The Wires
powered by Surfing Waves
Help!

To keep the Conversation going, please help me by linking news articles, opinion pieces and other political content in today's Comments section.

Link Code:   <a href="URL">text</a>

OR here's a link generator. The one I had posted died, then Akhilleus found one, but it too bit the dust. He found yet another, which I've linked here, and as of September 23, 2024, it's working.

OR you can always just block, copy and paste to your comment the URL (Web address) of the page you want to link.

Note for Readers. It is not possible for commenters to "throw" their highlighted links to another window. But you can do that yourself. Right-click on the link and a drop-down box will give you choices as to where you want to open the link: in a new tab, new window or new private window.

Thank you to everyone who has been contributing links to articles & other content in the Comments section of each day's "Conversation." If you're missing the comments, you're missing some vital links.

Marie: Sorry, my countdown clock was unreliable; then it became completely unreliable. I can't keep up with it. Maybe I'll try another one later.

 

Public Service Announcement

Zoë Schlanger in the Atlantic: "Throw out your black plastic spatula. In a world of plastic consumer goods, avoiding the material entirely requires the fervor of a religious conversion. But getting rid of black plastic kitchen utensils is a low-stakes move, and worth it. Cooking with any plastic is a dubious enterprise, because heat encourages potentially harmful plastic compounds to migrate out of the polymers and potentially into the food. But, as Andrew Turner, a biochemist at the University of Plymouth recently told me, black plastic is particularly crucial to avoid." This is a gift link from laura h.

Mashable: "Following the 2024 presidential election results and [Elon] Musk's support for ... Donald Trump, users have been deactivating en masse. And this time, it appears most everyone has settled on one particular X alternative: Bluesky.... Bluesky has gained more than 100,000 new sign ups per day since the U.S. election on Nov. 5. It now has over 15 million users. It's enjoyed a prolonged stay on the very top of Apple's App Store charts as well. Ready to join? Here's how to get started on Bluesky[.]"

Washington Post: "Americans can again order free rapid coronavirus tests by mail, the Biden administration announced Thursday. People can request four free at-home tests per household through covidtests.gov. They will begin shipping Monday. The move comes ahead of an expected winter wave of coronavirus cases. The September revival of the free testing program is in line with the Biden administration’s strategy to respond to the coronavirus as part of a broader public health campaign to protect Americans from respiratory viruses, including influenza and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), that surge every fall and winter. But free tests were not mailed during the summer wave, which wastewater surveillance data shows is now receding."

Wherein Michael McIntyre explains how Americans adapted English to their needs. With examples:

Beat the Buzzer. Some amazing young athletes:

     ~~~ Here's the WashPo story (March 23).

Back when the Washington Post had an owner/publisher who dared to stand up to a president:

Prime video is carrying the documentary. If you watch it, I suggest watching the Spielberg film "The Post" afterwards. There is currently a free copy (type "the post full movie" in the YouTube search box) on YouTube (or you can rent it on YouTube, on Prime & [I think] on Hulu). Near the end, Daniel Ellsberg (played by Matthew Rhys), says "I was struck in fact by the way President Johnson's reaction to these revelations was [that they were] 'close to treason,' because it reflected to me the sense that what was damaging to the reputation of a particular administration or a particular individual was in itself treason, which is very close to saying, 'I am the state.'" Sound familiar?

Out with the Black. In with the White. New York Times: “Lester Holt, the veteran NBC newscaster and anchor of the 'NBC Nightly News' over the last decade, announced on Monday that he will step down from the flagship evening newscast in the coming months. Mr. Holt told colleagues that he would remain at NBC, expanding his duties at 'Dateline,' where he serves as the show’s anchor.... He said that he would continue anchoring the evening news until 'the start of summer.' The network did not immediately name a successor.” ~~~

~~~ New York Times: “MSNBC said on Monday that Jen Psaki, the former White House press secretary who has become one of the most prominent hosts at the network, would anchor a nightly weekday show in prime time. Ms. Psaki, 46, will host a show at 9 p.m. Tuesday through Friday, replacing Alex Wagner, a longtime political journalist who has anchored that hour since 2022, according to a memo to staff from Rebecca Kutler, MSNBC’s president. Ms. Wagner will remain at MSNBC as an on-air correspondent. Rachel Maddow, MSNBC’s biggest star, has been anchoring the 9 p.m. hour on weeknights for the early days of ... [Donald] Trump’s administration but will return to hosting one night a week at the end of April.”

New York Times: “Joy Reid’s evening news show on MSNBC is being canceled, part of a far-reaching programming overhaul orchestrated by Rebecca Kutler, the network’s new president, two people familiar with the changes said. The final episode of Ms. Reid’s 7 p.m. show, 'The ReidOut,' is planned for sometime this week, according to the people, who were not authorized to speak publicly. The show, which features in-depth interviews with politicians and other newsmakers, has been a fixture of MSNBC’s lineup for the past five years. MSNBC is planning to replace Ms. Reid’s program with a show led by a trio of anchors: Symone Sanders Townsend, a political commentator and former Democratic strategist; Michael Steele, a former chairman of the Republican National Committee; and Alicia Menendez, the TV journalist, the people said. They currently co-host 'The Weekend,' which airs Saturday and Sunday mornings.” MB: In case you've never seen “The Weekend,” let me assure you it's pretty awful. ~~~

     ~~~ AP Update: "Joy Reid is leaving MSNBC, the network’s new president announced in a memo to staff on Monday, marking an end to the political analyst and anchor’s prime time news show."

Y! Entertainment: "Meanwhile, [Alex] Wagner will also be removed from her 9 pm weeknight slot. Wagner has already been working as a correspondent after Rachel Maddow took over hosting duties during ... Trump’s first 100 days in office. It’s now expected that Wagner will not return as host, but is expected to stay on as a contributor. Jen Psaki, President Biden’s former White House press secretary, is a likely replacement for Wagner, though a decision has not been finalized." MB: In fairness to Psaki, she is really too boring to watch. On the other hand, she is White. ~~~

     ~~~ RAS: "So MSNBC is getting rid of both of their minority evening hosts. Both women of color who are not afraid to call out the truth. Outspoken minorities don't have a long shelf life in the world of our corporate news media."

 

Contact Marie

Email Marie at constantweader@gmail.com

Constant Comments

Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts.

Success is not final, failure is not fatal; it is the courage to continue that counts. — Anonymous

A nation of sheep will beget a government of wolvesEdward R. Murrow

Publisher & Editor: Marie Burns

I have a Bluesky account now. The URL is https://bsky.app/profile/marie-burns.bsky.social . When Reality Chex goes down, check my Bluesky page for whatever info I am able to report on the status of Reality Chex. If you can't access the URL, I found that I could Google Bluesky and ask for Marie Burns. Google will include links to accounts for people whose names are, at least in part, Maria Burns, so you'll have to tell Google you looking only for Marie.

Thursday
Dec052024

The Conversation -- December 5, 2024

Clare Foran, et al., of CNN: "House Republicans voted on Thursday to block a Democrat-led effort to release a long-awaited Ethics Committee report on allegations against former GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz of Florida. The House took a step to effectively shut down a resolution from Democrats that would have required the public release of the report. House GOP leaders sidelined the effort by Democrats by setting up a vote to refer the resolution to the committee, a move that blocks the report's release for now. The outcome of the vote raises the question of whether the findings of the panel's investigation will ever become public." MB: Why, it appears House Republicans hate Gaetz less than they fear the Wrath of Trump.

The New York Times liveblog of the search for the gunman who killed United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson is here: "The authorities released two images they said may show the suspect without a face mask in the fatal shooting of the chief executive of one of the largest U.S. health insurers outside a hotel in Midtown Manhattan.... The authorities do not yet have the suspect's name but are pursuing several leads, a senior law enforcement official said." The suspect stayed at a hostel on the Upper West Side, and the photos were taken there. The photos currently are on the Times front page, so if you don't have a subscription, you can see them.

"Ballistics testing is continuing, the official said, but the casings appear to have been inscribed with words including 'delay' and 'deny' -- potentially references to ways that health insurance companies seek to avoid paying patient' claims.... UnitedHealthcare, one of the nation's largest health insurers, has come under fierce criticism from patients, lawmakers and others for denying patients' claims."

Dionne Searcey & Madison Kircher of the New York Times: "The fatal shooting on Wednesday of a top UnitedHealthcare executive, Brian Thompson, on a Manhattan sidewalk has unleashed a torrent of morbid glee from patients and others who say they have had negative experiences with health insurance companies at some of the hardest times of their lives. 'Thoughts and deductibles to the family,' read one comment underneath a video of the shooting posted online by CNN. 'Unfortunately my condolences are out-of-network.' On TikTok, one user wrote, 'I'm an ER nurse and the things I've seen dying patients get denied for by insurance makes me physically sick. I just can't feel sympathy for him because of all of those patients and their families.' The dark commentary after the death of Mr. Thompson, a 50-year-old insurance executive from Maple Grove, Minn., who was also a husband and a father of two children, highlighted the anger and frustration over the state of health care in America, where those with private insurance often find themselves in Kafka-esque tangles while seeking reimbursement for medical treatment and are often denied."

Ben Hubbard of the New York Times: "Syrian rebels stormed into the city of Hama on Thursday as government forces withdrew, bringing the rebels one step closer to the capital Damascus, the seat of power of President Bashar al-Assad. The swift advance on Hama, one of Syria's largest cities, and the retreat of government forces were confirmed by both the rebels and the government. The advance came just days after the rebels extended their control over Aleppo, a major hub in northern Syria. In a video circulated by the rebel group leading the offensive, their leader, Abu Mohammed al-Jolani, jubilantly calls for the rebels to push on toward other Syrian cities, including the capital."

~~~~~~~~~~

Marie: There's more to do, but after 5 or 6 hours of reading a computer screen, my eyes had had it. I'll try to get to doing more later this morning. In the meantime, I'll sit here enjoying my damned Winter Wonderland.

Abigail Hauslohner of the Washington Post: "President Joe Biden on Wednesday announced that the United States would spend more than $560 million on projects connected to the Lobito Corridor, a trans-African railway that will help get vital minerals and other goods to a port where they can be shipped to the United States and other destinations. The announcement, which brings the U.S. investment in the Lobito Corridor project to $4 billion, was an 11th-hour capstone to Biden's effort to increase American engagement in sub-Saharan Africa, a region that has become a focus of the struggle between the United States and China for economic and political influence across the globe. 'I think we're at one of the transition points in world history where what we do is going to affect what the next six, seven, eight decades look like,' Biden said at a celebratory event with African heads of state. 'I think this is one of those milestones.'"

