The Commentariat -- Dec. 28, 2012
Cliff Notes
Jennifer Steinhauer of the New York Times: President "Obama is expected to invite all four [Congressional leaders] to meet on Friday. In a related development, House Republicans were told to return to Washington on Sunday. Republican senators were planning to convene at the Capitol -- normally somnolent during Christmas week -- to strategize."
The Incoherent President. William Black asks President Obama, "given your warning that the fiscal cliff's austerity would cause a recession, why are you demanding a Grand Bargain (sic, actually the Grand Betrayal) that would inflict austerity for a decade and likely cause multiple recessions and larger deficits?" ...
... Let Them Eat Cake. Charles Pierce writes, not particularly well this time, on essentially the same subject. I'm linking the post for two reasons -- his coining (as far as I know)* of the term "courtier press," and the implied Marie Antoinettesque character of the "chained CPI," which relies on the assumption that if the masses can't afford beef, they'll buy chicken.
* Actually, the coiner may have been Robert Parry, in this 2006 piece "Colbert and the Courtier Press," on Stephen Colbert's performance at the annual White House Correspondents' Dinner. The courtiers were not amused when Colbert lampooned them:
The President makes decisions; he's the decider. The press secretary announces those decisions, and you people of the press type those decisions down. Make, announce, type. Put them through a spell check and go home. Get to know your family again. Make love to your wife. Write that novel you got kicking around in your head. You know, the one about the intrepid Washington reporter with the courage to stand up to the administration. You know --- fiction.
... And, yeah, I know Marie Antoinette did not actually say "Let them eat cake" or anything like it.
Abdication
Brett LoGiurato of Business Insider: Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid is really ticked off at Republicans, especially at Speaker John Boehner, whom Reid describes as running a "dictatorship." Here's Reid, on the Senate floor:
... Update: Reid is right. Boehner will not allow a vote on a middle-class tax-cut measure because he knows it will pass with Democrats & some Republicans voting for it. Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-Maryland) repeated Reid's charge this morning. ...
... MEANWHILE. Lisa Mascaro of the Los Angeles Times: Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell is MIA. "In the Senate, any deal on taxes and spending would be impossible without at least tacit approval from McConnell, given the power afforded the minority under the chamber's complex rules. But an aide said Wednesday that McConnell had not been in contact with any top Democrats...." ...
... CW: so, a complete GOP abdication. Adios, MoFo, It's time that we lay low. As long as Republicans hold power in Congress -- whether by majority control in the House or minority control (filibuster) in the Senate, Congress will be 100 percent dysfunctional, unable to vote, even on bills that the majority of each house favors. (P.S. Seems to me Democrats have pulled this, too.)
Steve Benen notices how thought & "logic" work in Right Wing World.
Jonathan Bernstein accidentally explains why there won't be a budget deal: "... not only are Republicans unwilling to offer specific spending cuts, but they have spent the past two election cycles running against the cuts that Democrats have proposed. Democrats already know that they will be attacked in 2014 for supporting a large tax increase. They simply cannot also be the ones who proposed spending cuts to popular programs, knowing that they'll be attacked for that, too. And, for good measure, they'll surely be attacked for allowing large deficits, too, regardless of what happens now." In short, Republicans are conniving AND irresponsible, & Democrats are sick of playing Charlie Brown to the GOP's Lucy.
Winger Philip Klein of the Examiner has some news for his fellow wingnuts: "If the nation goes over the cliff, the most likely outcome is the worst of both worlds for Republicans. Once some sort of legislation eventually gets passed, taxes will still go up on higher income earners. But additionally, Democrats will appropriate much of Bush's tax policy and Obama will become the great middle class tax cutter." Via Jonathan Bernstein.
"Grande Confusion." In the wake of Mitt Romney's bid for the presidency it is a good idea to remind ourselves that business leaders don't understand government. At all. Howard Schultz, the founder of Starbucks, may know how to turn java into gold, but he does not understand the first thing about the "fiscal cliff," -- which he has ass-backwards -- as Suzy Khimm of the Washington Post lays out. Khimm notes, "That's why Secretary Tim Geithner explained that going over the fiscal cliff would actually buy us more time before we hit the debt ceiling." Geithner's explanation, and every other accurate one, went right over Schultz's aerated grande noggin. But then Schultz gets his information from Washington's inflated boob jobs Bowles & Simpson. ...
... Jonathan Cohn of The New Republic: "Washington doesn't need two parties that can 'come together.' It needs one party to 'get it together.' Maybe Schultz should put that on a coffee cup." ...
