The Commentariat -- April 30, 2015
Internal links removed.
CW: As promised, another day of goofing off here on my part. Do check out Jon Stewart's interview of Judith Miller, which Victoria D. linked today.
Jonathan Weisman of the New York Times: "Shinzo Abe, in the first address by a Japanese prime minister to a joint meeting of Congress, praised his nation's 'quantum leap' in economic reforms but offered no specific concessions as he appealed to skeptical lawmakers to back a far-reaching Pacific trade accord. Mr. Abe faced a Congress deeply divided by President Obama's drive to obtain fast-track negotiating authority to complete the Trans-Pacific Partnership with Japan and 10 other nations on the Pacific Rim. Lawmakers in both parties have questioned Mr. Abe's ability to open his nation's agriculture and auto markets to American products, one of the biggest questions that remain in the trade talks." ...
... CW: Apparently, Abe's address made Speaker Boehner very, very sad:
Rebecca Shabad of the Hill: "Republicans on Wednesday unveiled a joint House-Senate budget that aims to torpedo ObamaCare while balancing the federal books within 10 years. The release of the blueprint sets up a vote in the House on Friday, with the Senate expected to follow suit next week." ...
... Robert Greenstein of the Center on Budget & Policy Priorities: "The budget conference agreement, if adopted by Congress, will represent one of the most radical budget plans that lawmakers have adopted since they created the modern budget process in 1974. That's no exaggeration. If they follow this plan, lawmakers would eviscerate substantial parts of the federal government -- including parts that have previously enjoyed bipartisan support -- and they also would violate the clear intent of the 2011 Budget Control Act (BCA). Consider this: More than doubling the sequestration cuts.... Radically shrinking much of government.... Using a blatant gimmick to increase defense spending.... Magic asterisk.... Robin Hood in reverse."
Amy Howe of ScotusBlog: "In the past few years, the Roberts Court has been very supportive of the freedom of speech.... But today an unusual coalition of five Justices -- Chief Justice John Roberts and the Court's four more liberal Justices -- agreed on one kind of speech that the government can ban: personal solicitations of campaign funds by people running for judgeships .... in Williams-Yulee v. The Florida Bar. ...
... Rick Hasen: "This is a case which makes it much more likely that limits on money and speech in judicial elections will be upheld.... This is a HUGE win for those who support reasonable limits on judicial elections -- and getting Roberts on this side of the issue is surprising, welcome, and momentous.... Justice Kennedy's dissent [is] not only a dissent to this case, but a defense of his decision in Citizens United." ...
... Gail Collins: "The reform community was thrilled. This is how low our expectations for clean elections have dropped, people.... Antonin Scalia ... found the whole idea of restricting judges' ability to hit up trial lawyers for money a 'wildly disproportionate restriction' upon judicial candidates' right of free speech.... Chief Justice Roberts provided the swing vote on the decision, an irony not lost on pretty much anybody. It's been Roberts who's led the court in castrating limits on the role of big money in other elections. The difference in this case, he explained, is that 'judges are not politicians.' While Roberts thinks his own profession needs to appear impartial and above the fray, he appears to feel that there's no need whatsoever for the public to believe that candidates for, say, president of the United States, aren't being swayed by rich donors."
Lyle Denniston of ScotusBlog: "What appears to be a clear majority of the Court has grown frustrated with the repeated constitutional assaults on the death penalty, especially since that penalty is still constitutionally permitted. That frustration almost boiled over as the Court heard the case of Glossip v. Gross." ...
... Ed Pilkington of the Guardian: "Anger spilled from the nine justices from both sides of the court's ideological divide. The more conservative wing vented their disapproval at those they called 'abolitionists' who they accused of trying to overturn the death penalty by stealth, while the more liberal judges attacked states such as Oklahoma for using a new drug protocol that had left prisoners 'writhing in pain' in executions that took up to two hours to complete.... 'If there's no method of executing a person that does not cause pain, that may show the death penalty is not consistent with the eighth amendment,' [Justice Breyer] said."
June's gonna be a nice time for a gay wedding. -- Jon Stewart
... CW: Also, too, it was pretty clever of the states opposing marriage equality to choose a gay man to argue their case. (Yeah, I know he's married to a woman & has five children for added window-dressing. But he is still gay-gay-gay-diddy-gay.) Please, Supremes, free John Birch Bursch. (But make him pay child support.) ...
... Linda Greenhouse: U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli explains to the Supremes why "wait-and-see" is just another way of validating the "house-divided" status for gays which racial minorities enduring for generations under "de jure racial segregation" in some states.