Jim Vanderhei & Mike Allen of Axios: Joe "Biden, 82, will limp away from the limelight -- widely disliked by the public, and now loathed by many Democrats who blame him for twin sins of selfishness: running again, then pardoning Hunter after repeatedly saying he wouldn't. Some in Biden's family have been shocked by the number of Democrats trashing his Hunter decision on the record, sources tell us. They expected some blowback -- not a wicked backlash. But even Biden's best friends think it was nuts to pardon Hunter as a solo act on the same evening he left for a long-promised three-day trip to Africa.... As cover, the president could have pardoned ... Trump at the same time -- or pardoned Hunter along with dozens of people whose convictions appear to result from injustices.... A snap YouGov poll found 64% of Democrats approve of the pardon -- a reversal of earlier Democratic sentiment." MB: Pardon Trump? Oh, please. With all due respect, Vanderhei & Allen are a couple of dipshit conservo-scolds. But still, they probably didn't pull all of the reporting part of this post out of thin air.

Marie: In yesterday's Conversation, I agreed with Kaitlan Collins & Van Jones of CNN that maybe Joe Biden should pardon some of Trump and Co's other targets. Now this: ~~~

     ~~~ Jonathan Martin in Politico Magazine: "President Joe Biden's senior aides are conducting a vigorous internal debate over whether to issue preemptive pardons to a range of current and former public officials who could be targeted with ... Donald Trump's return to the White House, according to senior Democrats familiar with the discussions. Biden's aides are deeply concerned about a range of current and former officials who could find themselves facing inquiries and even indictments, a sense of alarm which has only accelerated since Trump last weekend announced the appointment of Kash Patel to lead the FBI. Patel has publicly vowed to pursue Trump's critics. The White House officials, however, are carefully weighing the extraordinary step of handing out blanket pardons to those who've committed no crimes, both because it could suggest impropriety, only fueling Trump's criticisms, and because those offered preemptive pardons may reject them. The deliberations touch on pardoning those currently in office, elected and appointed, as well as former officials who've angered Trump and his loyalists.... The president himself, who was intensely focused on his son's pardon, has not been brought into the broader pardon discussions yet, according to people familiar with the deliberations." Among those other consideration for these preemptive pardons for imaginary crimes are Adam Schiff, Liz Cheney & Anthony Fauci.

The Unethics Plan for Trump. Eric Lipton, et al., of the New York Times: "In the wake of Donald J. Trump's election victory, his family business is poised to capitalize on his presidency with a variety of new ventures, according to a New York Times review of financial records and interviews with people knowledgeable about his finances. And unlike in his first term, the people said, the Trump Organization aims to issue a more limited ethics plan that is unlikely to significantly curb its growth.... The company would be free to profit from an array of business in countries essential to American foreign policy interests.... The Trump family is also branching out to forge foreign ties beyond the real estate business.... The new ventures [a cryptocurrency platform and a social media company] -- both of which will face oversight from federal regulators appointed by the president -- underscore how the company's recent expansion created an even more complicated web of conflicts than in Mr. Trump's first term." And so forth. MB: We are all just cogs in the wheel of the Trump Organization. Those of us who didn't vote for Trump are involuntary conscripts.

All the Best People, Ctd. Trump Hires Another Ex-Con. Chris Megerian of the AP: "... Donald Trump is bringing Peter Navarro, a former adviser who served prison time related to the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, back to the White House for his second administration. Navarro will serve as a senior counselor for trade and manufacturing, Trump announced on Truth Social, his social media website.... Navarro, a trade adviser during Trump's first term, was held in contempt of Congress for defying a subpoena from the House committee that investigated Jan. 6. Sentenced to four months in prison, he described his conviction as the 'partisan weaponization of the judicial system.'" (Also linked yesterday.)

Minho Kim of the New York Times: "... Trump announced on Wednesday night that he had chosen Frank Bisignano, the chairman of the payment processing behemoth Fiserv, to be the commissioner of the Social Security Administration, a sizable federal agency with more than 1,200 field offices and almost 60,000 employees.... Mr. Bisignano was listed as the second-highest-paid chief executive in the country in 2017, one of the few to have been compensated more than $100 million that year and to have received more than 2,000 times the average employee's salary at his firm, First Data Corporation, which later merged with Fiserv.... Earlier on Wednesday, Mr. Trump uploaded an elaborate biography of Mr Bisignano to social media and congratulated him and his family without mentioning the post to which Mr. Bisignano was being named. The president-elect made a clarification an hour later, ending the speculation on what Mr. Bisignano's next job would be." ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Once again, Trump shows off his own incompetence while choosing an inappropriate person to run a federal agency. Bisignano has lifted himself up at the expense of his employees. It is shameful to accept compensation worth $100 million a year. It is shameful to make more than 2,000 times what many of your employees earn. (Via progressive tax policy, the federal government should be taking most of that money out of Bisignano's pockets and putting it in the pockets of his workers.) Bisignano is virtually shouting, "I don't care about people who need Social Security, and Lord knows, I'll never need it." As Bloomberg notes in its report (republished by Yahoo! News) on Bisignano's nomination, "While Trump has pledged to protect Social Security benefits, critics say that many of the policies he says he plans to enact in office would actually weaken the program. A nonpartisan budget watchdog in October estimated that Trump's second-term agenda would drive the program to insolvency three years earlier and slash benefits by nearly a third." And in the Senate, you have Republicans like Mike Lee (Utah) who is scheming to wreck Social Security. (See digby's column, linked below.)

Carolyn Johnson, et al., of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump on Wednesday announced billionaire businessman Jared Isaacman, who has twice orbited the planet on private spaceflights, as his pick to lead the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. Isaacman, 41, is a major customer of SpaceX, the company founded by Elon Musk, who has been at Trump's elbow throughout the transition.... Isaacson flew on a SpaceX rocket to the highest orbit since the Apollo era this year and, along with a crewmate, became the first private astronauts to perform spacewalks."

Maggie Haberman & Jonathan Swan of the New York Times: "... Donald J. Trump's support for Pete Hegseth, whom he announced as his nominee for defense secretary shortly after Election Day, is wobbling after a crush of controversy over a rape allegation and a 2018 email from Mr. Hegseth's mother accusing him of a pattern of abuse toward women. How Mr. Hegseth fares through a series of tests on Wednesday will be critical for his chances. He is set to continue his meetings with key senators, including Joni Ernst of Iowa, a combat veteran who has spoken about being sexually assaulted herself, and his mother is expected to sit for an interview on Fox News. He is also set to start defending himself on television. Mr. Trump has made clear to people close to him that he believes Mr. Hegseth should have been more forthcoming about the problems he would face getting confirmed.... Mr. Trump is openly discussing other people for the job, including Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida, whom he defeated in the Republican presidential primaries and with whom he has had a contentious relationship.... He talked about it with Mr. DeSantis on Tuesday at a service honoring three Florida sheriff's deputies who were killed in a car crash." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

~~~ Michael Kranish and others at the Washington Post write a fairly long piece about Hegseth's history of drinking to excess. Hegseth denies it now, but in 2021 he seems to have admitted on a podcast that he had been a heavy drinker, a lapse he said was caused by a brush with death when he was in the military.

Marie: Rolling Stone has a firewalled story under the headline that Hegseth has promised to stop drinking and has asked his mom to call Senators. Sad!

Trump Fires DEA Nominee. Lalee Ibssa, et al., of ABC News: "... Donald Trump said Wednesday that he had pulled his pick to lead the Drug Enforcement Agency despite Hillsborough County, Florida, Sheriff Chad Chronister saying the day before he was withdrawing from consideration. Trump said Wednesday on his Truth Social platform that Chronister 'didn't pull out, I pulled him out, because I did not like what he said to my pastors and other supporters,' taking offense to a Wall Street Journal headline that called the move 'a setback.' Although Trump touted Chronister and said he would work to 'stop the flow of Fentanyl, and other Illegal Drugs,' in announcing his selection, there was pushback against Chronister from conservatives for his enforcement of COVID-19 lockdowns during the pandemic. Many prominent conservatives criticized Chronister for arresting a pastor who defied lockdown orders and held a service during the pandemic." ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: So, as usual, Trump doesn't mind demonstrating his incompetence. He never bothered to have Chronister vetted to see if the sheriff met Trump's stupid criteria. I'd guess the only thing he knew about Chronister is that he's a nice-looking White guy who would look swell when he announced a big drug bust and that his father-in-law was a bigwig whom like Trump, ran afoul of the law. Next, we see Trump's cruelty. Rather than allowing Chronister to bow out politely, as he did, saving not only his own face but also Trump's, Trump had to announce that he had fired him. Wow! What a macho man! I'm so impressed.

Franklin Foer of the Atlantic: "With Trump's unified control of ... Washington, congressional oversight is defunct. That leaves a lone bastion of countervailing power, one force capable of meaningfully slowing the maximalist ambitions of the incoming administration: blue states, especially the 15 state governments where Democrats control the executive and legislative branches.... Over the past several months, a small coterie of wonks and lawyers -- and a few farsighted Democratic governors -- have been working in anticipation of this moment.... The outlines of a new progressive vision of federalism -- pugilistic and creative, audacious and idealistic -- began to emerge....

Liberals might soon discover that federalism, once the hobbyhorse of conservatives, contains not only the hope of stubborn resistance but the possibility of regeneration.... The innovation that the new federalists propose is that the blue states begin to leverage their big budgets -- and their outsize influence -- by acting in concert. Banding together into a cartel, they can wield their scale to bargain to buy goods at discount.... [And] by creating uniform rules for, say, corporate governance or animal welfare or the disclosure of dark-money contributions to nonprofits, they stand a chance of shaping the standard for the entirety of the country...." Many thanks to laura h. for this gift link.

Historian Timothy Snyder has been thinking about the parallels between South Korea's "Dictator for a Day" Yoon Suk Yeol and ours. "But Yoon failed, and very badly. His dictatorship for a day lasted only about six hours. What can Americans learn from his less-than-a-day dictatorship?... The Senate, in confirmation hearings, has an obvious question to ask all of Trump's appointees with any responsibility for national security or intelligence: if Trump attempts to invoke the Insurrection Act to stifle domestic political life, just as Yoon attempted to do in South Korea, would you take part?... Are American legislators capable of defending their roles and their republic? The evidence thus far is very mixed; it remains to be seen. But South Koreans have shown the attitude and the resolve that is necessary.... Would Fox and Newsmax rise to the occasion, as did Chosun Ilbo [the major conservative newspaper]? Probably not.... But the crucial element in South Korea was the reaction of citizens themselves" who defied martial law & resisted. (Also linked yesterday.)

Dave Karpf, in a Substack essay, takes a Marxist view of democracy, though describing it in terms Emily Post might have appreciated. Rather than seeing our form of representative democracy as merely an opiate of the masses, Karpf says that it is "a compromise between political elites and the mass public. The public is given the vote as a pressure release valve of sorts -- a form of legitimate dissent that affects the composition of the government. Elites, as a result, enjoy unparalleled social stability." When a politician steps outside the bounds of propriety -- as Joe Biden did when he pardoned his prodigal son -- then he has been "uncouth," and there is a price for that. Thanks to RAS for the link. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: The fatal flaw in Karpf's analysis is his assessment of what's "couth" and what's "uncouth." You tell me why it's "uncouth" for Biden to pardon his son but not "uncouth" for Trump to pay hush money to a porn star or steal sensitive government-owned documents or try to stay in power by overturning a democratic election -- and why it's "uncouth" to call Trump to heel for these miscarriages of justice. Marxist theory isn't foolish, but you can see where, at least in this case, its proponent must adopt assumptions that don't make a lick of sense.

digby cites a Bluesky account called "SocialSecurityWorks.org," which reports that "[Tuesday] night, Sen. Mike Lee [R-Utah] wrote a blueprint for destroying Social Security. Lee's thread was quickly amplified by Elon Musk, who Donald Trump has put in charge of slashing our earned benefits. This is a declaration of war against seniors, people with disabilities, and the American public." If you want to know who's behind Social Security Works, their "About Us" webpage is here. Thanks to RAS for the link. Just bear in mind, if you're of a certain age (or if you hope to live so long), that Mike Lee's little "reforms" could happen. Republicans have been trying to destroy Social Security since the first weak version of it went into effect in the mid-1930s. Past failures do not ensure future failures. (Also linked yesterday.)

Catie Edmondson of the New York Times: Tuesday, the final House race was called for a Democrat, "cementing a 220-215 majority for Republicans in a margin even slimmer than they have now, at 220-213. Those margins will erode even further in January, when Representatives Elise Stefanik of New York and Mike Waltz of Florida resign to take jobs in the Trump administration. Former Representative Matt Gaetz of Florida has also given notice that he will not return. Republicans will then be down to a 217-215 majority, on par with the narrowest controlling margin in House history. If all Democrats are present and united in opposition to a measure, Mr. Johnson won't be able to afford a single defection on the House floor until those vacancies are filled later this spring. Even then, no more than three Republicans can break ranks without dooming a bill's passage. Mr. Johnson sounded unfazed at the prospect on Wednesday, telling reporters on Capitol Hill: 'We know how to work with a small majority. That's our custom.'"

Maegan Vazquez & Meryl Kornfield of the Washington Post: "Sen. Mitt Romney (Utah), a former GOP presidential nominee who later criticized fellow Republican Donald Trump, delivered his farewell address on the Senate floor Wednesday, stressing the importance of bipartisanship and promising to be 'a voice of unity and virtue' after he leaves Washington."

Nicholas Wu, et al., of Politico: "House Democrats are poised to unseat several senior committee leaders, and Hakeem Jeffries is letting it happen.... It's akin to a mutiny, especially given Democrats' typical deference to seniority in who leads panels. But party lawmakers are increasingly anxious about the incoming Trump administration and full GOP control of Congress. Many feel it's crucial to have leaders who are proven fighters and can effectively push back on Republican priorities like harsh limits on legal immigration. It echoes the argument many used when they called on President Joe Biden to step off the ticket over the summer. At the center of it all is Jeffries, the minority leader, and his leadership team, who also skipped the seniority line in many ways when they rose to the top ranks two years ago." ~~~