... ** If Schultz wants to know why Congress won't "come together" -- he should quit forcing his baristas to inscribe his nonsensical political messages on coffee cups & read Nate Silver: "In 1992, there were 103 members of the House of Representatives elected from what might be called swing districts: those in which the margin in the presidential race was within five percentage points of the national result. But ... I estimate that there are only 35 such Congressional districts remaining, barely a third of the total 20 years ago. Instead, the number of landslide districts -- those in which the presidential vote margin deviated by at least 20 percentage points from the national result -- has roughly doubled.... Most members of the House now come from hyperpartisan districts where they face essentially no threat of losing their seat to the other party. Instead, primary challenges, especially for Republicans, may be the more serious risk."
AND Joe Lieberman is still is smarmy, lying SOB. Steve Benen: Lieberman is again blaming "both sides" for Congressional dysfunction. "... consider recent events: the fiscal talks have broken down because Republicans won't compromise and accept meaningful concessions; the farm bill and the Violence Against Women Act are stuck because Republicans won't vote on them; efforts to reduce gun violence face extremely long odds because Republicans are beholden to the NRA; a U.N. treaty on disabilities was killed because Republicans believed extremist conspiracy theories; the process of filling President Obama's second term cabinet is stalled because of Republican smear campaigns; and another debt-ceiling crisis is underway because Republicans are threatening to hurt Americans on purpose unless Democrats pay a steep ransom."
E. J. Dionne: "... given the conservatives' habit of walking away even from their own ideas (the [health insurance] exchanges, for example) and of rejecting progressive efforts to save money, is it any wonder that liberals suspect them of greater interest in dismantling programs than in making them more efficient? We won't find genuine common ground on deficits until we resolve this dilemma."
New York Times Editors: "New legislation proposed by Senator Dianne Feinstein in response to the Newtown, Conn., murders would provide a far more effective ban on military-style assault weapons than the loophole-riddled law that lapsed in 2004."
Alex Pareene of Salon: "Congressional dysfunction and extremism may yet plunge the nation into an entirely avoidable recession, but at least Americans will likely be able to sleep at night secure in the knowledge that our lawmakers at least sprang into action, at the last possible minute, to preserve the government's right to constantly spy on everyone without telling anyone about it. In all likelihood, the Senate will vote today to reauthorize the FISA Amendments Act for a few years, just before it was scheduled to expire. The House reauthorized it all the way back in September, but the world's most deliberative body likes to take its time (plus Ron Wyden placed a hold on the bill until Senate leaders agreed to at least have a debate on proposed amendments to the Amendments)."
Steven Rosenfeld of AlterNet, in Salon: "Days after California's liberal Democratic Senator Barbara Boxer gave an impassioned floor speech saying that big steps must be taken to stop gun violence that is killing 87 people a day across America, she proposed a bill to give governors power to deploy National Guard troops in public schools -- or assign them to local police departments, freeing them to put police in schools." CW: thanks, Sen. Boxer, for lending credibility to the NRA. ...
... Free David Gregory. For those of you who are deeply concerned that Greggers will wind up behind bars, Josh Voorhees of Slate has the latest on David Gregory's troubles over waving a gun magazine prop in front of the NRA's Wayne LaPierre. CW: Note how the conversation has shifted from LaPierre's crazy ideas to Gregory's run-in with the law & Barbara Boxer's crazy ideas. Don't say the right doesn't still know how to drive the conversation into the ditch. ...
... CW: we should be talking instead about posts like this one from Matt Gertz of Media Matters: "During that interview, LaPierre said that a major flaw in the background check system is that states have failed to input mental health records, allowing people who have mental health issues that would prohibit them from buying a firearm to nonetheless pass a background check. But moments later, he expressed opposition to extending the background check system to all gun sales, maintaining a loophole that would allow the mentally ill to continue to obtain firearms."
James Broder of the New York Times: "Lisa P. Jackson is stepping down as administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency after a four-year tenure that began with high hopes of sweeping action to address climate change and other environmental ills but ended with a series of rear-guard actions to defend the agency against challenges from industry, Republicans in Congress and, at times, the Obama White House.... Ms. Jackson's departure comes as many in the environmental movement are questioning Mr. Obama's commitment to dealing with climate change and other environmental problems." ...
... Juliet Eilperin of the Washington Post reviews Jackson's tenure at EPA.
Garrett Epps of the Atlantic: "... Common Cause v. Biden, was a constitutional challenge to Senate rules allowing a minority of senators to prevent a vote, or even a debate, on any measure they disagree with. Only a 'cloture' vote of 60 senators can move a filibustered measure forward.... U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan ... slapped [it] down.... [The] lawsuit ... would have offered the Senate's majority an easy way out of its agonizing dilemma." ...
