The Commentariat -- Dec. 23, 2015
Internal links removed.
Afternoon Update:
For more on Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin (RTP), see Akhilleus's commentary in today's thread. While Bevin is hurting thousands of Kentuckians, there is irony in his hurting the very people who probably voted for him: low-income state workers.
*****
Bill Scher in Real Clear Politics: "Presidential scholars have a term to describe the typical experience of a chief executive who wins re-election to the White House. It's called the 'second-term curse.' There's evidence for it. Midway through their second terms, George W. Bush suffered Hurricane Katrina and the Iraqi quagmire, Bill Clinton was impeached, Ronald Reagan was staggered by the Iran-contra scandal,and Richard Nixon was run out of town. At the risk of jinxing our current president with one year left to go, he appears to have broken the curse." Via Steve Benen, whose commentary is worth reading, too.
Julie Davis of the New York Times: "... President Obama released letters he had received from gay members of the military thanking the president for repealing the 'don't ask, don't tell' policy exactly five years ago. Mr. Obama promised in a corresponding Facebook post that he would spend the remainder of his presidency looking for ways to combat discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans.... Mr. Obama's victory lap on the 'don't ask, don't tell' anniversary came amid criticism from some Republicans and conservatives that he has not done enough to support the military. Conservative news outlets reacted with outrage on Monday after the president allowed himself to be photographed celebrating a golf shot at the start of his two-week Hawaiian vacation, but did not make any comments to the news media about the death just hours earlier of six American soldiers in a suicide attack in Afghanistan." ...
... CW: "Conservative news outlets reacted with outrage" should be the sentence of the decade. Google it, & you get dozens of entries on unrelated topics, "conservatives reacting with outrage" to whatever. Also, Ms. Davis, a single Facebook entry does not constitute a "victory lap." It's true that President Obama has been on a bit of a victory lap, using year-end events like his press conference to tout his administration's accomplishments. A "lap" is a series of actions, not a single incidence. Pardon my pedantry.
Jeff Toobin of the New Yorker: "... President Obama is starting to come around on pardons, or at least on commutations.... Obama is moving in the right direction, but he has a long way to go.... Over the last year of his Presidency, his Administration should publish the names of people being considered for pardons.... This public airing might well save Obama from making some poor choices, but it will also guarantee him a measure of political protection.... The pardon power, with its roots in the monarchy, allows a President to go big -- and that's exactly how Obama should go."
Keith Alexander, et al., of the Washington Post: "More than 50 police officers involved in fatal shootings this year had previously fired their guns in deadly on-duty shootings, according to a Washington Post investigation.... The Post also found that an additional 45 officers had previously been involved in non-fatal shootings. The findings concerned many law enforcement experts, who said that most officers never fire their weapons on the job. The analysis also exposed another gap in the federal government's oversight of fatal police shootings nationwide: the absence of a system for tracking multiple shootings by individual officers.... In most cases, the person killed was armed and the shootings were found to be justified by authorities or were still under investigation."
Our Crooked Congress Prospers. Charles Pierce: "Buried in the budget deal that now has emerged from Congress is a provision by which the IRS will be actively forbidden from enacting new rules in 2016 to rein in the obvious scams in which most of the 501(c)4's engage. I don't care how loudly the flying monkeys howl at Speaker Paul Ryan for 'betraying' them by striking a deal at all, this is the real joker in the deck, and the fact that this principle was so easily bargained away says a great deal about the people in power from both political parties. They have accepted the new reality of legalized influence-peddling and are finding ways to prosper in it. This, I guess, is another New Normal in our politics."
William Frey, in the Washington Post, demonstrates how a Supreme Court decision for the plaintiff in the voting rights case Evenwel v. Abbott , who want legislative districts to be based on voters, not residents, would result in strongly skewing districts in favor of older, white citizens.
Thomas Edsall of the New York Times discusses political correctness, & it turns out everybody, from President Obama on down to Donald Trump, thinks political correctness is an outrageous disruption of free speech. ...
... CW: Edsall doesn't bother to discriminate among the types of so-called political correctness. There's a big difference between criticizing the "coddling of college students" (Obama) & calling women "fat pigs, dogs, slobs and disgusting animals" (Trump). Edsall lumped together average people who don't like to have to "be careful" what they say around "certain people" & Ben Carson's complaint that "'political correctness' bears the responsibility for the criticism he ... faced ... when he said he would 'not advocate that we put a Muslim in charge of this nation.'" Anway, Edsall, as he does quite often, exhibits the downside of both-siderism. Dana Milbank (column linked yesterday) did a much better job of capturing how Trump, Carson & the whole winger crowd have abused the term political correctness & used it as a catchall to criticize all manner of supposed liberal policies.
