The Commentariat -- Nov. 14, 2016
Afternoon Update:
A number of contributors have been crediting Akhilleus for coming up with the term "confederates" to describe the right-wing party & its followers. That didn't sound right to me, so I spent way too much time checking. Akhilleus has illuminated hundreds of good ideas here on Reality Chex. But the originator of the term "confederates" was actually Monoloco, who suggested it in January 2015.
Sam Roberts of the New York Times: "Gwen Ifill, an award-winning television journalist for NBC and PBS, former reporter for The New York Times and author who moderated vice-presidential debates in 2004 and 2008, died on Monday in Washington. She was 61. Her death, at a hospice facility, was announced by Sara Just, executive producer of 'PBS NewsHour.' The cause was cancer, PBS said." A full obituary is to follow. Thanks to NJC for the lead.-- CW
Simon Tisdale of the Guardian: "When [President Obama] makes his final visit to Europe this week, in what had been planned as a triumphant farewell tour, Obama's awkward job is to reassure nervous allies that a Trump presidency will not be as bad as they fear." CW: That would be a betrayal of his beliefs -- and of reality.
Steve M. on how NPR is whitewashing the Steve Bannon appointment: "NPR's coverage of the election and its aftermath has been awful in recent days.... NPR's preferred approach seems to be letting loyalists come on one at a time, and allowing them to spin and spin and spin." ...
... CW: NPR is a broadcast operation; it relies on its share of the public airwaves (and to a very small extent, public funding) to get its stories out. Donald Trump, by virtue of his appointing a friendly FCC commissioner, will soon control the public airwaves. (Conspiracy theorist Alex Jones is probably polishing his resume'.) What you're hearing in NPR "news reporting" -- and no doubt soon in other non-political programming -- is self-preservation, not accurate news coverage. Expect NPR to become a broadcasters' Pravda on the Potomac. This is voluntary co-option. The commercial broadcast networks will do the same.
Sewell Chan & Christina Anderson of the New York Times: "Six years after the Swedish authorities opened an investigation into a rape accusation made against Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks founder, he faced questioning about the matter on Monday. The questions were prepared by prosecutors in Sweden, where an arrest warrant for Mr. Assange was issued in 2010, but were posed by a prosecutor from Ecuador under an agreement the two countries made in August. Ecuador granted Mr. Assange political asylum in 2012, and the interview occurred at the Ecuadorean Embassy in London. Mr. Assange has lived in the embassy since June 2012 to avoid extradition to Sweden over the rape accusation." -- CW ...
... The Guardian story, by Esther Addley & David Crouch, is here.
*****
CW: If you missed Kate McKinnon's "SNL" cold open, do take time to watch it; it's embedded in yesterday's Commentariat.
** Trump Names White Supremacist/Anti-Semite to Top White House Post. Michael Shear, et al., of the New York Times: "... Donald J. Trump on Sunday chose Reince Priebus, the chairman of the Republican National Committee and a loyal campaign adviser, to be his White House chief of staff, turning to a Washington insider whose friendship with the House speaker, Paul D. Ryan, could help secure early legislative victories. In selecting Mr. Priebus, Mr. Trump passed over Stephen K. Bannon, the right-wing media provocateur. But he named Mr. Bannon his senior counselor and chief West Wing strategist, signaling an embrace of the fringe ideology long advanced by Mr. Bannon and a continuing disdain for his party's establishment.... In a statement Sunday afternoon, the transition team emphasized that the two men would work 'as equal partners to transform the federal government.'... The official statement mentioned Mr. Bannon first.” Emphasis added. -- CW ...
... Elise Viebeck & Katie Zezima of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump faces a growing backlash against his decision to name campaign chairman and former head of Breitbart News Stephen K. Bannon as chief strategist at the White House, a choice critics believe will empower white nationalists. A chorus of advocacy groups, commentators and congressional Democrats denounced Bannon as a proponent of racist, anti-Semitic and misogynistic views as Trump began his first full week as president-elect.... A spokesman for Trump accused critics and the media of trying to 'divide people' following the election when they raise questions about Bannon's views and history." -- CW ...