~~~ Nicholas Fandos of the New York Times: "Representative Jerrold Nadler plans to step down as the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee next term, succumbing to calls for generational change as his party prepares to confront a second Trump administration. Mr. Nadler, the 77-year-old dean of New York's congressional delegation, had been facing a direct challenge from a close ally, Representative Jamie Raskin of Maryland. Mr. Raskin, 61, was said to have secured the votes necessary to defeat him. The transition would represent a significant departure for House Democrats, who have traditionally awarded coveted committee leadership jobs based primarily on seniority.... Furious over being challenged, Mr. Nadler had initially fought to hold the position he has held since 2017. But on Wednesday, he conceded that he did not have a path to victory and endorsed Mr. Raskin to replace him in a letter to colleagues."

Adam Liptak & Emily Bezelon of the New York Times: "Members of the Supreme Court's conservative majority seemed ready on Wednesday to uphold a Tennessee law denying transition care to transgender youth, with some of them saying that judgments about contested scientific evidence should be made by legislatures rather than judges. 'The Constitution leaves that question to the people's representatives, rather than to nine people, none of whom is a doctor,' Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. said. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson responded that leaving the question to the states was an alarming abdication of responsibility.... The Tennessee law prohibits medical providers from prescribing puberty-delaying medication, providing hormone therapy or performing surgery to treat what the law called 'purported discomfort or distress from a discordance between the minor's sex and asserted identity.' But the law allows those same treatments for 'a congenital defect, precocious puberty, disease or physical injury.'" MB: Gosh, CJ Roberts sure finds convenient situations to indulge in false expressions of humility.


John Miller
, et al., of CNN: "The CEO of UnitedHealthcare was shot and killed in midtown Manhattan Wednesday morning in an apparent targeted attack as he was about to attend the company’s annual investor conference, a law enforcement official tells CNN. The gunman remains on the loose. Brian Thompson was walking toward the New York Hilton Hotel in Midtown Manhattan, dressed in a suit and tie, to attend UnitedHealthcare's annual investor conference being held in the ballroom. A gunman, who investigators tell CNN was masked in the freezing temperatures, waited for about 10 minutes before Thompson's arrival, before opening fire from 20 feet away shooting multiple times, striking Thompson. The gunman fled, cutting through an alleyway and hopping on to a bicycle, the official told CNN. Investigators are continuing to canvas the area. Police currently believe that the suspect fled into Central Park." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ The New York Times is liveblogging developments in the manhunt for the shooter. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Update. Michael Lipton, et al., of the New York Times: "By nightfall, a sprawling manhunt with police officers, dogs and drones spread citywide, bearing down on surveillance videos, a dropped cellphone and even Citi Bike data in search of the killer. The police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, who was sworn in 10 days ago, called it a 'brazen targeted attack,' adding, 'We will not rest until we identify and apprehend the shooter in this case.'"

~~~~~~~~~~

Montana. Praveena Somasundaram of the Washington Post: "Several Montana Republicans joined Democrats on Tuesday to block a measure that would have barred transgender lawmakers from using the state Capitol bathrooms that aligned with their gender identities. The proposed measure would have banned Rep. Zooey Zephyr, a transgender Democratic lawmaker who was reelected in November, from using the women's bathroom outside Montana's House and Senate chambers. Last year, Zephyr was silenced in the House after speaking out against her Republican colleagues for their support of a ban on gender-affirming care for transgender children. Weeks ahead of her return to the House floor, Zephyr’s colleagues in the chamber rejected the bathroom measure in a 12-10 vote. Three Republicans joined Democrats in voting against it, characterizing it as a rule that would not add value to their work while also noting they didn't necessarily disagree with the ideology driving it."

Tennessee. Emily Cochrane & Shaila Dewan of the New York Times: "The Justice Department released the results of its investigation into the Memphis Police Department on Wednesday, finding that it had used excessive force, treated Black people more harshly than white people and mistreated those with mental health issues. The report said that the civil rights violations had a 'corrosive effect.' The 73-page report made special note of the treatment of children, saying that they had experienced 'aggressive and frightening encounters with officers.'... The Police Department has been under scrutiny since January 2023, when officers fatally beat Tyre Nichols, a 29-year-old Black man, after pulling him over on his way home from work. The body and street camera footage that captured the violence prompted a national outcry and testimony from other residents about the agency’s pattern of excessive force.... The city, however, has already indicated that it may not agree to fully cooperate with an overhaul of its Police Department. Shortly before Wednesday's report was released, the city sent a letter to the Justice Department rejecting its push to negotiate an agreement, known as a consent decree.” And that's because Donald Trump. Really. The report, linked above, is via the DOJ, not the NYT, so you can access it whether or not you have a NYT account. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Let me just add that Memphis' hubris is possible because Merrick Garland's DOJ didn't think it was important to get out this report well before the election, when Memphis officials didn't know whether or not they would be able to rely on Trump's Injustice Department to ignore the report's conclusions. Merrick the Unready is such a lazy, lackadaisical attorney general. The only thing we have to thank Mitch McConnell for is that we're not having to read report after report that "Once again, Justice Garland delayed a decision in the case but eventually came down on the side of the Court's more conservative justices."

~~~~~~~~~~

France. Adam Nossiter of the New York Times: "French lawmakers passed a no-confidence measure against Prime Minister Michel Barnier and his cabinet on Wednesday, sending the country into a fresh spasm of political turmoil that leaves it without a clear path to a new budget and threatens to further jolt financial markets. France's lower house of Parliament passed the measure with 331 votes, well above the majority of 288 votes that were required, after Marine Le Pen's far-right National Rally joined moves by the chamber's leftist coalition to oust the government. Mr. Barnier is expected to resign soon. It was the first successful no-confidence vote in France in over 60 years and made Mr. Barnier's three-month-old government the shortest-tenured in the history of France's Fifth Republic."

Israel/Palestine, et al. Only One Government at a Time, Ha Ha Ha. The Washington Post's live updates of developments Thursday in Israel's wars are here: "... Donald Trump's newly named Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, met with leaders in Qatar and Israel in late November to revive efforts to conclude a ceasefire and hostage deal in Gaza, two people familiar with the matter told The Washington Post. Witkoff was named special envoy on Nov. 12. Witkoff's meetings with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Qatari Prime Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani were the first sign of Trump dispatching personnel to fulfill his long-shot goal of concluding a ceasefire and hostage deal before he takes office on Jan. 20, a timeline many view as unrealistic."