Annals of Journalism. Ken Ritter of the AP: "The editor of the Las Vegas Review-Journal capped more than a week of turmoil sparked by the sale of Nevada's largest newspaper to the family of casino magnate and Republican party kingmaker Sheldon Adelson with an announcement on Tuesday that he's stepping down. Mike Hengel stunned the newsroom with word that he had accepted a voluntary buyout, according to several staff members who took to Twitter after the announcement."
Presidential Race
Patrick Healy of the New York Timeslooks back on the year in presidential campaigning.
Bernie Sanders, in a New York Times op-ed: "To rein in Wall Street, we should begin by reforming the Federal Reserve, which oversees financial institutions and which uses monetary policy to maintain price stability and full employment. Unfortunately, an institution that was created to serve all Americans has been hijacked by the very bankers it regulates."
Fox Business Gets Down to Business. Ben Kamisar of the Hill: "As few as six candidates could make the next GOP presidential debate stage in January, as Fox Business Network's new criteria could drastically shrink the field less than a month before the Iowa caucuses.... Using current RealClearPolitics averages, Donald Trump, Sen. Ted Cruz (Texas), Sen. Marco Rubio (Fla.), Ben Carson, former Gov. Jeb Bush (Fla.), and Gov. Chris Christie (N.J.) currently sit in the national top six.... That would relegate Sen. Rand Paul (Ky.), Carly FIorina, and Gov. John Kasich (Ohio) to the undercard debate...."
Nick Corasantini & Matt Flegenheimer of the New York Times: "Soaring advertising costs in early primary states are compelling major 'super PACs' to realign their tactics, de-emphasizing costly broadcast commercials in favor of the kind of nuts-and-bolts work that presidential candidates used to handle themselves. They are overseeing extensive field operations, data-collection programs, digital advertising, email lists, opposition research and voter registration efforts.... Originally conceived as a vehicle to raise and spend unlimited money on television, the most expensive part of a White House run, the groups now are seeking to relieve campaigns of much of the vital infrastructure that candidates would otherwise have to assemble and manage themselves." ...
... CW: Now I'd like one of you brilliant legal scholars -- maybe you, John Roberts, because I'm pretty sure you never miss a day of Reality Chex -- explain to me how compiling e-mails lists & collecting other data, etc., constitutes "free speech." It's one think to say, "I like Ted"; quite another to skulk around looking for Marco's lovechild.
Alan Rappeport of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump's tax plan would benefit the wealthiest Americans the most while saddling the economy with trillions of dollars in new debt, according to an analysis released on Tuesday by the Tax Policy Center.... Despite the populist tone of his campaign, Mr. Trump's plan appears to open new loopholes that would allow the well-off to shave their tax bills and could debilitate the economy as lawmakers look for requisite spending cuts.... While Mr. Trump said that billionaires like himself would be hit the hardest under his plan, the Tax Policy Center disagrees." ...
Jonathan Capehart of the Washington Post: "Trump's support is deeper than we want to admit." ...
... Zachary Goldfarb of the Washington Post: Donald Trump's saying it was 'too disgusting' to talk about Hillary Clinton's bathroom break & "that she had got 'schlonged' by Barack Obama ... was another example of his mastery in exploiting the psychological biases of conservatives...." It turns out that research shows conservatives are more easily "disgusted" than liberals & don't like talking/thinking about private parts. ...
... CW: I have always thought this was the main reason conservatives are so often anti-gay; they just don't like being reminded about nasty, dirty sex, & when they do speak of sex, they joke about it and/or treat it in terms of conquest & power dynamics -- the kind of "discourse" you might have engaged in when you were in 7th grade. We've already learned that Trump uses a third-grader's vocabulary. His disengagement with facts & truth also are childish. His simplistic ideas -- build a wall, make the Mexicans pay -- & ignorance of Government 101, his insults, his schoolyard bullying & his love of glitz -- almost everything about him suggests remarkably arrested development. He models his followers -- people whose sociopathy is rooted in their failure to grow past grade-school intellectual & social developmental levels. No, Donald, you are not "like very, very smart," and neither are your supporters. ...