... AND Jonathan Bernstein really wants you to know that "Cloture votes do not equal filibusters."
Paul Krugman looks at the long-term prospects for economic growth & says -- stay tuned. He's thinking about it. Krugman's column -- titled "Is Growth Over?" conforms to my headline thesis: if the headline is written in the form of a question, don't expect a meaningful answer.
Mark Arsenault of the Boston Globe: "US Representative Edward Markey, dean of the state's Washington delegation, will run in 2013 for the US Senate seat expected to open with the nomination of US Senator John Kerry to head the State Department. Markey, 66, a Malden Democrat elected to the House in 1976, is the first prominent candidate to declare a run for Kerry's seat, which will be filled through a special election early next summer, probably in June." ...
... David Bernstein, writing before Markey's announcement, prognosticated on how the Senate election will go down. So far, so good.
LeAnne Gendreau of NBC Connecticut: "The FBI has arrested a woman, [Nouel Alba of the Bronx,] who was the subject of a Today Show story about alleged scams exploiting the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Last week, NBC's Jeff Rossen reported that Alba posted a solicitation on Facebook within hours of the shooting, identifying herself as an aunt of Noah Pozner, a 6-year-old victim. Later ... she asked for funds to pay for the funeral, Rossen reported."
Local News
Ignore the Voters. Paul Egan of the Detroit Free Press: "Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder has signed a new emergency manager law that will take effect in the spring for financially troubled local governments and school districts, his spokeswoman said today.Approval by the Legislature of the Local Financial Stability and Choice Act during the recent lame duck session was controversial because voters on Nov. 6 repealed the former emergency manager law, Public Act 4 of 2011. The new law continues one of the most controversial provisions of PA 4 -- the ability for emergency managers appointed by the state to amend or scrap collective bargaining agreements." ...
... "An Affront to Michigan Women." New York Times Editors: "Despite clear public support for women's reproductive rights, Michigan's Republican-controlled Legislature used the just-ended lame-duck session to ram through harmful measures eliminating insurance coverage of abortions and imposing medically unnecessary regulations on providers of safe and legal abortion care." The editors urge Gov. Rick Snyder to veto the anti-women bills. Good luck with that.
News Ledes
AP: Dawn Nguyen, "a 24-year-old woman, was arrested Friday and charged in connection with the Christmas Eve ambush slaying of two volunteer firefighters responding to a house fire in upstate New York.... The state charge is connected to the purchase of an AR-15 semiautomatic rifle and a 12-gauge shotgun that William Spengler had with him Monday when firefighters Michael Chiapperini and Tomasz Kaczowka were gunned down."
New York Times: "Jean S. Harris, the private-school headmistress whose 1981 trial for the murder of a prominent Scarsdale, N.Y., physician galvanized a nation mulling feminist perspectives with its story of vengeance by an aging woman scorned, died on Sunday at an assisted-living facility in New Haven. She was 89."
AP: "As a the muted ends of a powerful winter storm that has killed more than a dozen people plodded through the Northeast, many in Arkansas were seeking warmth and shelter against the cold prospect of life without electricity into the new year."
AP: Russian "President Vladimir Putin on Friday signed a bill banning Americans from adopting Russian children, part of a harsh response to a U.S. law targeting Russians deemed to be human rights violators. Although some top Russian officials including the foreign minister openly opposed the bill and Putin himself had been noncommittal about it last week, he signed it less than 24 hours after receiving it from Parliament, where both houses passed it overwhelmingly."
Reuters: "Russia urged the Syrian government on Friday to act on its stated readiness for dialogue with its opponents, throwing its weight behind a diplomatic push to end a 21-month-old conflict in Syria."
AP: "North Korea has repaired flood damage at its nuclear test facility and could conduct a quick atomic explosion if it chose, though water streaming out of a test tunnel may cause problems, analysis of recent satellite photos indicates. Washington and others are bracing for the possibility that if punished for a successful long-range rocket launch on Dec. 12 that the U.N. considers a cover for a banned ballistic missile test, North Korea's next step might be its third nuclear test."
New York Times: "The Chinese government issued new rules on Friday requiring Internet users to provide their real names to service providers, while assigning Internet companies greater responsibility for deleting forbidden postings and reporting them to the authorities."
Worse than Bibi. Reuters: "Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud party is set to win a parliamentary election on January 22 although the popularity of a far-right party opposed to Palestinian statehood is growing, polls showed on Friday. Two out of three surveys showed the right-wing Likud losing voters to political newcomer Naftali Bennett's religious party Bayit Yehudi (Jewish Home)and to a fractured center-left bloc."