Mexico. James Wagner & Emiliano Mega of the New York Times: "Mexican security forces captured more than a ton of fentanyl this week, marking the country’s largest synthetic opioid seizure, which officials on Wednesday said was equivalent to 20 million doses of the drug. It was the latest show of force in a crackdown on violence and illicit drugs by Mexico's new president, Claudia Sheinbaum, ahead of the inauguration next month of ... Donald J. Trump. Mr. Trump has vowed to place steep tariffs on Mexico until the government stops drugs and migrants from crossing the border.... During her daily news conference on Wednesday morning, Ms. Sheinbaum said the operations were part of a long investigation and resulted in 'the largest mass seizure of fentanyl pills ever made.'"

South Korea. The New York Times is liveblogging developments in the political crisis in South Korea here: “The South Korean general appointed as the commander of President Yoon Suk Yeol's short-lived declaration of martial law learned of the move only when Mr. Yoon announced it on television, the general told lawmakers during hearings on Thursday. Despite his position, the general, Park An-su, told a parliamentary committee that he also did not know who ordered troops to move in on the National Assembly in an attempt to cordon it off. During his testimony, the deputy defense minister, Kim Seon-ho, said that the defense minister had ordered the troops in. Mr. Kim said that he had opposed the mobilization. The defense minister, Kim Yong-hyun, resigned Thursday before the hearings and did not take part."

News Ledes

New York Times: “A gunman shot two kindergarten students, ages 5 and 6, at a small parochial school in rural California on Wednesday afternoon and then died from what the authorities believe was a self-inflicted gunshot wound, a spokesman for the Butte County Sheriff's Office said. The authorities believe that the gunman targeted the school because of its affiliation with the Seventh-day Adventists, a Protestant Christian denomination. The two students, both boys, are in 'extremely critical condition' and are being treated for 'very, very serious injuries' at a trauma center in the Sacramento area, Kory L. Honea, the sheriff of Butte County, said at a news conference Wednesday night."

New York Times: "Richard Hamilton, an inventive mathematician who devised the Ricci flow, a groundbreaking equation that helped advance understanding of the fundamental nature of three-dimensional space, died on Sept. 29 in Manhattan. He was 81.... In 1982, Dr. Hamilton published 'Three-manifolds with positive Ricci curvature' in The Journal of Differential Geometry. The article laid out his revolutionary theory: a kind of geometric analog to the heat equation in physics. While the heat equation described how heat diffuses throughout space, as hot spots gradually merge with cooler regions, resulting in temperature equilibrium, the Ricci flow (named after the 19th-century Italian mathematician Gregorio Ricci-Curbastro) offered a model for understanding how irregular shapes can smooth themselves out, evolving into spheres.” MB: Of course I understand all this completely.

Wednesday
Dec042024

The Conversation -- December 4, 2024

Historian Timothy Snyder has been thinking about the parallels between South Korea's "Dictator for a Day" Yoon Suk Yeol and ours. "But Yoon failed, and very badly. His dictatorship for a day lasted only about six hours. What can Americans learn from his less-than-a-day dictatorship?... The Senate, in confirmation hearings, has an obvious question to ask all of Trump's appointees with any responsibility for national security or intelligence: if Trump attempts to invoke the Insurrection Act to stifle domestic political life, just as Yoon attempted to do in South Korea, would you take part?... Are American legislators capable of defending their roles and their republic? The evidence thus far is very mixed; it remains to be seen. But South Koreans have shown the attitude and the resolve that is necessary.... Would Fox and Newsmax rise to the occasion, as did Chosun Ilbo [the major conservative newspaper]? Probably not.... But the crucial element in South Korea was the reaction of citizens themselves" who defied martial law & resisted.

All the Best People, Ctd. Trump Hires Another Ex-Con. Chris Megerian of the AP: "... Donald Trump is bringing Peter Navarro, a former adviser who served prison time related to the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, back to the White House for his second administration. Navarro will serve as a senior counselor for trade and manufacturing, Trump announced on Truth Social, his social media website.... Navarro, a trade adviser during Trump's first term, was held in contempt of Congress for defying a subpoena from the House committee that investigated Jan. 6. Sentenced to four months in prison, he described his conviction as the 'partisan weaponization of the judicial system.'"

Maggie Haberman & Jonathan Swan of the New York Times: "... Donald J. Trump's support for Pete Hegseth, whom he announced as his nominee for defense secretary shortly after Election Day, is wobbling after a crush of controversy over a rape allegation and a 2018 email from Mr. Hegseth's mother accusing him of a pattern of abuse toward women. How Mr. Hegseth fares through a series of tests on Wednesday will be critical for his chances. He is set to continue his meetings with key senators, including Joni Ernst of Iowa, a combat veteran who has spoken about being sexually assaulted herself, and his mother is expected to sit for an interview on Fox News. He is also set to start defending himself on television. Mr. Trump has made clear to people close to him that he believes Mr. Hegseth should have been more forthcoming about the problems he would face getting confirmed.... Mr. Trump is openly discussing other people for the job, including Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida, whom he defeated in the Republican presidential primaries and with whom he has had a contentious relationship.... He talked about it with Mr. DeSantis on Tuesday at a service honoring three Florida sheriff's deputies who were killed in a car crash."

digby cites a Bluesky account called "SocialSecurityWorks.org," which reports that "[Tuesday] night, Sen. Mike Lee [R-Utah] wrote a blueprint for destroying Social Security. Lee's thread was quickly amplified by Elon Musk, who Donald Trump has put in charge of slashing our earned benefits. This is a declaration of war against seniors, people with disabilities, and the American public." If you want to know who's behind Social Security Works, their "About Us" webpage is here. Thanks to RAS for the link. Just bear in mind, if you're of a certain age (or if you hope to live so long), that Mike Lee's little "reforms" could happen. Republicans have been trying to destroy Social Security since the first weak version of it went into effect in the mid-1930s. Past failures do not ensure future failures.

John Miller, et al., of CNN: "The CEO of UnitedHealthcare was shot and killed in midtown Manhattan Wednesday morning in an apparent targeted attack as he was about to attend the company's annual investor conference, a law enforcement official tells CNN. The gunman remains on the loose. Brian Thompson was walking toward the New York Hilton Hotel in Midtown Manhattan, dressed in a suit and tie, to attend UnitedHealthcare's annual investor conference being held in the ballroom. A gunman, who investigators tell CNN was masked in the freezing temperatures, waited for about 10 minutes before Thompson's arrival, before opening fire from 20 feet away shooting multiple times, striking Thompson. The gunman fled, cutting through an alleyway and hopping on to a bicycle, the official told CNN. Investigators are continuing to canvas the area. Police currently believe that the suspect fled into Central Park." ~~~

     ~~~ The New York Times is liveblogging developments in the manhunt for the shooter.

~~~~~~~~~~

Maggie Haberman, et al., of the New York Times: "... Donald J. Trump's transition operation announced on Tuesday that it had belatedly signed an agreement with the Justice Department that will allow the F.B.I. to conduct background checks on people Mr. Trump intends to appoint as senior officials in his new administration. F.B.I. background checks have long been a routine part of transitions.... But Mr. Trump, who is hostile to the F.B.I. because of its role in various criminal and counterintelligence investigations into him, had let weeks pass without signing the agreement.... Despite the signing of the agreement, it remains unclear whether Mr. Trump's team plans to send the names of all officials requiring a security clearance or Senate confirmation to the F.B.I. for vetting." Read on for a brief report on Trump's now-rejected Plan A, pushed by "his top legal adviser, Boris Epshteyn."

Marie: I guess this is what can happen when Trump accidentally nominates someone who might be a decent guy: ~~~

Alejandra Jeramillo & Jack Forrest of CNN: "Chad Chronister, a Florida sheriff, has withdrawn from consideration as ... Donald Trump's pick to lead the Drug Enforcement Administration, he announced Tuesday. 'Over the past several days, as the gravity of this very important responsibility set in, I've concluded that I must respectfully withdraw from consideration,' Chronister, the sheriff of Hillsborough County, posted on X.... The Trump transition team declined to comment. Trump's choice of Chronister had received backlash from the MAGA corner of the Republican Party, some of whom took to social media to lambast the sheriff. Republican Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky critichtmlized Trump's selection in a post on X on Sunday, saying the sheriff 'should be disqualified' over his enforcement of Covid-19 protocols. Reacting to Chronister's withdrawal Tuesday, Massie said in a separate post that he was 'glad to see him withdraw from consideration.' There was also a belief among some allies of th president-elect that Chronister was not a true Republican, let alone a Trump loyalist. It is not clear whether this pushback to his selection led to him withdrawing his name." (Also linked yesterday.)

     ~~~ Marie: I was wondering how Trump happened to choose Chronister in the first place, and I'd guess this is it: fromthe CNN report: "Chronister's wife, Nicole DeBartolo, is the daughter of former San Francisco 49ers owner Edward DeBartolo Jr. During his first term, Trump granted Chronister's father-in-law a presidential pardon after he pleaded guilty in 1998 to failing to report a felony in a bribery case, which led to former Louisiana Gov. Edwin W. Edwards' federal prison sentence." So Chronister is not a celebrity; but he's related to one who's been in trouble with the law. Good enough.

Donald Trump, International Diplomat. James Liddell of the Independent: "Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau joined Trump for dinner at his Mar-a-Lago resort in Palm Beach, Florida, on Friday, for what Trump called a 'very productive' three-hour dinner between the two leaders. Sources told Fox News that, during the dinner, Trump joked that there is a way around the looming [taxes Trump planned to impose on our closest neighbor and ally]: Canada becoming America's 51st state. Trudeau, among others at the meeting, responded to the quip with nervous laughter, the source said." MB: At least he was going to pay for Greenland; Canada, he'll merely threaten into oblivion. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ David Gilmour of Mediaite: “Donald Trump posted an AI-generated image of himself standing beside the Canadian flag on a snow-capped mountain Tuesday.” Oddly, that snow-capped mountain is the Matterhorn, which even kids who went to Disneyland know is not in Canada but forms part of the border between Switzerland and Italy. Is Trump planning to take over those countries, too? ~~~

     ~~~ Alexandra Petri of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump ... is once again threatening to annex a peaceful neighbor for unclear reasons.... I, for one, am not afraid to say: I don't think annexing Canada is a good idea." Petri gives her reasons: something about the War of 1812, Napoleon in Russia, hostile Canadian geese and some other stuff. "Finally, perhaps most ominously, it would remove any last smidgen of doubt that Ted Cruz is eligible to run for president."

Sarah Ferris, et al., of CNN: "Donald Trump's choice of Pete Hegseth to run the Defense Department is in jeopardy amid questions from some key GOP senators over whether he's fit for the job. The pressure is forcing the president-elect's team to maneuver behind the scenes to avoid a second Cabinet pick from collapsing amid a Republican revolt, all while alternate names for Defense secretary, should Hegseth falter, begin to emerge.... The incoming chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, Roger Wicker, told CNN that he expects to see a whistleblower report outlining allegations of misconduct during Hegseth's time running a veterans' group. The New Yorker this week detailed the allegations in the report. [Heather Cox Richardson outlines some of those allegations below.]... Other reports have also emerged about Hegseth's conduct while employed at Fox News." (Also linked yesterday.) The Washington Post's story is here. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: I don't know. A perpetually-drunken sexual predator and abuser who loves him some convicted war criminals seems like just the person to run the massive Defense Department. ~~~

