The Commentariat -- July 7, 2016
Missy Ryan & Karen DeYoung of the Washington Post: "President Obama announced revised troop plans for Afghanistan on Wednesday, keeping 8,400 U.S. troops in the country when he steps down early next year, the clearest indication yet of his inability to end the long war there.... He had hoped to leave a force of 5,500 in early 2017." -- CW ...
Mike Lillis of the Hill: "Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) had hoped to move an 'anti-terror' package in response to last month's mass shooting in Orlando -- a package that included legislation designed to make it tougher for suspected terrorists to buy firearms. But Republican leadership is facing opposition from the members of the conservative Freedom Caucus, who deem the measure a violation of constitutional protections. Because Democrats are overwhelmingly opposed to the bill, judging it too lax, Ryan and GOP leaders don't have the 218 votes needed to move the bill through the lower chamber." -- CW
Linda Greenhouse: "The takeaway from the term that ended last week seems to be that by the time the Supreme Court, short-handed and stumbling in the wake of Justice Antonin Scalia's death, finally got its act together at the end of June, it had -- lo and behold -- turned liberal. Count me a skeptic.... To reject a conservative extreme doesn't make the court liberal. Rather, it puts the court -- increasingly over the dissent of the chief justice, it's worth noting -- in the zone of mainstream reasonableness." -- CW
Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. Michael Grynbaum & John Koblin of the New York Times: "Gretchen Carlson, the longtime Fox News anchor, filed a lawsuit on Wednesday saying that Roger Ailes, the powerful chairman of Fox News, fired her from the network last month after she refused his sexual advances and complained to him about discriminatory treatment in the newsroom.... The lawsuit ... portrays the Fox chairman as a serial sexual harasser, charging that he ogled Ms. Carlson in his office, called her 'sexy' and frequently made sexually charged comments about her physical appearance. Ms. Carlson ... charges that during a meeting last fall to discuss her concerns about what she considered ill treatment, Mr. Ailes told her: 'I think you and I should have had a sexual relationship a long time ago and then you'd be good and better and I'd be good and better.'" Story includes copy of the complaint. -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Louis Nelson of Politico: "Fox News CEO Roger Ailes is denying allegations made in a bombshell lawsuit Wednesday that he sexually harassed a former on-air host for the network, Gretchen Carlson.... Minutes [before Ailes issued a statement -- 'defamatory ... offensive ... wholly without merit ... will be defended vigorously,' etc. --], Fox News' parent company, 21st Century Fox, issued its own statement announcing an internal review into Carlson's allegations -- an unprecedented move that also extended to her former 'Fox & Friends' co-host Steve Doocy, who was not named in the lawsuit." -- CW ...
... Brian Stelter of CNN, in an interview: "I just spoke with one of the attorneys involved in Carlson's suit. They say that ten women have called the law firm today, wanting to speak with the law firm because they say they also have stories to share about treatment by Roger Ailes. I want to be careful with that though because that doesn't mean they are alleging anything, any wrongdoing, and they are not suing, Right now it is only Carlson who is suing." -- CW
Presidential Race
Cristiano Lima of Politico: "Bernie Sanders confirmed on Wednesday night that he is in discussions with the Hillary Clinton campaign about a potential endorsement of her candidacy, adding that he anticipates a 'coming together' of the two campaigns. Appearing on MSNBC's 'All In With Chris Hayes,' Sanders was pointedly asked whether mounting reports that he is finally getting ready to endorse his longstanding Democratic primary rival had any validity. 'You're not denying the report that there are talks about a possible endorsement?' Hayes asked. Sanders replied: 'That's correct.'" -- CW ...