... Jose DelReal of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump's decision to appoint Stephen Bannon as his chief strategist in the White House has drawn a sharp rebuke from political strategists who see in Bannon a controversial figure too closely associated with the 'alt-right' movement, which white nationalists have embraced.... 'Stephen Bannon was the main driver behind Breitbart becoming a white ethno-nationalist propaganda mill, the [Southern Poverty] [L]aw [C]enter wrote via Twitter in its first statements on Bannon's elevation." -- CW...
... Oops! Newt Didn't Get the Memo.* Kristine Guerra of the Washington Post: "Newt Gingrich blasted the notion that Donald Trump's campaign and rhetoric catered to what's called the alt-right movement, which rejects establishment conservatism and spreads its far-right ideology online. 'It's garbage,' the former House speaker and a Trump adviser told CBS's John Dickerson on 'Face the Nation' on Sunday when asked to comment on the alt-right movement, whose members have shown support for Trump. 'Donald Trump is a mainstream conservative who wants to profoundly take on the left. The left is infuriated that anybody wants to challenge their moral superiority,' Gingrich said." -- CW
... * Or he did get the memo but thinks he can pretend Bannon is a mild-mannered reporter. ...
... ** Paul Waldman: "There has been way too much euphemizing about Bannon, so let's talk plainly. He's not just a 'controversial' figure who ran a 'provocative' web site. He is one of the foremost drivers of the spread of white nationalism in the United States today, and Breitbart is a firehose of thinly veiled racism and anti-Semitism, spewing its endless supply of poison into our politics.... And now to the cluelessness:... The man ran for president for a year and a half, and is surprised that the presidency is such a big job. Meanwhile, his aides were under the impression that the Obama staffers would stick around and be working for them now. This is appalling, but it shouldn't be surprising. Those of us who actually contemplated a Trump presidency during the campaign were particularly disturbed not just by Trump's ignorance, but also by the fact that it was accompanied by a certainty that he knew everything he needed to know, despite the fact that he knew virtually nothing." (See also Margaret Hartmann's report, linked below.) -- CW ...
... Zachary Pleat of Media Matters provides a good overview of Bannon's racist, misogynist, xenophobic, anti-Semite, anti-LGBT views, as expressed in his hate site Breitbart "News." -- CW ...
... Kim Bellware of the Huffington Post: "Breitbart has propagated conspiracy theories, like Planned Parenthood having Nazi ties or Clinton aide Huma Abedin being a spy for Saudi Arabia. The website traffics in misogynist and racist stories; it frames women who push back against harassment or gender bias as weak and incompetent and portrays people of color and immigrants as inherently criminal. Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.) spokesman Adam Jentleson said Trump's choice of Bannon 'signals that White Supremacists will be represented at the highest levels in Trump's White House.' 'It is easy to see why the KKK views Trump as their champion,'...." -- CW
Emily Schultheis of CBS News: "... Donald Trump said in a wide-ranging interview with '60 Minutes' that his role of appointing a Supreme Court justice is 'very important' -- and that he plans to appoint pro-life justices. 'I'm pro-life,' he said. 'The judges will be pro-life.'... When [interviewer Lesley] Stahl followed up on the question, asking whether it's okay that some women might have to travel to other states to receive abortions, Trump said there's a 'long way to go' before discussing that.... During the third presidential debate, he suggested that third-trimester abortions were currently legal and that Clinton supported allowing them -- both things which are not true. Trump added that his Supreme Court nominees would also be 'very pro-Second Amendment.'... As for same-sex marriage, Trump said after the Supreme Court ruling last year it's the law of the land -- and that he is 'fine' with that being the case." -- CW
Ben Jacobs of the Guardian: "... Donald Trump returned to Twitter on Sunday morning, to attack a familiar target: the New York Times." -- CW ...
... Daniel Politi of Slate: "... this latest attack came shortly after Trump told 60 Minutes that he will be 'restrained' on how he uses Twitter." CW: There's "restrained" and there's "restrained." In this case, I think "restrained" mean, "didn't wrap anti-NYT tweets in Star of David or hangman's noose." ...
