said at a news conference." The New York Times story, by Alan Blinder, is here. Here are clips from President Carter's news conference:
Matt Apuzzo of the New York Times: "In dozens of lawsuits around the country involving local disputes, the federal government has filed so-called statements of interest, throwing its weight behind private lawsuits and, in many cases, pushing the boundaries of civil rights law.... Recently ... the Justice Department has filed statements of interest in cases involving legal aid in New York, transgender students in Michigan, juvenile prisoners in solitary detention in California, and people who take videos of police officers in Baltimore."
E. J. Dionne: "You can bet that the Texas voting case or another in North Carolina, or both, will make their way to a Supreme Court that has already gutted the Voting Rights Act once in a 2013 decision written by [Chief Justice John] Roberts. Will he do it again? And will voters in 2016 realize just how important a president's power to name future Supreme Court justices is to the very right they will be exercising on Election Day?" CW: Yes & no, in that order.
Linda Greenhouse: "In the breadth of its perspective on the history and current problematic state of the death penalty, in its cleareyed dissection of the irreconcilable conflict at the heart of modern death-penalty jurisprudence, the Connecticut Supreme Court not only produced an important decision for its own jurisdiction; but it addressed the United States Supreme Court frankly and directly."
George Yancy of the New York Times interviews Cornel West. CW: In my opinion, West is a preening, narcissistic crank, but he is worth reading for the direction of his complaints, which should be considered if not necessarily shared or adopted in full.
Gardiner Harris of the New York Times: "President Obama will travel to New Orleans next week for the 10th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina...." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Karoun Demirjian of the Washington Post: "Congress is unlikely to override a promised veto by President Obama if both chambers reject a deal to curtail Iran's nuclear capabilities, according to a Washington Post analysis of where the votes currently stand." With charts! ...
... Oh yeah? What about this? George Jahn of the AP: "Iran will be allowed to use its own inspectors to investigate a site it has been accused of using to develop nuclear arms, operating under a secret agreement with the U.N. agency that normally carries out such work, according to a document seen by The Associated Press.... The White House has repeatedly denied claims of a secret side deal favorable to Tehran.... The document is labeled 'separate arrangement II,' indicating there is another confidential agreement between Iran and the IAEA.... Iran is to provide agency experts with photos and videos of locations the IAEA says are linked to the alleged weapons work, 'taking into account military concerns.' That wording suggests that -- beyond being barred from physically visiting the site -- the agency won't get photo or video information from areas Iran says are off-limits...." ...
... CW: I didn't know what to make of this story. The AP doesn't usually make up stuff. All the prominent commentary on it came from the winger fringe, so no help there. Then ....
... Juan Cole: "The accord actually provides for the inspectors of the International Atomic Energy Agency always to be present at such inspections. The reason for the presence of Iranian experts is that there is a long history of outside nuclear teams being sent in by the Great Powers for espionage. I.e., the Iranian inspectors are there to keep an eye on the UN inspectors, not to cover up Iranian activities.... The AP should retract its inaccurate allegations."
Sean Fitz-Gerald of New York: "Regal Cinemas, the nation's largest movie-theater chain, announced it's beginning to search ticket buyers' bags before letting them in, according to multiple reports. The move comes on the heels of an uptick in movie-theater shootings as well as the release of a survey that found roughly half of moviegoers interviewed wanted more security."
Presidential Race
Maggie Haberman of the New York Times posts full video of Hillary Clinton's meeting with BlackLivesMatter activists last week. "The combination of patience and gentle scolding with which she responded seemed a distillation of Mrs. Clinton's worldview: that movement politics gets you only so far, and that activists must pave the way for those in office to act.... [The video] also showed Mrs. Clinton as even her admirers lament that she is seldom seen: spontaneous, impassioned and seemingly unconcerned about potential repercussions." ...
... CW: What you're seeing here is a candidate with a presidential advantage, which she uses to a positive end. Because Clinton has a Secret Service detail, she was able to keep these young people from disrupting her public meeting, but she had the guts & sense not to shut them out entirely & to engage them in an actual dialog -- which for all the participants is far superior to a shout-down. Allowing the dialog to be taped was pretty smart, too. ...
... Kendall Breitman of Bloomberg: "When it comes to using a private server for her e-mails when she was secretary of state, Hillary Clinton 'didn't really think it through,' according to her communications director...., Jennifer Palmieri. '... Others had done it before and it was just more convenient and she kept it like that, and she didn't really -- that's the thing, she didn't really think it through.' 'She has said, had she, she would have done it differently,' Palmieri added. ...
... CW: Again, this is a problem that derives from having a staff that doesn't have the guts to tell the boss she making a mistake, even when the issue is one the boss hasn't given much thought. I see this as a serious flaw to Hillary's management style, & there's little reason to think the style wouldn't carry over to the White House.
"There Goes the Electability Argument!" Ed Kilgore: "... new CNN/ORC poll findings [Wednesday] should provide a very rude shock to those who think Republican voters will finally wake up and realize Donald Trump would be a disaster as a general election candidate and stampede instead to a 'grown-up' like Establishment fave Jeb Bush. At this particular moment, Donald Trump is running better than Jeb Bush in trial general election match-ups with Hillary Clinton." ...