~~~ Heather Cox Richardson on Substack: "... Jane Mayer of the New Yorker reported that Trump's choice for secretary of defense, Fox News Channel weekend host Pete Hegseth, had been forced to leave previous leadership positions at the advocacy groups Veterans for Freedom and Concerned Veterans for America because of serious allegations of 'financial mismanagement, sexual impropriety, and personal misconduct.' Under his direction, Veterans for Freedom ran up huge debt for what appears to have been inappropriate expenses; the group's donors squeezed Hegseth out of his job and then shuttered the organization. He moved to Concerned Veterans for America. A whistleblower for Concerned Veterans for America reported that Hegseth was repeatedly so drunk at events that he had to be carried out, and that he once tried to join dancers on stage at a strip club to which he brought his work team. Their report said that Hegseth and other members of his team ... sexually pursued [female staffers], leading to allegations of sexual assault. Another complaint said that at a bar in the early hours of May 29, 2015, Hegseth began to chant drunkenly: 'Kill All Muslims! Kill All Muslims!' An email from one of the whistleblowers ... detailed Hegseth's 'history of alcohol abuse' and said he had 'treated the organization funds like they were a personal expense account -- for partying, drinking, and using CVA events as little more than opportunities to "hook up" with women on the road.'" (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

~~~ And Pete Keeps on Drinking. Chloe Males, et al., of NBC News: "Pete Hegseth ... drank in ways that concerned his colleagues at Fox News, according to 10 current and former Fox employees who spoke with NBC News. Two of those people said that on more than a dozen occasions during Hegseth's time as a co-host of 'Fox & Friends Weekend,' which began in 2017, they smelled alcohol on him before he went on air. Those same two people, plus another, said that during his time there he appeared on television after they'd heard him talk about being hungover as he was getting ready or on set. One of the sources said they smelled alcohol on him as recently as last month and heard him complain about being hungover this fall. None of the sources with whom NBC News has spoken could recall an instance when Hegseth missed a scheduled appearance because he'd been drinking."

Gary Fineout, et al., of Politico: "... Donald Trump is considering nominating Republican presidential rival Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis as Defense secretary, according to two people familiar with the situation. DeSantis would replace Pete Hegseth, whose prospects for confirmation appear to be dimming amid allegations of sexual assault and alcohol abuse." ~~~

     ~~~ Marc Caputo of the Bulwark: "Donald Trump and Ron DeSantis have personally discussed the possibility of the Florida governor becoming the next secretary of defense amid concerns that sexual assault allegations could engulf the president-elect's current nominee for the post, Pete Hegseth. The talks, relayed by four sources briefed on them, are in their advanced stages.... DeSantis is weighing whether to appoint Trump's daughter-in-law, Lara Trump, to fill [Marco] Rubio's Senate seat. The possibility that the governor himself could end up at the Pentagon may factor into that decision."

Annals of "Journalism," Ha Ha Ha. Brian Stelter of CNN: "What's a media outlet supposed to do when its longtime host is picked to run the Pentagon, and then a series of eyebrow-raising news stories trigger doubts about his appointment? If you're Fox News, evidently, you just pretend the stories don't exist. Fox News, which employed Pete Hegseth for a decade, has not covered the past week's controversies involving ... Donald Trump's nominee for defense secretary, according to SnapStream and TVEyes database searches. The omission is potentially significant because Fox is the top TV outlet for Republicans, and Hegseth's confirmation hinges on Republican senators. On Fox, Hegseth's former colleagues aren't raising alarms about the allegations or defending him -- they're just not talking about the issue at all."

Return of the Kleptocracy. John Hudson of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump offered billionaire investor Stephen Feinberg the job of deputy defense secretary, said people familiar with the matter, a decision that could elevate a longtime political supporter with investments in defense companies that maintain lucrative Pentagon contracts. A spokesman for Feinberg declined to say if the private-equity investor has accepted the potential nomination.... During the first Trump administration, Feinberg led the President's Intelligence Advisory Board, which provides the U.S. leader advice on intelligence assessments and estimates and counterintelligence matters....

"The search for a capable No. 2 has taken on heightened significance as lawmakers weigh the nomination of former Fox News personality Pete Hegseth to lead Trump's Pentagon as defense secretary. Hegseth, who has not run a large organization or held a senior Pentagon role, has faced scrutiny about his leadership abilities as opponents surface claims that he promoted a reckless drinking and party culture, and mismanaged the finances at veterans organizations he was involved with in recent years, both of which he denies."

Thanks, Joe! Shayna Jacobs of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump's felony conviction for falsifying business documents is tainted by the same corruption in the justice system that President Joe Biden decried when he announced his son's pardon, Trump's attorneys wrote in a document released Tuesday. The attorneys pointed to comments by Biden in defending his pardon of his son Hunter, in which he alleged the younger Biden was targeted by the president's detractors for political payback. Biden said in a statement that his son was 'selectively, and unfairly, prosecuted' and 'treated differently' than most. Trump's lawyers Todd Blanche and Emil Bove wrote in their court filing that the same corruption Biden described extended to the state court case handled by New York Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan. Merchan has rejected past claims by Trump lawyers that the case was tainted by political bias." An NBC News story is here.

Danny Hakim & Alessandro Sassoon of the New York Times: "Lawyers for Fani T. Willis, the Fulton County district attorney, and the Georgia legislature clashed in court on Tuesday as Republican lawmakers seek to force Ms. Willis to testify and turn over records as part of their review of her prosecution of ... Donald J. Trump and his allies for 2020 election interference. Since the U.S. Justice Department dropped its two cases against Mr. Trump..., Ms. Willis has the last active prosecution of the president-elect.... The case was upended after revelations in January that Ms. Willis had a romantic relationship with the private lawyer she hired to run the case. Mr. Trump and other defendants are seeking to disqualify Ms. Willis and her entire office.... Republican lawmakers in the State Senate have seized on the revelations about Ms. Willis's relationship and are seeking to force her to testify about it as part of their own review, even though she has already testified about it in court. Ms. Willis is fighting to avoid that."


In the Substack essay also linked above, Heather Cox Richardson goes on to discuss Joe Biden's pardon of his son Hunter. Besides running down a list of the usual reasons to favor the pardon as well as blaming the media for their double standard, Richardson writes, "As legal commentator Asha Rangappa noted: 'People criticizing the Hunter Biden pardon need to recognize: For the 1st time, the FBI and Justice Department could literally fabricate evidence, or collaborate with a foreign government to "find" evidence of a "crime," with zero accountability. That's why the pardon goes back to 2014.'" Thanks to Ken W. for the link. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Read Richardson's post because she covers a number of points I haven't seen elsewhere. Richardson herself does not specifically endorse the pardon, but her explanation as to who it was necessary is compelling. Nonetheless -- with the exception of Trump's horrifying appointments of Gaetz & Patel -- everything she reports in this regard is old news. Some of it is very old news. Yet Joe Biden himself said in June 2024 (after Hunter was found guilty in his first trial), and his team said even after the November election that he would not pardon Hunter. Why was that??? Joe Biden knew full well what Trump was capable of and reportedly his team's own internal polling going all the way back to this past summer showed that Trump would win the election. The more I dig into the nitty-gritty of it, the more I move from "disappointed" to "angry" at Joe Biden's behavior.

Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post subjects President Biden's pardon of his son to the Pinocchio test: "If you take the White House's word, Biden only came to this decision in recent days -- even though the statements he marshals in defense of a pardon could have been made back when he firmly stated, twice, that he would not pardon his son. It's possible that Trump's nominations of loyalists at the Justice Department and the FBI might have played a role in changing Biden's mind.... The White House has only hinted at that possibility. We can certainly see a good case for a Four-Pinocchio rating. Many pundits have accused Biden of lying. But we have not yet seen evidence that Biden made his statements in June knowing he would eventually reverse course.... Biden never addresses the fact that he once pledged not to pardon his son -- easily meeting our definition of a clear but unacknowledged 'flip-flop' from a previously held position." Kessler ends up giving Biden one upside-down Pinocchio.

CNN's Kaitlan Collins & Van Jones agree: since Joe Biden was willing to protect his son from political prosecutions, why not grant blanket pardons to others who are on Trump's hit list -- like Andrew McCabe & Mark Esper? Good question. (Mediaite link.)

Oh, leave it to Devlin Barrett, now sharing his thoughts on the pages of the New York Times, to take Joe Biden's pardon of his son and run with a front-page both-sides extravaganza. Sorry, kids, even though you read it in the New York Times, one of these things is not like the other. ~~~

     ~~~ Devlin Barrett of the New York Times: "Over a few days, the American justice system was buffeted by raw exercises of power from the current Democratic president and the incoming Republican president....The special counsel appointed to investigate ... Donald J. Trump is wrapping up his work without the charges he brought in two cases ever going in front of a jury. The special counsel named to lead the inquiry into Hunter Biden, the president's son, has just seen the two convictions he secured wiped away by a presidential pardon. Mr. Trump ... is trying to install a new F.B.I. director, Kash Patel, dedicated to turning the nation's premier law enforcement agency upside down. And President Biden, who for years cast himself as the principled defender of democratic norms and the rule of law, defended his grant of clemency to his son by saying Hunter had been 'selectively, and unfairly, prosecuted' in a process infected by 'raw politics.'" ~~~

     ~~~ In fairness to Barrett, a ways down the page he finds an ethics expert, Kathleen Clark, who says, "that in her view the Hunter Biden pardon was 'political malpractice' but not a broadside against the Justice Department. She is far more concerned, she said, about Mr. Trump's effort to install Mr. Patel at the F.B.I.... 'If we actually want someone who will administer the agency well, who has good judgment about law enforcement and intelligence issues, and who can stand up to and say no when appropriate, Kash Patel is exactly the wrong person.'" Further down the page, he reports that another professor, Michael Greenburger, who also was a DOJ official, "called the pardon 'a small, selfish act on Biden’s part, and I do not hold it against him.' By comparison, Mr. Greenberger argued, the planned pick of Mr. Patel 'is potentially a devastating blow' to the F.B.I." But we are still left with the impression that Barrett thinks he is comparing apples to apples when in fact he's comparing apples to the Orange Jesus.

Mitch Is Not Amused. Alexander Bolton of the Hill: "Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) vented his displeasure Monday after two Democratic-appointed federal judges reversed their decisions to retire in what appear to be efforts to stop ... Trump from nominating their successors. McConnell called the unusual decisions to forgo retirement following Trump's sweeping victory last month a 'partisan' gambit that would undermine the integrity of federal courts." MB: Thank goodness Mitch would never do anything partisan-y in confirming judges: like when he refused to give Merrick Garland a hearing for Supreme Court Justice when President Obama nominated Garland ten months before his presidential term expired but then McConnell pushed through Amy Phoney Barrett four months before Trump's term ended. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: I would say Scott Lemieux agrees with me. He writes, "It is dispositive evidence of a morally indifferent universe that Mitch McConnell can say this stuff without immediately being struck by lightning[.]"