Margaret Hartmann of New York: "Two nights after Baltimore was burned and looted by rioters, the city's curfew appears to be working. National Guardsmen and police in riot gear were stationed through the city once again, but at 10:00 p.m. only a few stragglers were still out. Members of the community were credited with helping clear the streets, averting clashes with police. 'We are very proud of what has happened here tonight. We are proud of our city,' said Congressman Elijah Cummings. Earlier on Wednesday evening, protesters across the country turned out by the thousands to express their outrage over the death of Freddie Gray, and other victims of police brutality. Massive demonstrations in Washington, D.C., Boston, and Minneapolis were peaceful, but a march in New York ended with the arrest of more than 60 protesters." ...
... Jason Molinet, et al., of the New York Daily News: "Protesters jammed Union Square and clashed with NYPD officers as they marched through the streets of New York City in solidarity with Baltimore activists Wednesday night, briefly shutting down the Holland Tunnel and snarling traffic along the West Side Highway - resulting in at least 100 arrests. What began as a small gathering at Union Square around 6 p.m. swelled to more than 1,000 people, many holding 'Justice 4 Freddie Gray' placards while chanting 'Black Lives Matter' and continued into the early hours Thursday." ...
... Today in Blame-the-Victim News. Peter Hermann of the Washington Post: "A prisoner sharing a police transport van with Freddie Gray told investigators that he could hear Gray 'banging against the walls' of the vehicle and believed that he 'was intentionally trying to injure himself,' according to a police document obtained by The Washington Post." CW: Will consume Fox "News" coverage for days. ...
... Adam Chandler of the Atlantic: "Jayne Miller, a reporter for WBAL-TV, disputed the prisoner's claims on Twitter. She argues that Baltimore Police Commissioner Anthony Batts told her the second prisoner in the police van said Gray had been 'mostly quiet' during the ride and there had been 'no evidence' of Gray banging his head against the van." ...
... In a discussion with Lawrence O'Donnell of MSNBC, Miller cites her own reporting that completely debunks the claim. "The second prisoner is ony in the van for the last five minutes of the ride..., a full 30 minutes after Gray was loaded in the van." ...
... Blame-the-Victim, Ctd. Mark Puente & Doug Donovan of the Baltimore Sun: "Online reports are swirling that Freddie Gray had spinal surgery shortly before he died in police custody, and had collected a payout in a settlement from a car accident. Those reports -- which raise questions about the injury that led to his death in April 19 --; point to Howard County court records as proof. But court records examined Wednesday by The Baltimore Sun show the case had nothing to do with a car accident or a spine injury. Instead, they are connected to a lawsuit alleging that Gray and his sister were injured by exposure to lead paint." ...
... Terrence McCoy of the Washington Post: "Before his controversial death earlier this month while in police custody..., the life of Freddie Gray was defined by failures in the classroom, run-ins with the law, and an inability to focus on anything for very long. Many of those problems began when he was a child and living in [a] house [with pealing lead paint], according to a 2008 lead poisoning lawsuit filed by Gray and his siblings against the property owner, which resulted in an undisclosed settlement.... Advocates and studies say [lead poisoning] can diminish cognitive function, increase aggression and ultimately exacerbate the cycle of poverty that is already exceedingly difficult to break.... The burden weighs heaviest on the poorestcommunities like the Sandtown-Winchester neighborhood in West Baltimore that produced Freddie Gray." ...
... See Keith Howard's comment in today's thread. ...
... Charles Blow: "We can't roundly condemn violent revolt now while ignoring the violent revolts that have littered this country's history. We can't rush to label violent protesters as 'thugs' while reserving judgment about the violence of police killings until a full investigation has been completed and all the facts are in." Thanks to safari for the link.
Dana Milbank: "The Civil War era's 14th Amendment, granting automatic citizenship to any baby born on American soil, is a proud achievement of the Party of Lincoln. But now House Republicans are talking about abolishing birthright citizenship. A House Judiciary subcommittee took up the question Wednesday afternoon, prompted by legislation sponsored by Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) and 22 other lawmakers that, after nearly 150 years, would end automatic citizenship." Read the whole column.
Donald McNeil of the New York Times: "Rubella, a disease with terrible consequences for unborn children, has finally been eliminated from the Americas, a scientific panel set up by global health authorities announced on Wednesday. The disease, also known as German measles, once infected millions of people in the Western Hemisphere. In a 1964-65 outbreak in the United States, 11,000 fetuses were miscarried, died in the womb or were aborted, and 20,000 babies were born with defects."