... James Downie of the Washington Post: "... the draft 2016 version [of the Democratic party platform] leaked Friday shifts noticeably leftward from its 2012 counterpart in both policy and language. While not yet set in stone, the change is an encouraging sign that activists' years of work are paying off and that the party is embracing an agenda that speaks to the concerns of millions of Americans who have too often been forgotten in mainstream political debate. From the opening of the 2016 draft platform, one can see the rhetorical fingerprints of progressive movements, especially Black Lives Matter and the insurgent presidential campaign of Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.)." -- CW
Michael Shear of the New York Times: "The investigation into Hillary Clinton's email server is over, Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch said on Wednesday, issuing a brief written statement that she had accepted the F.B.I.'s recommendation that no one should be charged in the case that has engulfed Mrs. Clinton's presidential ambitions for more than a year." -- CW
"Hillary Clinton's E-mail Was Probably Hacked, Experts Say." David Sanger of the New York Times: FBI Director James "Comey described, in fairly blistering terms, a set of email practices that left Mrs. Clinton's systems wide open to Russian and Chinese hackers, and an array of others.... 'Reading between the lines and following Comey's logic, it does sound as if the F.B.I. believes a compromise of Clinton's email is more likely than not,' said Adam Segal..., who studies cyberissues at the Council on Foreign Relations.... Until Mr. Comey spoke, Mrs. Clinton and her campaign have said that her server -- there were actually several, in succession -- was never hacked." -- CW ...
... C-SPAN is carrying James Comey's testimony live, beginning at 10 am ET, on the CSPAN3 channel & on CSPAN-Radio. The radio page also has links to phone apps. The Washington Post also has a livefeed on its online front page. CW: I almost never watch or listen to CSPAN, but I'll likely make an exception today, if time & circumstance allow. ...
... Comey & Elijah Cummings shot down the notion (promulgated by Trump & other Republicans) that Petraeus was prosecuted for "far less" than what Clinton did. I'll get up a video of this later. Uh-oh, Comey called Clinton "negligent." He's a lawyer; he knows what that means. ...
... The New York Times is liveblogging the hearing. -- CW ...
... David Herszenhorn & Jonathan Martin of the New York Times: "The F.B.I. director, James B. Comey, will testify before Congress on Thursday to explain his decision to recommend no criminal charges against Hillary Clinton.... If he makes a convincing case for his decision on Thursday before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, it could make Republicans look foolish.... Democrats were quick to accuse the Republicans of refusing to accept the F.B.I.'s recommendation, despite past praise for Mr. Comey.
"... The Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell of Kentucky..., focused Wednesday on raising doubts about Mrs. Clinton's trustworthiness. He said Mrs. Clinton's statements to the F.B.I. should be made public to compare with her prior remarks. 'There's no particular penalty for lying to the public, unless the public gets tired of it, but there is a real penalty for lying to the F.B.I.,' Mr. McConnell said at a news conference at the Capitol. Mr. McConnell deflected a question ... about whether he believed Mr. Trump was qualified to handle classified information." -- CW ...
... David Herszenhorn: "... James B. Comey, will go before Congress on Thursday to explain his decision to recommend no criminal charges against Hillary Clinton, a House committee chairman announced Wednesday morning.... The House speaker, Paul D. Ryan, said that Mrs. Clinton should be barred from receiving classified information -- an extraordinary recommendation even if it is certain to be ignored by the Obama administration. In addition, Attorney General Loretta Lynch will appear Tuesday before the House Judiciary Committee, and that committee's chairman, Bob Goodlatte of Virginia, made it clear he would focus on Ms. Lynch's impromptu meeting with former President Bill Clinton, ahead of the F.B.I.'s announcement." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ..." ...
... Jordan Fabian of the Hill: "The White House on Wednesday brushed aside House Speaker Paul Ryan's (R-Wis.) call to block Hillary Clinton from receiving classified intelligence briefings as punishment for the FBI's probe into her use of a private email server while secretary of State. White House press secretary Josh Earnest said it's a 'longstanding tradition' for major party presidential nominees to receive such briefings.... 'What the Office of the Director of National Intelligence [DNI] has indicated is that they expect those briefings to move forward after the party conventions.... We should leave those decisions in the hands of our intelligence professionals and not risk them being sullied by the political debate.'... Earnest noted that he's given a similar response to questions about presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump's fitness to receive classified briefings." -- CW
Julian Hattem of the Hill: "Furious congressional Republicans are launching a multipronged attack against the FBI and Hillary Clinton. A total of five congressional committees will either hold hearings with high-profile law enforcement officials over the next week or have already begun inquiries to the FBI about its investigation of the former secretary of State." -- CW ...