~~~~~~~~~~

China/U.S. David Pierson, et al., of the New York Times: "China said on Tuesday that it would begin banning the export of several rare minerals to the United States, an escalation of the tech war between the world's two biggest powers. The move comes a day after the Biden administration tightened Chinese access to advanced American technology. The ban signals Beijing's willingness to engage in supply chain warfare by blocking the export of important components used to make valuable products, like weaponry and semiconductors. Sales of gallium, germanium, antimony and so-called superhard materials to the United States would be halted immediately on the grounds that they have dual military and civilian uses, China's Ministry of Commerce said. The export of graphite would also be subject to stricter review." (Also linked yesterday.)

South Korea. Hyung Jin-Kim & Kim Tong-Hyung of the AP: "South Korea's opposition parties Wednesday submitted a motion to impeach President Yoon Suk Yeol over the shocking and short-lived martial law that drew heavily armed troops to encircle parliament before lawmakers climbed walls to reenter the building and unanimously voted to lift his order. Impeaching Yoon would require the support of two-thirds of parliament and at least six justices of the nine-member Constitutional Court would have to support it to remove him from office. The motion, submitted jointly by the main opposition Democratic Party and five smaller opposition parties, could be put to a vote as early as Friday. Yoon's senior advisers and secretaries offered to resign collectively and his Cabinet members, including Defense Minister Kim Yong Hyun, were also facing calls to step down, as the nation struggled to make sense of what appeared to be a poorly-thought-out stunt.... Martial law lasted only about six hours, as the National Assembly voted to overrule Yoon and the declaration was formally lifted around 4:30 a.m. during a Cabinet meeting." ~~~

     ~~~ The New York Times' live updates of developments Wednesday are here. CNN's live updates of developments Wednesday are here. ~~~

~~~ Jack Kim & Ju-Min Park of Reuters: "President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law on Tuesday night, creating the most serious challenge to South Korea's democracy since the 1980s as lawmakers rejected the move in a vote and protesters gathered outside parliament. Yoon's declaration, which he cast as aimed at his political foes, was vocally opposed by the speaker of parliament and even the leader of Yoon's own party, Han Dong-hoon, who has clashed with the president over his handling of recent scandals. Under South Korean law, the president must immediately lift martial law if parliament demands it by a majority vote. Live television footage showed helmeted troops apparently tasked with imposing martial law attempting to enter the National Assembly building.Parliamentary aides were seen trying to push the soldiers back by spraying fire extinguishers. Yoon said in a TV broadcast that opposition parties had taken the parliamentary process hostage. He vowed to eradicate 'shameless pro-North Korean anti-state forces' and said he had no choice but to take the measure to safeguard constitutional order." Thanks to RAS for the link. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Yesterday, the New York Times liveblogged developments here. CNN live-updated developments here. (Also linked yesterday.)

Tuesday
Dec032024

The Conversation -- December 3, 2024

Marie: I guess this is what can happen when Trump accidentally nominates someone who might be a decent guy: ~~~

Alejandra Jeramillo & Jack Forrest of CNN: "Chad Chronister, a Florida sheriff, has withdrawn from consideration as ... Donald Trump's pick to lead the Drug Enforcement Administration, he announced Tuesday. 'Over the past several days, as the gravity of this very important responsibility set in, I've concluded that I must respectfully withdraw from consideration,' Chronister, the sheriff of Hillsborough County, posted on X.... The Trump transition team declined to comment. Trump's choice of Chronister had received backlash from the MAGA corner of the Republican Party, some of whom took to social media to lambast the sheriff. Republican Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky criticized Trump's selection in a post on X on Sunday, saying the sheriff 'should be disqualified' over his enforcement of Covid-19 protocols. Reacting to Chronister's withdrawal Tuesday, Massie said in a separate post that he was 'glad to see him withdraw from consideration.' There was also a belief among some allies of the president-elect that Chronister was not a true Republican, let alone a Trump loyalist. It is not clear whether this pushback to his selection led to him withdrawing his name."

     ~~~ Marie: I was wondering how Trump happened to choose Chronister in the first place, and I'd guess this is it: from the CNN report: "Chronister's wife, Nicole DeBartolo, is the daughter of former San Francisco 49ers owner Edward DeBartolo Jr. During his first term, Trump granted Chronister's father-in-law a presidential pardon after he pleaded guilty in 1998 to failing to report a felony in a bribery case, which led to former Louisiana Gov. Edwin W. Edwards' federal prison sentence." So Chronister is not a celebrity; but he's related to one who's been in trouble with the law. Good enough.

South Korea. Jack Kim & Ju-Min Park of Reuters: "President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law on Tuesday night, creating the most serious challenge to South Korea's democracy since the 1980s as lawmakers rejected the move in a vote and protesters gathered outside parliament. Yoon's declaration, which he cast as aimed at his political foes, was vocally opposed by the speaker of parliament and even the leader of Yoon's own party, Han Dong-hoon, who has clashed with the president over his handling of recent scandals. Under South Korean law, the president must immediately lift martial law if parliament demands it by a majority vote. Live television footage showed helmeted troops apparently tasked with imposing martial law attempting to enter the National Assembly building. Parliamentary aides were seen trying to push the soldiers back by spraying fire extinguishers. Yoon said in a TV broadcast that opposition parties had taken the parliamentary process hostage. He vowed to eradicate 'shameless pro-North Korean anti-state forces' and said he had no choice but to take the measure to safeguard constitutional order." Thanks to RAS for the link. ~~~

     ~~~ The New York Times is liveblogging developments here. CNN is live-updating developments here.

David Pierson, et al., of the New York Times: "China said on Tuesday that it would begin banning the export of several rare minerals to the United States, an escalation of the tech war between the world's two biggest powers. The move comes a day after the Biden administration tightened Chinese access to advanced American technology. The ban signals Beijing's willingness to engage in supply chain warfare by blocking the export of important components used to make valuable products, like weaponry and semiconductors. Sales of gallium, germanium, antimony and so-called superhard materials to the United States would be halted immediately on the grounds that they have dual military and civilian uses.... The export of graphite would also be subject to stricter review."

Donald Trump, International Diplomat. James Liddell of the Independent: "Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau joined Trump for dinner at his Mar-a-Lago resort in Palm Beach, Florida, on Friday, for what Trump called a 'very productive' three-hour dinner between the two leaders. Sources told Fox News that, during the dinner, Trump joked that there is a way around the looming [taxes Trump planned to impose on our closest neighbor and ally]: Canada becoming America's 51st state. Trudeau, among others at the meeting, responded to the quip with nervous laughter, the sources said." MB: At least he was going to pay for Greenland; Canada, he'll merely threaten into oblivion.

Heather Cox Richardson on Substack: "... Jane Mayer of the New Yorker reported that Trump's choice for secretary of defense, Fox News Channel weekend host Pete Hegseth, had been forced to leave previous leadership positions [link fixed] at the advocacy groups Veterans for Freedom and Concerned Veterans for America because of serious allegations of 'financial mismanagement, sexual impropriety, and personal misconduct.' Under his direction, Veterans for Freedom ran up huge debt for what appears to have been inappropriate expenses; the group's donors squeezed Hegseth out of his job and then shuttered the organization. He moved to Concerned Veterans for America. A whistleblower for Concerned Veterans for America reported that Hegseth was repeatedly so drunk at events that he had to be carried out, and that he once tried to join dancers on stage at a strip club to which he brought his work team. Their report said that Hegseth and other members of his team ... sexually pursued [female staffers], leading to allegations of sexual assault. Another complaint said that at a bar in the early hours of May 29, 2015, Hegseth began to chant drunkenly: 'Kill All Muslims! Kill All Muslims!' An email from one of the whistleblowers ... detailed Hegseth's 'history of alcohol abuse' and said he had 'treated the organization funds like they were a personal expense account -- for partying, drinking, and using CVA events as little more than opportunities to "hook up" with women on the road.'" ~~~

     ~~~ Richardson goes on to discuss Joe Biden's pardon of his son Hunter. Besides running down a list of the usual reasons to favor the pardon as well as blaming the media for their double standard, Richardson writes, "As legal commentator Asha Rangappa noted: 'People criticizing the Hunter Biden pardon need to recognize: For the 1st time, the FBI and Justice Department could literally fabricate evidence, or collaborate with a foreign government to "find' evidence of a "crime," with zero accountability. That's why the pardon goes back to 2014.'" Thanks to Ken W. for the link. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Read Richardson's post because she covers a number of points I haven't seen elsewhere. Richardson herself does not specifically endorse the pardon, but her explanation as to why it was necessary is compelling. Nonetheless -- with the exception of Trump's horrifying appointments of Gaetz & Patel -- everything she reports in this regard is old news. Some of it is very old news. Yet Joe Biden himself said in June 2024 (after Hunter was found guilty in his first trial), and his team said even after the November election that he would not pardon Hunter. Why was that??? Joe Biden knew full well what Trump was capable of and reportedly his team's own internal polling going all the way back to this past summer showed that Trump would win the election. The more I dig into the nitty-gritty of it, the more I move from "disappointed" to "angry" at Joe Biden's behavior.