... CW: As I've said before, this should unsettle Democrats, too. ...
... Steve M. New York Crank "... don't write off Bernie so fast. If Hillary flounders, his momentum will pick up. And given that this could be a populist vs. populist race, Bernie just might make more sense to populist voters."
Mark Murray of NBC News: "Eight GOP presidential candidates have now said they oppose "birthright citizenship" if their parents are not documented citizens; that is, they favor repealing or ignoring or reinterpreting the part of the Fourteenth Amendment that guarantees citizenship to U.S.-born babies." ...
... Trump Is Just Copying Me. -- Ted Cruz. Sahil Kapur of Bloomberg: "Republican presidential candidate Ted Cruz says that he 'absolutely' supports ending birthright citizenship.... Cruz says 'virtually every element' in Trump's immigration plan 'is contained within legislation' that he has previously filed." CW: Cruz was born in Canada to a Cuban father & (U.S.) American mother. He had dual citizenship -- U.S. & Canada -- till he decided to run for president. In March of this year famed birther Donald Trump called Cruz's Canadian birth a "hurdle" that "somebody could look at very seriously." That's two GOP candidates now -- Cruz & Walker -- who claim authorship for Trump's extreme anti-immigration policy. BUT ...
... A Fine Bromance. Tim Mak of the Daily Beast: "It's a bromance with a payoff -- the senator [Ted Cruz] has been developing the billionaire's support and their aides are even discussing joint events, but if Trump drops out, Cruz aims to clean up." ...
... Eliza Collins of Politico: "Jeb Bush doesn't want birthright citizenship to go away, but he is calling for stronger enforcement for people who abuse it." ...
... David Leopold, past president of the American Immigration Lawyers Association, in TPM, explains the law re: "birthright citizenship." Donald "Trump claims that birthright citizenship must end because it's the 'biggest magnet for illegal immigration' -- it attracts illegal immigrants using their 'anchor babies' to reap the benefits of U.S. citizenship."... The 'magnet' to which Trump refers is an arduous 31-year-long slog to legal status for the undocumented parent.... According to the Migration Policy Institute (pdf), repeal of birthright citizenship would lead to a dramatic increase in the number of unauthorized children living in the U.S. -- as many as 24 million by 2050.... Trump's extremist proposal to end birthright citizenship ... comes at the grave cost of abridging civil rights, even hearkening back to the days of Dred Scott...." ...
... AND, if you're into original intent, Li'l Randy is wrong here, "... I don't think the 14th Amendment was meant to apply to illegal aliens. It was meant to apply to the children of slaves." Amanda Terkel of the Huffington Post: "... the framers of the 14th Amendment were thinking of immigrants' children, as they made clear in an 1866 debate on the Senate floor. Sen. Edgar Cowan (R-Pa.) was an opponent of birthright citizenship.... When he asked whether the proposed legislation would cover children of immigrants, Sen. John Conness (R-Calif.), a supporter, said it would." ...
... CW BTW: Terkel is reading a sanitized version of Conness's remark: "The proposition before us...relates...to the children begotten of Chinese parents in California, and it is proposed to declare that they shall be citizens.... I am in favor of doing so." Charles Pierce has "Chinese" as "Mongol"; Paul Finkelman has it as "Mongolian." Finkelman identifies Conness as a racist, who opposed equality for black Americans &, as a Californian, was hostile to Chinese immigrants. He seems, however, to have come around, as the concept of equality expanded. Nothing about intent is straightforward, despite what "law office historians" & Nino Scalia would assert. ...
... "Act Two of the Trump Epic." Josh Marshall of TPM: "Trump is now defining the GOP policy agenda. And that makes him far more than a top candidate or even a nominee. Ending birthright citizenship used to be an idea embraced on the far right of the House GOP caucus and bandied about by rightwing policy wonks. Trump has now not only made it a signature of his campaign. He's also pulling all the other candidates along with him.... In three years we've now gone from the need to support comprehensive immigration reform, to balking on supporting the deal, to embracing the policies that used to be held by the comical likes of Steve King...."
Eliza Collins: "In a 30-minute news conference in Derry, New Hampshire [yesterday], that was broadcast live on Fox News and CNN..., [Donald Trump] ripped into [Jeb Bush].... Bush saying the U.S. had to show they had 'skin in the game' by committing more resources to combating the Islamic State was 'one of the the dumber things I've heard, ever, in politics,' Trump said. 'Between Common Core, his 'act of love' on immigration and 'skin in the game' with Iraq ... I don't see how he's electable. And then on top of that he talks about women's health issues,' Trump said.... 'Right down the road, we have Jeb -- very small crowd,' he said[, referring to Jeb!'s simultaneous event in nearby Merrimack, New Hampshire]. 'You know what's happening to Jeb's crowd right down the street? They're sleeping now.'"