... Brian Stelter & Jill Disis: "On Sunday morning, Trump tweeted: 'Wow, the @nytimes is losing thousands of subscribers because of their very poor and highly inaccurate coverage of the "Trump phenomena.'" Trump did not cite any evidence to back up his claim. And the Times flatly says it is not true. The newspaper crunched the numbers on Sunday morning.... Then it responded to Trump, naturally, on Twitter. 'Fact: surge in new subscriptions, print & digital, with trends, stops & starts, 4 X better than normal,' the Times said.... On Friday, the newspaper's publisher, Arthur Sulzberger, wrote a letter to subscribers saying 'let's pause for a moment on those famous instructions that Adolph S. Ochs left for us: to cover the news without fear or favor. As Donald Trump begins preparing for his new administration, those words have rarely felt more important,' Sulzberger said. In a followup tweet, Trump wrongly characterized the letter as an 'apology' for earlier coverage." -- CW
Amy Wang of the Washington Post: "In a '60 Minutes' interview scheduled to air Sunday..., Donald Trump said he planned to immediately deport 2 million to 3 million undocumented immigrants who 'have criminal records' after his inauguration next January.... According to The Washington Post Fact Checker, Trump likely gets these estimates from a Department of Homeland Security fiscal 2013 report saying there were 1.9 million 'removable criminal aliens.' However, that figure includes undocumented immigrants and people who are lawful permanent residents, or those who have temporary visas." CW: In other words, these are people whose "crime," at most, is being here, not violent criminals.
Michael Birnbaum of the Washington Post: "Perplexed foreign ministers from the European Union nations met Sunday to try to assess the election of Donald Trump..., underlining the uncertainty for America's closest allies over issues as wide-ranging as Iran, Russia and climate change. The emergency dinner gathering was a measure of how suddenly the U.S.-Europe relationship has been cast into disarray by the election of a man most European leaders openly campaigned against. The E.U. is deeply dependent on U.S. cooperation for a host of European priorities, many of which Trump called into question on the campaign trail." -- CW ...
... Annals of "Journalism," Ha Ha Ha. Christopher Dickey & Asawin Suebsaeng of the Daily Beast: "Breitbart, which currently has operations in London and Jerusalem, certainly has plans to expand in France and Germany with new bureaus to cultivate and promote the populist-nationalist lines there. Bannon, elevated Sunday night from the head of Trump's favorite public-relations outfit masquerading as news outlet to a White House senior counselor, is right now the direct line between the European far-right and Donald J. Trump, leader of the free world." CW: Of course Trump & Bannon have plans to dismantle the "free" part of "free world."
Paul Krugman: "... the consequences of the new regime's awfulness won't be apparent right away. Opponents of that regime need to be prepared for the real possibility that good things will happen to bad people, at least for a while." -- CW
Jonathan Chait: "Whatever signs of normality [Trump] has given since Tuesday's triumph are, thus far, purely superficial.... It is now within the realm of imagining that the United States will come to resemble some sort of illiberal democracy or quasi-democracy -- Berlusconi's Italy or, eventually, even Putin's Russia.... The man who thought he was through with politics has, it turns out, one more essential role left: Beginning next year, Obama needs to rally the opposition, to community-organize his coalition, and to exploit his celebrity to make the case for saving his legacy.... Trump's election is one of the greatest disasters in American history.... The proper response is steely resolve to wage the fight of our lives." -- CW ...
... The Drumpf Whisperer. Margaret Hartmann of New York: "The Wall Street Journal reported on Sunday that President Obama 'plans to spend more time with his successor than presidents typically do' because he realized during their meeting last week that Trump 'needs more guidance.' Per the Journal:
During their private White House meeting on Thursday, Mr. Obama walked his successor through the duties of running the country, and Mr. Trump seemed surprised by the scope, said people familiar with the meeting. Trump aides were described by those people as unaware that the entire presidential staff working in the West Wing had to be replaced at the end of Mr. Obama's term. -- CW
Melanie Eversley of USA Today: The post-election uptick in hate crimes is greater than what occurred following 9/11, according to hate-crime watchers like the SPLC. CW: I suspect this is because there are more groups to "hate" and the targets are ubiquitous, whereas the Muslim population was relatively concentrated & comparatively small. There's not a town in the U.S. that doesn't have women to victimize, for instance. ...