~~~~~~~~~~

Katie Rogers & Glenn Thrush of the New York Times: "Support for pardoning Hunter Biden had been building for months within the [Biden] family, but external forces had more recently weighed on Mr. Biden, who watched warily as ... Donald J. Trump picked loyalists for his administration who promised to bring political and legal retribution to Mr. Trump's enemies. Mr. Biden had ... invited Mr. Trump to the White House, listening without responding as the president-elect aired familiar grievances about the Justice Department -- then surprised his host by sympathizing with the Biden family's own troubles with the department, according to three people briefed on the conversation. But it was Hunter Biden's looming sentencings on federal gun and tax charges, scheduled for later this month, that gave Mr. Biden the final push.... Mr. Biden's decision has tarnished a storied public legacy....

"Hunter Biden was hardly shy about telling the people around him that he wanted -- needed -- a pardon, although it is unclear how often he had discussed the matter directly with his father before this past week.... The final discussions about pardons excluded senior White House staff, including only the Bidens and defense lawyers. After the decision was made, aides were told to execute their orders, [said] a person familiar with the situation."~~~

Whether our nominee was the vice president or someone else, we would have had a much better chance to defeat Donald Trump.... His decision to pardon his son, no matter how unconditional his love, feels like another instance of putting his personal interest ahead of his responsibility to the country It further erodes Americans' faith that the justice system is fair and equal for all. -- Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.), one of the more thoughtful & least judgmental Democratic senators ~~~

~~~ Peter Baker of the New York Times: "Now, in the desultory final days of his administration, [President] Biden finds himself repudiated, even by some of his fellow Democrats, as the president who refused to step aside until it was too late, paved the way for Mr. Trump's return to power and, in a final gesture of personal grievance over stated principle, pardoned his own son for multiple felony convictions. The disappointment and frustration expressed by his own supporters since Mr. Biden intervened to spare his son Hunter from prison and any future investigations captured the disenchantment of many Democrats with the outgoing president as the end draws near.... The decision to attack the credibility of the justice system to safeguard a relative aggravated admirers who sympathized with his plight as a father yet were shocked that he would break his own promise to respect the courts' decision.... Mr. Biden is sliding toward the end of his presidency in lackluster fashion." ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Bear in mind that throughout his long public career, Joe Biden has often put his own interests before those of the country. Sometimes his self-interest was understandable, even laudable. Sometimes not so much. Even before he took the oath of office as senator, he decided not to fulfill his obligation to serve because of the sudden death of his wife and daughter and the severe injuries to both of his sons. He plagiarizes a lot, most infamously in his shortlived presidential campaign of 1987-88. He has always lied and exaggerated hos own supposed heroism. He mistreated Anita Hill, giving us Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas. This was one time Joe did keep his promises -- to White segregationist Southern senators. And of course he ran for president this year when (1) every poll showed he was extremely unpopular, and (2) those close to him knew he was losing it. So doing something that will make him more popular with the people who will be his primary caregivers over the next years fits well into his lifelong pattern of self-service. ~~~

~~~ Maya Miller of the New York Times: "Many Democratic lawmakers, particularly progressives, have defended [President] Biden's move as the justified action of a concerned father who fears that ... Donald J. Trump will abuse his power to follow through on his threats to seek retribution against his rivals. But others, especially moderate members of Congress, said the president's decision to pardon Hunter Biden -- which he repeatedly vowed he would not do -- would cause further damage to democratic norms.: Miller reports a number of comments from prominent Democrats. Politico's report is here. An AP report is here. ~~~

This is not a corrupt pardon. It's about taking care of a family member knowing what Trump will do otherwise. -- Prof. Kimberly Wehle of the University of Baltimore, in an email to the New York Times ...

~~~ Kenneth Vogel of the New York Times: The "sweeping amnesty [President Biden accorded his son Hunter] is raising awkward historical comparisons and sharp questions about the use of presidential clemency. It also has inflamed a debate about who deserves mercy and for what, while underscoring the Biden family's concerns about Hunter Biden's vulnerability to prosecution related to his foreign business activities.... 'It is extraordinarily hazardous to use the pardon power in a case where the person is an intimate of the president,' said Aziz Z. Huq, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School. Mr. Huq ... said President Biden's pardon of his son 'really does strike at the rule of law.'... Hunter Biden had yet to be sentenced, let alone to serve any time, so he would not have qualified for a recommendation from the [DOJ's Office of the Pardon Attorney, which vets and recommends to the president candidates for clemency], and it does not appear as if he applied for one.... Kimberly Wehle, a law professor at the University of Baltimore..., said in an email that it was Mr. Trump -- not President Biden -- who initiated 'the norm-violating behavior' by pledging to use the Justice Department to prosecute his enemies." ~~~

~~~ A Blueprint for Trump. Kyle Cheney & Betsy Swan of Politico: "In his sweeping pardon of Hunter Biden, President Joe Biden did not just protect his son. He also handed ... Donald Trump a template to shield his own allies and stretch the pardon power even further. Legal experts say Trump now has fresh precedent -- and political cover -- to issue expansive pardons absolving his allies not only of specific offenses, but even any undetermined crimes they may have committed.... The younger Biden is now effectively cleared of legal consequences for any federal law he might have broken over a nearly 11-year period. Those terms are so unusual -- and the process leading to it was so secretive -- that the Justice Department's Office of the Pardon Attorney ... was taken by surprise.... In the final days of Trump's first term, at least one close ally -- former Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) -- requested a similarly sweeping pardon, according to congressional testimony. But top White House aides made clear it was a nonstarter.... Almost immediately after the Hunter Biden pardon was announced, Trump hinted that he may cite it as justification for granting broad clemency to Jan. 6 defendants." ~~~

~~~ There was a good deal of back-and-forth in yesterday's Comments about President Biden's pardon of his wayward son Hunter. Nearly everyone disagreed with me; that is, they thought the pardon was cool. The best argument for the pardon, IMO (yet not convincing, of course), was Jeanne's: she's just pissed off at the vindictive Trumpy creeps, so screw them. Rational arguments were expressed, to be sure; I just don't think they hold up against counterarguments. ~~~

~~~ Scott Lemieux in LG&$ expresses a view similar to Jeanne's: "The idea that Republicans need a 'precedent' to do whatever they want or that the choices Biden makes will affect Trump's decisionmaking in any way is absurd. Trump pardoned a wealthy in-law who was guilty of more serious crimes and made him the announced nominee to be Ambassador to France earlier this week. And of course Trump pardoned many cronies and co-conspirators who committed crimes other people might actually be prosecuted for.... Indeed, if there's any precedent of material consequence here here it's Trump paying no political or criminal price for his unprecedented corruption and abuse of power. Democratic politicians wondering why they should be the only suckers left at the table is for better or worse going to be a predictable outcome of the normalization of Trump and his re-election."

~~~ If you want to read the gory details of of the political prosecution of Hunter Biden, here's a very, very long white paper (the summary runs to nearly nine pages) by Hunter's attorneys at Winston & Strawn. Via Marcy Wheeler. Bear in mind that the authors have an obvious bias, one that is indeed dictated by legal ethics. Nonetheless, it would be the height of stupid to pretend the investigation and prosecution of Hunter Biden was not poliitically-motivated. ~~~

~~~ Marcy Wheeler: “In the face of seeing Pam Bondi and Kash Patel preparing to redouble efforts to find politicized prosecutions against Donald Trump's adversaries, Joe Biden chose to end the process, with his son, at least. I'm actually on the record opposing the pardon -- but not for the reasons everyone else is.... I oppose the pardon because it eliminates Hunter's standing to appeal and with those appeals to begin telling the story that the media chose to ignore.... I think Biden fucked this one up. Not just for saying he wouldn't pardon Hunter, but for not taking action far earlier -- like firing David Weiss the day he was inaugurated, citing Trump's first impeachment, or pardoning Hunter and firing Weiss on November 6 -- to do something about this. I think Merrick Garland shouldn't have given Weiss himself SCO status (not least, because Weiss continues to investigate crimes -- the alleged attempted framing of Joe Biden by Alexander Smirnov -- to which he is a witness). I think Garland's supervision of Special Counsels allowed the abuse of the system, repeatedly.... Because the press has unquenchable thirst for lazy dick pic sniffing, they don't do the work of reading the court filings. Because the press thirsts for a false appearance of both sides neutrality, they're always on the hunt for something to fit into their both sides scandal box." Thanks to RAS for the link. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: And let me just say I am grateful to Wheeler for reminding us that the political prosecution of the son of his boss is one more thing Merrick Garland engineered. Garland is the worst attorney general since, well, Bill Barr. ~~~

~~~ Look for the Silver Lining. Eric Levitz, now of Vox: "... it is not hard to understand Biden's hypocrisy.... I suspect most fathers in his shoes would do as he has done. But Biden ... is, for a few more weeks anyway, the de facto leader of the Democratic Party. And this pardon does his co-partisans no favors. To the contrary, it reinforces the narrative that Democrats' ostensible horror at Trump's use of public power for private benefit is sanctimonious posturing.... Fortunately, Democrats now have the opportunity to demonstrate the sincerity of their ideals, while also mitigating one of their party's greatest political liabilities -- all by simply loudly and uniformly condemning Biden's pardon as an abuse of power.... The president's extraordinary unpopularity has weighed on Democrats for years now.... Democrats face little imperative to protect Biden's brand.... In pardoning Hunter, Biden has given both his son and his party a chance for a new beginning. Democrats should seize it." ~~~

~~~ digby: "All of our remonstrating about how Biden was pure and [Trump] is evil would have meant absolutely nothing unless we all want to see Hunter martyred over this nonsense just to prove a point (which woulodn't be proven anyway.) Meanwhile, Kash Patel and Pam Bondi are on record saying they would go after Hunter Biden and the rest of the 'Biden Crime Family' with everything they have. It's probably a good idea to take that seriously right now." Thanks to gonzo for the link. ~~~

~~~ Robert Reich on Substack: "The pardoning power was never supposed to be a means for presidents to put themselves, their families, members of their administration, and campaign staff above the law. Yet that's precisely what it has become. Bill Clinton pardoned his brother, Roger, on old drug charges. George H.W. Bush pardoned former Defense Secretary Caspar Weinberger and others in his administration on charges stemming from the Iran-Contra affair. As the framers of the Constitution saw it, the pardoning power was supposed to be a safety valve against injustice. The origins of the power in the United States Constitution are found in the 'prerogative of mercy' that originally appeared during the reign of King Ine of Wessex in the seventh century....

"Representative Steve Cohen, a Democrat from Tennessee's 9th District, has repeatedly introduced just such an amendment, which would prohibit a self-pardon and pardons of family members, administration officials, and campaign employees. It would also bar the president from issuing pardons to those whose crimes were committed to further a direct and significant personal interest of the president or others close to him or her, and those whose crimes were committed at the direction of, or in coordination with, the president." ~~~