... Apparently, Trump also considers women's breasts to be private parts, & the mere mention of their biological function also is "disgusting." Although Trump thinks it important to have "a young and beautiful piece of ass" at his disposal, the women function as symbols of his power, not as sexual, or -- God forbid -- romantic partners. This is the same dynamic you see in his comment that Barack Obama "schlonged" Hillary Clinton. "Schlong" as verb is not idiomatic Yiddish; Trump appropriated the noun to describe a real political power struggle in ruthless sexual terms: a young black man conquering/raping an older white woman. This of course plays into the false stereotype of young black men as dangerous sexual predators -- so Trump's coinage of "schlonged" is a two-fer. Trump's hatred of Obama is pathological -- Trump sees Obama as a potent young black man who would conquer/rape those pieces of ass Trump parades as power trophies. Trump's pathetic birtherism foray was all about his own sexual insecurity. Thanks to Victoria D. for the link to Nina Bahadur's Huffington Post piece on 18 things Trump has said about women. That will be 5 cents, please. ...
... Evan McMorris-Santoro of BuzzFeed: "Donald Trump 'has discovered that women go to the bathroom and it's very upsetting for him,' [Bernie] Sanders told a large crowd of laughing college students.... 'He must have a very unusual relationship with women,' Sanders said. He noted that he too took a pit stop at the debate."
Behind Closed Doors. Mike Allen of Politico: "In June, Ted Cruz promised on NPR that opposition to gay marriage would be 'front and center' in his 2016 campaign. In July, he said the Supreme Court's decision allowing same-sex marriage was the 'very definition of tyranny' and urged states to ignore the ruling. But in December, behind closed doors at a big-dollar Manhattan fundraiser..., [Cruz] assured a Republican gay-rights supporter that a Cruz administration would not make fighting same-sex marriage a top priority."
Beyond the Beltway
AP: "Republican Kentucky governor Matt Bevin ordered the state to prepare new marriage licenses that do not include the names of county clerks, in an attempt to protect the religious beliefs of clerk Kim Davis and other local elected officials.... 'The requirement that the county clerk's name appear on marriage licenses is prescribed by Kentucky law and is not subject to unilateral change by the governor,' the [ACLU] says.... Davis and her supporters had asked [former Gov. Steve] Beshear [D] to issue a similar executive order. Beshear had refused, arguing only the state legislature had the authority to change the state law requiring the contents of the marriage license form."
AP: "A federal judge ruled on Tuesday that Utah can cut off federal funds to the state's Planned Parenthood organization, a move the Republican governor ordered after the release of secretly recorded videos by an anti-abortion group. The ruling from US district judge Clark Waddoups reversed an earlier decision.... His ruling allows Utah to cut off funds ... while the organization still pursues its lawsuit against the state."
Jenna Portnoy of the Washington Post: Virginia "Attorney General Mark R. Herring (D) announced Tuesday that Virginia will no longer recognize concealed carry handgun permits from 25 states that have reciprocity agreements with the commonwealth. Under the policy, Virginians with a history of stalking, drug dealing or inpatient mental-health treatment cannot obtain a permit in a state with comparatively lax laws and carry a handgun legally at home." (Also linked yesterday.) ...
... Voting Saves Lives. CW: If you recall, Herring won election by "a mere 165 votes out of more than 2 million cast." This is why you vote Democratic, even if the candidate isn't super-progressive.
Way Beyond
New York Times: "For the first time, Iraqi forces engaged Islamic State fighters within the city center of Ramadi on Tuesday, reaching the edge of the inner government district in an attempt to seize the critical western provincial capital after months of approach and maneuvering, officials said."
Tim Arango of the New York Times: "On land and at sea, Turkey's borders, long a revolving door of refugees, foreign fighters and the smugglers who enable them, are at the center of two separate yet interlinked global crises: the migrant tide convulsing Europe and the Syrian civil war that propels it. Accused by Western leaders of turning a blind eye to these critical borders, Turkey at last seems to be getting serious about shoring them up. Under growing pressure from Europe and the United States, Turkey has in recent weeks taken steps to cut off the flows of refugees and of foreign fighters who have helped destabilize a vast portion of the globe, from the Middle East to Europe." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Rick Lyman of the New York Times: "Interviews with aid workers and dozens of refugees making their way across a half-dozen countries revealed a widespread fear of the Bulgarian authorities. They talked of rough or violent behavior by border guards, who will register and fingerprint the migrants -- meaning they have to stay in Bulgaria while their cases are adjudicated -- or push them back into Turkey. The Bulgarian government, which like its counterparts in many other Central and Eastern European capitals has been far less welcoming of refugees than those in most of Western Europe, dismissed suggestions of systemic efforts to intimidate refugees."
News Lede
New York Times: "A Walmart truck driver who crashed his tractor-trailer into a vehicle carrying the comedian Tracy Morgan, critically injuring Mr. Morgan and killing another passenger, was indicted on Wednesday by a New Jersey grand jury on charges of manslaughter, vehicular homicide and aggravated assault."