... Gail Collins: "In his big press appearance Tuesday, F.B.I. Director James Comey took the now-familiar prosecutorial path of smearing the target he couldn't nail. But the bottom line was that Clinton had used less-than-secure private email servers rather than the State Department system, which was the proper procedure, albeit possibly even less less-than-secure. Worse, she did not tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth when she was cornered. It's a problem for campaign strategists, but not much of a surprise for voters." -- CW
Abby Phillip & Anne Gearan of the Washington Post: "Hillary Clinton came [to Atlantic City, New Jersey,] Wednesday in an attempt to turn the spotlight away from her handling of classified emails and back on rival Donald Trump's controversial business practices.... [Clinton] focused intently on everything but the email issue, with a speech bashing Trump and a major policy shift toward the free-college pledge promised by her primary rival, Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont. Here in this resort town where Trump built casinos that went bankrupt, Clinton pointed to one of the shuttered locations as an example of what she portrayed as a record of selfish and unethical business practices." -- CW ...
... Matt Flegenheimer of the New York Times: "Hillary Clinton's campaign announced plans on Wednesday to eliminate college tuition at in-state public colleges and universities for families with annual incomes under $125,000 -- a significant nod to a core position of Senator Bernie Sanders, who had pledged to make tuition at public institutions free for all students." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Scott Wong of the Hill: "Donald Trump will meet with Republican lawmakers on Capitol Hill Thursday morning in a last-ditch effort to unify a fractured GOP two weeks before the party's national convention in Cleveland. Trump's back-to-back meetings -- first with House Republicans at the Capitol Hill Club, then with Senate Republicans at their campaign headquarters -- will take place amid growing anxiety among the GOP elite over whether the brash New York billionaire will be a drag on vulnerable down-ballot candidates this fall." -- CW
... Matthew Nussbaum of Politico: "Donald Trump blasted Hillary Clinton's use of a private email server in a speech in Ohio Wednesday night but spent almost as much time re-visiting the controversies that have dogged his campaign and distracted from his opponent's legal woes.... He said he regretted removing a tweet that was widely criticized as anti-Semitic.... Appearing with possible vice-presidential pick Newt Gingrich, Trump blamed the media for the uproar. 'When they told me the Star of David I said, "You've got to be kidding, how sick are they?" They're the ones with the bad tendencies when they think that way,' Trump said. 'These people are sick, folks. I'm telling you, they're sick.'" -- CW ...
... Update. A "Rambling and Somewhat Manic-Sounding Address." Maggie Haberman, et al., of the New York Times: "Often shouting..., Donald J. Trump on Wednesday offered a defiant defense of his campaign's decision to publish an image widely viewed as anti-Semitic -- saying he regretted deleting it -- and vigorously reaffirmed his praise of Saddam Hussein, the murderous Iraqi dictator.... It was a striking display of self-sabotage from a presumptive presidential nominee and underscored the limitations of Mr. Trump's scattershot approach during the Republican primaries -- not to mention how difficult he often makes it for his campaign team to control him." -- CW
We shouldn't have destabilized -- Saddam Hussein was a bad guy. Right? He was a bad guy. Really bad guy. But you know what, he did well. He killed terrorists. He did that so good. -- Donald Trump, speech in North Carolina, July 5
Hussein was no opponent of terrorists, certainly in the eyes of the West. Perhaps Trump is referring to Hussein's fight against internal religious extremist movements that he viewed as a threat to his regime -- a part of his overall suppression of dissent. But Trump's description -- that Hussein 'killed terrorists,' and did it 'so well' or was 'so good' at it -- is just not credible, especially given the overwhelming evidence of Hussein's long-standing record of supporting (financially and operationally) international terrorist groups. -- Michelle Lee of the Washington Post
Margaret Hartmann of New York: "It's time to reconsider the possibility that Donald Trump is a secret Hillary Clinton supporter, as opposed to merely a man whose campaign is a garbage fire." On a day when the story should have been Clinton's 'extremely careless' handling of secret correspondence, Trump took time out to praise Saddam Hussein. Trump's "admiration of Hussein is no secret. He's made the same point many times, dating back to at least 2004, when he told the Dallas Morning News, 'No matter how much you hate Saddam Hussein, and obviously he was a horror show, he kept terrorists out of Iraq.'... Now suddenly Saddam Hussein was trending on Twitter, and replacing headlines about Clinton's email scandal." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... CW: For fun, read the tweeted reactions to Trump's Saddam remarks which Hartmann embedded. AND this:
Paul Ryan's face as Megyn Kelly tells him about Donald Trump's remark about Saddam Hussein. h/t @Aaron_RS pic.twitter.com/WWxWnUL6E2
-- Caleb Howe (@CalebHowe) July 6, 2016
Jonathan Chait: "To watch Donald Trump rant and rave uncontrollably on the stump and on Twitter -- praising Saddam Hussein for his disregard for civil liberties, insisting the anti-Semitic propaganda he inadvertently borrowed from neo-Nazis is as innocent as a Disney poster -- is to ponder the psychology of a party that would entrust supreme executive authority to a racist, nationalistic, power-worshiping demagogue.... [Trump & Adolf Hitler] have certain traits in common relative to the political environments they inhabit.... Whatever norms or bounds that we think limit the damage a president could inflict are likely to be exceeded if that president is Trump." -- CW
Matea Gold of the Washington Post: "Donald Trump raisedmore than $26 million through online and mail solicitations in June and another $25 million at events with the Republican National Committee, his campaign announced Wednesday.... The combined $51 million falls short of the $68.5 million that presumptive Democratic contender Hillary Clinton and the Democratic party collected in June, which included $40.5 million she raised directly for her campaign." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
David Fahrenthold of the Washington Post: "Eric Trump, the son of ... Donald Trump, said in an interview Wednesday that his father gives 'millions and millions and millions' of his own money to charity -- including hundreds of thousands to Eric Trump's own charitable foundation. He did not, however, immediately provide new details to help confirm those donations.... [Eric Trump] denounced its reporting -- often in forceful, profane terms. 'I'm just saying, Jesus Christ, why is this guy trying to f[uck]ing kill us?' Eric Trump said at one point." CW: So that settles that. (Also linked yesterday.)
Robert Costa of the Washington Post: "Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), the chairman of the powerful Senate Foreign Relations Committee who has recently emerged as a finalist in the search for Donald Trump's running mate, told The Washington Post in an interview Wednesday that he has taken himself out of consideration for the position. Corker said that he informed the presumptive Republican presidential nominee of his decision during their day together on Tuesday...." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Burgess Everett of Politico: "Joni Ernst all but removed herself from Donald Trump's vice presidential search, telling Politico in an interview that she wants to help Trump become president but that she's focused on Iowa and the Senate, where the freshman senator said she's 'just getting started.' The GOP senator met with Trump on Monday and received effusive praise afterward, with Trump predicting he will 'see her again.'" -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Jonathan Chait: "Trump's intent use of the period leading up to his convention as a reality-television-style audition where he appears with a series of potential running mates and selects the most desirable is giving way to a reality in which the field is considering, and then rejecting, Trump, until he is left with no other decent options." -- CW
... Steve M.: "Well, I'm relieved.... I don't think I could have endured a Trump-Corker ticket -- if only because the media narrative would be: Bob Corker? Wow, what a serious, respectable choice! Trump really is pivoting! He's so presidential now, just because he's chosen this person we like so much! Trump will never change, but a Corker pick would have allowed Beltway journalists to continuing fooling themselves into thinking that he might. (Of course, some of them will anyway.)" -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
How to Put a Positive Light on a Selfish, Greedy, Narcissistic Bastard:
Mr. Trump believes in putting your oxygen mask on first before helping others. -- Katrina Pierson, spokesperson for Donald Trump
Senate Race
Another Rat Leaves Ship. Burgess Everett & Seung Min Kim of Politico: "First he reversed his decision to leave the Senate. Now, Marco Rubio has changed his mind about attending the Republican convention. The Florida senator will stay home to campaign for reelection in one of the country's hottest Senate races, a Rubio official confirmed Wednesday." -- CW
Beyond the Beltway
Michael Miller & Wesley Lowery of the Washington Post: "A Minnesota traffic stop turned deadly Wednesday evening as a police officer opened fire on a driver.... The bloody aftermath of the confrontation was broadcast live on Facebook by a female passenger in the car.... In the video, she says [Philando] Castile was legally licensed to carry a firearm and was reaching for his identification when the officer opened fire. 'He let the officer know that he had a firearm and he was reaching for his wallet and the officer just shot him in his arm,' [Lavish] Reynolds says in the video." -- CW
... CW: Here's the rule: In many states and municipalities it is legal to carry a firearm. Unless you are a minority. Especially black. In which case, it's a capital offense. With no appeal.