~~~ Tom Nichols of the Atlantic: This pardon was "a tremendous strategic blunder, one that will haunt Democrats as they head into the first years of another Trump administration.... Had Biden not pardoned his son, elected Republicans at every level ... would have had to say, on the record, whether they agreed with Trump letting people who stormed the Capitol and assaulted law-enforcement officers out of jail.... The vulnerable Republicans running for reelection might have pleaded with him to avoid some of the more potentially disgusting pardons. Forget all that. Joe Biden has now provided every Republican ... with a ready-made heat shield against any criticism about Trump's pardons, past or present.... Even worse, he has inadvertently given power to Trump's narrative about the unreliability of American institutions.... Joe Biden could have waited until Hunter was sentenced for his federal crimes later this month and then commuted his punishments while fashioning a more limited pardon for other issues. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: This is a gift link from laura h. She has given you the opportunity to read the whole essay, so I urge you to do so. For those of you who disagree with Nichols (most of you, I gather), you will be happy to know he is a conservative, so he's probably written plenty you and I would challenge. ~~~

~~~ Jonathan Chait of the Atlantic: "President Biden's complaint about the higher standard applied to his son reflects the perspective of myopic privilege. Crimes by family members of powerful public officials are far more damaging to public confidence than similar crimes by anonymous people. Holding them to account through strict enforcement of the law is good and correct. What the president fails to note in his self-pitying statement is that Hunter Biden for years engaged in legal but wildly inappropriate behavior by running a business based on selling the perception of access to his father.... Joe Biden's defense of Hunter's influence peddling by stressing its narrow legality merely serves to highlight the hypocrisy of his fatherly indulgence.... With the pardon decision, like his stubborn insistence on running for a second term he couldn't win, Biden chose to prioritize his own feelings over the defense of his country." Thanks to laura h. for this gift link. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Whatever you think of this pardon, it's nearly impossible to refute Chait's arguments. What Biden conveniently forgot, and what criminals like Trump never consider, is what Julius Caesar said: that his wife must be above suspicion. It isn't just the wife; it's the relatives in general. A person certainly cannot control what his relatives do, and he can forgive them for their bad behavior for their sake and his own. But to issue a public pardon, to ensure that the relative will not face the consequences of his unlawful behavior, and to hold that relative to be above the law for whatever lame excuse or valid reason, is quite a different matter. To break one's own oath in doing so only magnifies the error in judgment. ~~~

~~~ John Dean Has an Idea. Ed Mazza of the Huffington Post: “John Dean, the former White House counsel who helped bring down President Richard Nixon in the Watergate scandal, urged President Joe Biden to go further with his pardons.... Dean ... urged Biden to issue blanket pardons to everyone ... Donald Trump has vowed to target when he returns to the White House next month [as well as to Trump himself]." ~~~

~~~ Marie: I did mention in yesterday's Comments the possibility of Trump & his lackeys arranging for the execution of Hunter Biden, but I didn't suggest seriously that it was a possibility. Perhaps I should have: ~~~

     ~~~ Steve M: "On the subject of the Hunter Biden pardon, I don't think we should dismiss this theory: [Jim "Not a Football Presenter" White wrote on Bluesky,] 'After spending some time wondering what could have tipped the balance leading to the Hunter Biden pardon, I finally started to think that the fascists may have been planning to use Hunter as their first ginned-up treason charge followed by execution.'... I won't be surprised if Trump, Patel, and Attorney General Pam Bondi try to bring President Biden up on treason charges, now that Hunter appears to be out of their reach. Right-wingers ... believe both Bidens were cashing in, and selling America out to China and Ukraine."

Minho Kim of the New York Times: "Warren Stephens, an investment banker and billionaire who donated to ... Donald J. Trump's rivals before eventually supporting him in the 2024 race, was tapped as Mr. Trump's ambassador to Britain on Monday. The selection of Mr. Stephens for the ambassadorship, a plum posting that often goes to one of the largest donors to a presidential campaign, was in part a nod to the American Opportunity Alliance, a big-money network of Republican donors in which Mr. Stephens plays a leadership role. Mr. Trump and the alliance had a tense relationship at times over the course of his campaign."

All the Things Kash Patel Said He Would Do to Destroy and Abuse the FBI. Elizabeth Williamson & Charlie Savage of the New York Times: "'Fire the top ranks of the F.B.I.' Encourage Congress to demand testimony exposing 'every single bit of filth and corruption' at the agency, and withhold its funding 'until the documents come in.' Prosecute leakers and journalists. Replace the national security work force with 'people who won't undermine the president's agenda.' These are among a long list of changes Kash Patel recommended in his 2023 book, 'Government Gangsters.'... Charles Kupperman, deputy national security adviser during the first Trump administration, warned that Mr. Patel's ideas would be anathema t the F.B.I.'s mission. 'The irony of this is that they all complained about the politicization of the F.B.I., and here Trump is putting in someone who's going to do just that,' Mr. Kupperman said in an interview. 'These are not reforms, they are punitive measures from a guy trying to be the enforcer for Trump.'... Mr. Patel would be well positioned to help carry out new investigations [into Donald Trump's political adversaries]....

"Mr. Patel has either threatened or filed defamation lawsuits against The New York Times, CNN and Politico for what he wrote was 'all the manifold lies they told about me while I worked at the White House.' So far he has not been successful. But he has not been deterred.... Mr. Patel has also ... said that leakers should be prosecuted.... In a September 2024 podcast, he declared that he would close the F.B.I.'s Washington headquarters and disperse the officials who work there to other parts of the country.... Mr. Patel called in his book for weakening civil service job protections for tens of thousands of career officials."

Peter Eavis & Jack Ewing of the New York Times: "A Delaware judge on Monday affirmed an earlier ruling that rescinded a giant pay package that Tesla had awarded its chief executive, Elon Musk. The pay, in the form of stock options, was worth more than $50 billion and helped make Mr. Musk the richest person in the world. The package is now worth $100 billion after Tesla's share price jumped sharply in recent weeks. The judge, Chancellor Kathaleen St. J. McCormick of the Delaware Court of Chancery, struck down the award in January, ruling that shareholders had not been properly informed of its details and that members of Tesla's board were not sufficiently independent. But lawyers for Tesla and Mr. Musk argued that a second shareholder vote in June in favor of the package cleared the way for effectively reinstating it." The story goes into the details of the dispute.

Dan Lamothe of the Washington Post: "The Senate on Monday confirmed an Army general's promotion to four-star officer after a Republican senator dropped the freeze on his nomination in the wake of backlash from retired military officers and some former Trump administration officials. Sen. Markwayne Mullin (R-Oklahoma) had placed a hold last month on the nomination of Lt. Gen. Christopher Donahue, who was on the ground during the evacuation of Afghanistan, to become a four-star general and the top commander at U.S. Army Europe. President Joe Biden nominated Donahue for the promotion, and the hold could have upended the general's career depending on how long it was extended. It came after ... Donald Trump pledged for months to fire any senior officer associated with the fall of Afghanistan.... Among those who backed Donahue are former defense secretary Mark T. Esper.... Retired Gen. Tony Thomas, a former head of U.S. Special Operations Command, last month called the hold a 'disgrace.'"

"I Forgot." Mariana Alfaro of the Washington Post: "A House Democratic staffer was arrested and charged Monday after entering the U.S. Capitol with rounds of ammunition, according to the Capitol Police. The staffer, identified as 38-year-old Michael Hopkins, was stopped by officers Monday morning while going through routine security screening as he entered the Cannon House Office Building and officers noticed 'what appeared to be ammunition on the x-ray screen.'... [According to a police statement,] 'The staffer told the officers that he forgot the ammunition was in the bag."

~~~~~~~~~~

Kansas. Kate Christobek of the New York Times: "A former Kansas police detective who had been accused of repeatedly sexually assaulting two women over several years while on duty was found dead on Monday, the first day of his trial on federal civil rights charges. Roger Golubski, 71, died of a fatal gunshot wound at his home in Edwardsville, west of Kansas City, Kan., according to the Kansas Bureau of Investigation. The police had responded to a 911 call reporting the sound of a gunshot and found Mr. Golubski dead on his back porch, the bureau said, adding that there were no signs of foul play.... Mr. Golubski, [who is White and] who retired from the Police Department in Kansas City, Kan., in 2010 after 35 years on the force, had long been suspected of raping and terrorizing Black women as he patrolled the streets.

Wisconsin. Mitch Smith of the New York Times: "A Wisconsin judge on Monday struck down portions of a 2011 law that stripped most government workers in the state of collective bargaining rights and set off fierce demonstrations. The ruling by Judge Jacob Frost of the Dane County Circuit Court is certain to be appealed. But his decision provided at least a temporary victory to labor unions and Democrats in Wisconsin, who turned out by the thousands to protest the law more than a decade ago and who have been trying ever since to take it off the books.... Republicans ... advanced the legislation despite large-scale protests at the State Capitol in Madison and an attempt by Democratic lawmakers to scuttle the vote by fleeing to Illinois." Thanks to Ken W. for the link.

~~~~~~~~~~

Israel/Palestine, et al. One President at a Time, Ha Ha. Ephrat Livni of the New York Times: "... Donald J. Trump on Monday demanded that the hostages taken in the Hamas-led attack on Israel be released from Gaza before his inauguration in January, or there will be 'hell to pay' in the Middle East for those responsible. Writing on Truth Social, and without naming any militant group, Mr. Trump said in his post: 'If the hostages are not released prior to January 20, 2025, the date that I proudly assume Office as President of the United States, there will be ALL HELL TO PAY in the Middle East, and for those in charge who perpetrated these atrocities against Humanity. Those responsible will be hit harder than anybody has been hit in the long and storied History of the United States of America. RELEASE THE HOSTAGES NOW!'" ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Pardon my cynicism, but Bibi must have told Donald he was about to agree to a hostage deal, so Trump is doing this in order to take credit for release of the hostages.

Ukraine, et al. John Ismay of the New York Times: "The Pentagon will send Ukraine an additional $725 million in military assistance from its stockpiles, including anti-personnel land mines, drones, portable antiaircraft missiles and anti-tank missiles. In a statement, the Pentagon said on Monday that the shipment was part of a surge in security aid as Ukraine battles a renewed Russian offensive. The new support comes amid deep concerns in Ukraine that the incoming Trump administration might cut off military aid to the country. President-elect Donald J. Trump has vowed to end the war quickly, though he has not said how. But ... JD Vance has outlined a plan that would allow Russia to keep the Ukrainian territory it has seized."