Nicholas Kulich & Nicola Clark of the New York Times: "The Federal Aviation Administration raised questions in 2010 about whether it should grant a pilot's license in the United States to Andreas Lubitz, who in March flew a Germanwings jetliner into a French mountainside, but was assured by his doctors in Germany that he had fully recovered from an episode of depression the year before, according to newly released documents.... The release of the information, in response to Freedom of Information Act requests from news organizations, helps to fill in gaps in the timeline of Mr. Lubitz's illness and treatment.... There is also evidence suggesting that Mr. Lubitz might have tried to mislead the F.A.A. about his treatment, initially marking 'no' in response to a question on whether he had ever been treated for mental disorders on a form dated June 2010. Referring to a question number on the form, the file notes, 'changed from N to Y.'"
Presidential Race
Alan Rappeport of the New York Times: "Senator Bernie Sanders, an independent from Vermont, announced Thursday that he was running for president as a Democrat, injecting a progressive voice into the contest and providing Hillary Rodham Clinton with her first official challenger for the party's nomination.... Mr. Sanders issued a statement to supporters that laid out his goals for reducing income inequality, addressing climate change and scaling back the influence of money in politics." ...
... Here's Sanders' interview with the AP's Dave Gram.
Mike McIntire & Jo Becker of the New York Times: "Aides to former President Bill Clinton helped start a Canadian charity that effectively shielded the identities of donors who gave more than $33 million that went to his foundation, despite a pledge of transparency when Hillary Rodham Clinton became secretary of state. The nonprofit, the Clinton Giustra Enterprise Partnership (Canada), operates in parallel to a Clinton Foundation project called the Clinton Giustra Enterprise Partnership, which is expressly named in an agreement Mrs. Clinton signed to make all donors public while she led the State Department. However, the foundation maintains that the Canadian partnership is not bound by that agreement and that under Canadian law contributors' names cannot be made public."
Amy Chozick & Michael Barbaro of the New York Times: "In an unusually impassioned speech, Hillary Rodham Clinton delivered a pointed assessment of race in America on Wednesday, lamenting the recent deaths of young black men and calling for overhauling the 'out-of-balance' criminal justice system on display on the smoke-filled streets of Baltimore. In her first major policy speech since announcing her presidential run, Mrs. Clinton spoke forcefully about the damage done, ticking off the names of the unarmed African-American men who have died at the hands of white police officers in recent months." ...
... Video & the transcript of Clinton's speech is here. ...
... Elias Isquith of Salon: Aside from the fact that she failed to mention that her husband -- and Joe Biden -- "contributed to the mass incarceration she decried in her speech..., those who want to see criminal justice reform and inequality at the center of her campaign have reason to be optimistic.... She consistently tied ... policy tweaks to a broader theme of economic inequality, describing 'talk about smart policing and reforming the criminal justice system' as worthless unless paired with 'talk about what's needed to provide economic opportunity.'"
Frank Rich on various topics, beginning with Baltimore. Rich takes a moment to whack Li'l Randy: "Then we have Rand Paul, who in an interview with the conservative radio host Laura Ingraham yesterday, joked that he was 'glad the train didn't stop' in Baltimore when he passed through it this week. Remember Rand Paul? This is the one Republican presidential hopeful who has been making a point of reaching out to African-Americans. He doesn't seem to realize that not stopping in Baltimore is exactly the problem for him and his peers." ...
... Andrew Rosenthal of the New York Times: "Rand Paul, the Kentucky senator and political aspirant, for instance, chose an interview with the Republican radio host Laura Ingraham the other night to show that he has a) no taste, b) no sense of humor and c) nothing useful to add to the discussion of race.... Mr. Paul's witless joke demonstrates that he's simply not prepared to take on national leadership. Hiding in a moving rail car is not anything remotely like an adequate response to the Baltimore mess from someone who wants to be president."
Beyond the Beltway
Emma Fitzsimmons of the New York Times: "The board of the [New York City] Metropolitan Transportation Authority voted on Wednesday to ban political advertising on New York City subways and buses to avoid the legal challenges it had faced after rejecting some ads with political messages.... The vote followed a lively debate over free speech as dissenting board members and advocacy groups argued that the transit system was a public space that should be a forum for debating political issues.... The change came a week after a federal judge ordered the authority to display an ad produced by a pro-Israel group that the authority argued could be interpreted as a call to violence."
News Lede
Guardian: "A Nasa spacecraft crashed into the planet Mercury on Thursday, ending its four-year mission to explore the planet by creating a new crater on its surface. Out of fuel after more than a decade in space, the robotic Messenger probe slammed into the planet at about 3.26pm ET, on the far side of Mercury and out of sight of telescopes."