... Daniel Politi lays out a partial list of post-election racist incidents, which are occurring around the country. See also Ken W.'s comment at the top of today's thread. Clearly, Trump's election has emboldened the deplorables, as if they weren't bold enough already. ...
... Casey Quinlan of Think Progress: "In the days following the election, students are already invoking the name of ... [Donald Trump] while they spread white supremacist messages." -- CW
** Henry Grabar of Slate: "For nearly half a century, Democrats have worked to position themselves as America's metropolitan party.... Trump won dominant support in rural America. He outran Romney by more than 40 percent in large swaths of the Midwest. His rural success was not confined to the Rust Belt.... The metropolis has economic power but little political power. The American countryside has limited economic power but vast political power.... When politicians inveigh against 'urban America,' they're often stoking their constituents' race-based fears. But 'urban' is now also code for class, power, money, and the Democratic Party.... Americans are less geographically mobile than at any point since 1948. Young Americans are not going to sacrifice their dreams to accommodate the country's byzantine electoral system, which was designed to grant the franchise exclusively to landowners." -- CW
"Trump's America." CW: Just two weeks ago, a reader snapped a picture of Union Square, where a group of a dozen or so Clinton supporters gathered. Here's what Union Square looked like Saturday, courtesy of the same reader:
I love the poorly educated! -- Donald Trump, Nevada Republican primary victory speech, Feb. 23 ...
... Matt Taibbi of Rolling Stone: "The Democratic Party's failure to keep Donald Trump out of the White House in 2016 will go down as one of the all-time examples of insular arrogance.... But the party's willful blindness symbolized a similar arrogance across the American intellectual elite. Trump's election was a true rebellion, directed at anyone perceived to be part of 'the establishment.' The target group included political leaders, bankers, industrialists, academics, Hollywood actors, and, of course, the media. And we all closed our eyes to what we didn't want to see.... America is like a giant manor estate where the aristocrats don't know they're aristocrats and the peasants imagine themselves undiscovered millionaires." -- CW
AND Trump Born in Pakistan, Not Eligible to be U.S. President! Times of Israel: "After years leading the false charge that President Barack Obama was born outside of the United States..., Donald Trump is facing his own minor 'birtherism' moment, with a Pakistani television network claiming the New Yorker was born in Pakistan.... The report, not unlike the claims once made against Obama, appears to have originated with social media posts.... According to Neo News, Trump was born as Dawood Ibrahim Khan in the now-Taliban-controlled Waziristan region of the country in 1954. After his parents were killed in a car accident, a British Indian Army captain took little Dawood to London, where the Trump family later adopted him and brought him to America, the report claimed.... Neo News even provided a photo of the alleged young Trump, wearing what appears to be traditional Pakistani boys' garb." CW: I sure hope the NYT is following up. By 2020, 69 percent of Democrats should be convinced Trump is not a natural-born citizen.
Josh Marshall: "Paul Ryan ... just said he will try to rush [the demise of Medicare] through early next year while repealing Obamacare.... Ryan claims that Obamacare has put Medicare under deeper financial stress. Precisely the opposite is true. And it's so straightforward Ryan unquestionably knows this. The Affordable Care Act actually extended Medicare's solvency by more than a decade....Ryan says current beneficiaries will be allowed to keep their Medicare. Says. But after the cord is cut between current and future beneficiaries, everything is fair game. For those entering the system, Ryan proposes phasing out Medicare and replacing it private insurance with subsidies to help seniors afford the private insurance.... You'll hear lots of people calling this 'reform' and other catchwords. But Medicare is a single payer, universal health care system. Replacing it with private insurance means getting rid of it." -- CW ...
What people don't realize is, because of Obamacare, Medicare is going broke. -- -- House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.), interview with Fox News Channel, Nov. 10
It's bad enough that Ryan, like many politicians, uses imprecise rhetoric such as 'broke'.... But the House speaker really went off the rails when he said on national television that Obamacare is making the program go broke. That’s the exact opposite of what happened. -- Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post
News Lede
Guardian: "New Zealand battled severe storms and violent aftershocks as the country struggled to recover from a devastating earthquake that swallowed roads, twisted railway lines and left towns and cities smashed and deserted." -- CW