I had to do it for myself. -- Donald Trump, on why he's running
I think this is what people mean by "authencity." -- Constant Weader
... Time reporters interview Donald Trump for the magazine's cover story, & he says he's so much better than all the other bozos running for president. Et-cetera. Michael Scherer has the cover story here, with a lot of embedded videos of Trump saying he's so much better than all the other bozos running for president, etc. ...
... More of the Same. Tal Kopan of CNN: "... Donald Trump took on an array of subjects and political figures during a lengthy interview with CNN's Chris Cuomo on Wednesday.... Trump said the controversy surrounding Hillary Clinton's email use is 'devastating,' and that it's not surprising that he came within 6 points of the Democrat in a head-to-head polling match-up. 'I think it's devastating for the election, but I think her bigger problem is not the election. I think her bigger problem is going to be the criminal (problem),' Trump said."
Philip Rucker & Jose Del Real of the Washington Post: In New Hampshire, Trump & Kasich are squeezing out Jeb! "Trump led the field in New Hampshire with 18 percent, followed by Bush at 13 percent and Kasich right behind at 12 percent, according to a recent Boston Herald/Franklin Pierce University poll of likely GOP primary voters."
Sahil Kapur: Experts suggest the state-run high-risk insurance pools that both Scott Walker & Marco Rubio propose would be prohibitively expensive, which is kind of a moot point because Congress would never fund them anyway. ...
... The Audacity of Dopes. CW: One thing that gets me about these Walker & Rubio "plans": ObamaCare, such as it is, took tens of thousands of hours to develop into something that had a chance to get through Congress & that was also cost-effective & workable. These bozos think they can dash off some "ideas" on a napkin, most of which are already known to be unworkable, unpassable, & meaner than dirt, then foist them off as a blueprint for a real replacement for the ACA. ...
... Kevin Drum of Mother Jones produces two charts that show how much ScottieCare "screws the poor," no matter the age of the head of household. Drum acknowledges that his post is "anticlimactic" because readers could already guess how his comparisons between ScottieCare & ObamaCare would turn out.
CW: I have been avoiding linking to any stories about Mike Huckabee, because of his remarks comparing the Iran deal to the Holocaust. But to update you a bit, Huckleberry is in Israel, demonstrating anew what an astounding, bigoted ignoramus he is. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Ed Kilgore: "Huck held a fundraiser for Americans living in West Bank settlements deemed illegal under international law.... The dude seems off-balance."
Tom Jensen of Public Policy Polling: "Finally another declared independent candidate, Deez Nuts, polls at 9% in North Carolina to go along with his 8% in Minnesota and 7% in Iowa in our recent polling." ...
... Ben Collins & Emily Shire of the Daily Beast: "Brady Olson is 15 years old. He filed to run for the President of the United States with the FEC on July 26 as Deez Nuts." ...
... Tim Dickinson of Rolling Stone interviews Deez/Brady: "I really didn't want to see Clinton, Bush, or Trump in the White House, so I guess I'm just trying to put up a fight.... I'm fifteen, so I haven't been registered yet. I side more with the Libertarian Party." (CW: Like so many 15-year-old boys.)
Beyond the Beltway
Andy Grimm of the Times-Picayune: "Five New Orleans Police officers convicted in the shooting of unarmed pedestrians at the Danziger Bridge days after Hurricane Katrina are entitled to a new trial, a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday (Aug. 18). The 2-1 ruling by a panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upholds U.S. District Judge Kurt D. Englehardt's 2013 decision to throw out the convictions of the officers on charges related to shootings that left two civilians dead, and a coverup involving the lead NOPD investigator on the case. 'The reasons for granting a new trial are novel and extraordinary,' the appeals court decision said, citing the misconduct of then-federal prosecutors who posted pseudonymous comments on NOLA.com stories about the case. The ruling also said the Department of Justice 'inadequately investigated' the misconduct." ...
... CW: Englehardt & all three justices on the Appeals Court panel are GOP appointees. ...
... Charles Pierce: "There should be a special circle of derision reserved exclusively for prosecutors who botch important cases in very stupid ways."
AP: "Vast areas of California's Central Valley are sinking faster than in the past as massive amounts of groundwater are pumped during the historic drought, Nasa said in new research released on Wednesday. The research shows that in some places the ground is sinking nearly two inches each month, putting infrastructure on the surface at growing risk of damage." ...
... Darryl Fears of the Washington Post: "... a new study released Thursday says human-caused global warming is worsening ... [California's drought]. The study by Columbia University's Earth Institute isn't the first to say warming has played a key role in fueling California's dry conditions, but it's the first to measure its impact, predicting that it increased the problem by as much as 25 percent."
Jaime Fuller of New York: "After NJ.com reported [Wednesday] morning that drones were available for purchase at Brookstone and Hudson News locations at Newark International Airport, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey said it was 'strongly opposed to the sale of drones at terminal shops' and that they should stop being sold 'immediately.' The New York Post reports that a Brookstone in Terminal 7 at JFK International Airport also sells drones.... 'This is obviously not a very well thought out retail strategy,'" an airport law enorcement official said. CW: Aw, c'mon, capitalism is awesome.