AP: "A Louisiana police officer shot and killed a man following a confrontation outside a Baton Rouge convenience store, authorities said. An autopsy shows Alton Sterling, 37, of Baton Rouge, died Tuesday of multiple gunshot wounds to the chest and back, said East Baton Rouge Parish Coroner Dr. William Clark.... The owner [of the store] said Sterling did not have a gun in his hand at the time but he saw officers remove a gun from Sterling's pocket after the shooting." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Radley Balko of the Washington Post: "The witness to the shooting -- the owner of the convenience store -- said the cops seemed aggressive from the start. The witness also said that Sterling was complying with the officers, and that he wasn't holding the gun, nor did he have a hand near the gun when he was shot.... From what we know right now, this appears to be another case of police officers deploying lethal force that was likely legal, but was also unnecessary.... Was it legal? is the question we ask when deciding whether or not to prosecute. Was it preventable? is the question we need to ask to save lives." -- CW ...
... Jarvis DeBerry of the New Orleans Times-Picayune: "The Baton Rouge Police Department -- like so many other departments across the country -- is notorious for its brutal treatment of black people." -- CW ...
... Brandon Patterson of Mother Jones: "Louisiana Governor John Bel-Edwards announced Wednesday morning that the Department of Justice's civil rights division will open an investigation into the police shooting death of Alton Sterling, a 37-year-old black man shot multiple times by a Baton Rouge police officer early Tuesday morning. The FBI and the U.S. attorney's office for the Middle District of Louisiana will assist the investigation, Bel-Edwards said." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Update. Zack Kopplin & Justin Miller of the Daily Beast embed a second video, provided by Abdullah Muflahti, the owner of the convenience store in front of which he police shot & killed Alton Sterling: "Muflahi's video does not appear to support the officer's claim that Sterling's gun represented an active threat: it appears to have been in a pocket and never reached his hand. Instead, the video shows Sterling pinned down, shot twice in the chest, and then shot four more times. After mortally wounding him, one of the officers removes an object from Sterling's right pants pocket. (Police during a Wednesday press conference refused to comment on whether Sterling had a gun.)" -- CW
Emma Ockerman of Time: "A 37-year-old man who had previously been charged with providing support to Al-Qaeda was handed a three-count indictment in Toledo, Ohio on Wednesday for soliciting the murder of the federal judge presiding over his case. Yahya Farooq Mohammad was charged with attempted first-degree murder of a federal officer, solicitation to commit a crime of violence and use of interstate commerce facilities in commission of murder for hire, according to a news release from the U.S. Department of Justice. He was accused of soliciting someone to kidnap and murder U.S. District Court Judge Jack Zouhary after he told an inmate at a county jail in April that he was willing to pay $15,000 to carry out the act, the Toledo Blade reports." -- CW
Way Beyond
Luke Harding of the Guardian: "A defiant Tony Blair [-- the former British PM --] defended his decision to go to war in Iraq in 2003 following the publication of a devastating report by Sir John Chilcot, which mauled the ex-prime minister's reputation and said that at the time of the 2003 invasion Saddam Hussein 'posed no imminent threat'. Looking tired, his voice sometimes croaking with emotion, Blair described his decision to join the US attack as 'the hardest, most momentous, most agonising decision I took in 10 years as British prime minister'." CW: The Guardian is updating developments & analyses here.