The Commentariat -- August 27, 2020
Afternoon Update:
Max Cohen & Matthew Choi of Politico: "Support for Joe Biden's White House bid is growing among staffers of past presidential campaigns -- Republican ones, that is. Several dozen former staffers from Sen. Mitt Romney's (R-Utah) presidential campaign, the George W. Bush administration and the campaign and Senate staff of former Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) have signed on to an effort to elect Joe Biden. For the Romney and McCain staffers, they're working to elect the same man they tried to defeat in 2012 and 2008, respectively.... In an open letter obtained by Politico, the group 'Romney Alumni for Biden' says Trump's rhetoric and actions are antithetical to the Republican Party they believe in.... The 34 total signatories include finance, operations, policy and events staffers from Romney's presidential bid. Politico also received in advance a letter from Bush alumni supporting Biden, whose signatories include former Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez, Bush domestic policy adviser Sally Canfield, former Ambassador James Glassman and former U.S. Treasurer Rosario Marin. The group praised Biden's decency and ability to work across party lines and launched a website raising money for ... [Biden]." ~~~
~~~ Rebecca Shabad & Mike Memoli of NBC News: "Several hundred former aides to President George W. Bush and Sen. John McCain announced Thursday that they are endorsing Joe Biden for president.... A political action committee, 43 Alumni for Biden, that launched last month posted a list of nearly 300 members of the Bush administration or campaigns who are publicly backing Biden.... Earlier this week, more than two dozen former Republican Congress members backed Biden for president." ~~~
~~~ Jonathan Martin of the New York Times: "More than 100 former staff members for Senator John McCain are supporting Joseph R. Biden Jr., a show of support across the political divide that they hope amplifies the 'Country First' credo of the former Arizona senator. That motto and 'his frequent call on Americans to serve causes greater than our self-interest were not empty slogans like so much of our politics today,' the group of aides, most of them still Republicans, wrote in a joint statement, praising Mr. McCain and implicitly taking aim at President Trump.... The list of signatories includes a range of people -- from chiefs of staff in Mr. McCain's Senate office to junior aides on his campaigns -- who worked for him over his 35 years in Congress and during two presidential bids. Mark Salter, Mr. McCain's longtime chief aide and speechwriter, helped organize the letter.... Coinciding with Mr. Trump's renomination acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention on Thursday and the second anniversary of Mr. McCain's death this week, the joint endorsement of Mr. Biden represents the latest effort from anti-Trump Republicans to lure conservatives and moderates away from the president." ~~~
~~~ Salter's letter is published as an op-ed in the Washington Post. Here's the statement by the McCain group, published in Medium, & the list of signatories.
Glenn Kessler, et al., of the Washington Post: "The third night of the Republican National Convention yet again offered a cascade of false claims, especially in Vice President Pence's speech. Here are 20 claims that caught our attention." Mrs. McC: This is a remarkable list of whoppers. All of the puppet-makers in all the world could not make enough Pinocchio marionettes to cover one GOP convention.
Shutting the Stable Door After the Horse's Ass Has Bolted. Vivian Salama of CNN: "The Department of Homeland Security sent an agency-wide email to its employees Thursday morning reminding them not to participate in partisan politics, citing "heightened scrutiny." While directives like this are standard in election years, the warning comes days after acting Homeland Security Secretary Chad Wolf participated in a swearing in ceremony with ... Donald Trump for naturalized Americans as part of the Republican National Convention, raising ethics concerns.... Signed by Joseph Maher, the agency's designated ethics official, the email references the Hatch Act, which stipulates that most executive-branch officials must not engage in political activity in an official capacity at any time...." ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: BTW, the official name of the Hatch Act is "An Act to Prevent Pernicious Political Activities." Nearly everything Trump does is a pernicious political activity.
Now, Don't Get Confused by Another Quasi-Reversal by Another Gutless Wonder. From Thursday's NYT coronavirus updates: "The director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has scaled back the agency's recommendation advising some people not to get tested after exposure to the novel coronavirus, now saying 'testing may be considered for all close contacts of confirmed or probable Covid-19 patients.' The statement by Dr. Robert R. Redfield was issued to some news outlets late Wednesday, and more broadly Thursday morning, after a storm of criticism over the new C.D.C. guidelines -- involving potentially asymptomatic people -- which were the product of the White House Coronavirus Task Force and not C.D.C.'s own scientists. Dr. Redfield made the statement in an effort to clarify the new policy, an official said. However, the guidelines issued earlier this week remained on the C.D.C.'s website as of Thursday morning, and it appears unlikely that the agency will change them."
Dropping the Mic. Ben Strauss of the Washington Post: "About 30 minutes into a makeshift pregame show without any basketball to follow it, TNT's 'Inside the NBA' cut to former NBA star Chris Webber. Webber was supposed to call one of Wednesday night's playoffs games from the Orlando bubble. But all three games were postponed after players, led by the Milwaukee Bucks, said they would not play in protest of the shooting of Jacob Blake, the unarmed Black man, by police in Kenosha, Wis. Choking back tears, Webber delivered an impassioned monologue supporting the players' historic actions.... Webber's words came just a few minutes after the opening moments of the show, during which Kenny Smith, a former NBA player and host, walked off the set in solidarity with the players. 'For me, I think the biggest thing now -- as a black man and a former player -- I think it's best for me to support the players and just not be here tonight,' Smith said before taking off his microphone and leaving his chair." The Colbert segment embedded below has video of Smith's extraordinary protest.
Grifter-in-Chief. David Fahrenthold, et al., of the Washington Post: "Trump has now visited his own properties 270 times as president, according to a Washington Post tally -- with another visit planned for Thursday, when he is scheduled to meet GOP donors at his Washington hotel. Through these trips, Trump has brought the Trump Organization a stream of private revenue from federal agencies and GOP campaign groups. Federal spending records show that taxpayers have paid Trump's businesses more than $900,000 since he took office. At least $570,000 came as a result of the president's travel, according to a Post analysis. Now, new federal spending documents obtained by The Post via a public-records lawsuit give more detail about how the Trump Organization charged the Secret Service -- a kind of captive customer, required to follow Trump everywhere.... The documents show that the Trump Organization charged daily 'resort fees' to Secret Service agents guarding Vice President Pence in Las Vegas and in another instance asked agents to pay a $1,300 'furniture removal charge' during a presidential visit to a Trump resort in Scotland. In addition, campaign finance records have provided new details about the payments the Trump Organization received from GOP groups, as a result of the 37 instances in which Trump headlined a political event at one of his properties. Those visits have brought the company at least $3.8 million in fees, according to a Post analysis of campaign spending records." ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie's Financial Planning Advice to Future Presidents & Vice Presidents: Buy or build an expensive resort in some isolated place in the USA & go there at every opportunity and charge the federal government exorbitant rates for every possible thing. I'm sure Republicans wouldn't mind if Joe Biden and Kamala Harris tried this stunt.
~~~ AND There's This from the WashPo report: "In response to questions for this report, White House spokesman Judd Deere said in a statement..., 'The Washington Post is blatantly interfering with the business relationships of the Trump Organization, and it must stop.... Please be advised that we are building up a very large "dossier" on the many false David Fahrenthold and others stories as they are a disgrace to journalism and the American people.'" ~~~
~~~ Oliver Darcy of CNN: David "Fahrenthold wrote on Twitter that if anyone knows 'anything about a dossier the White House has supposedly compiled' on him, to let him know or provide him a copy. Fahrenthold won a Pulitzer Prize in 2017 for 'casting doubt' on Trump's 'generosity toward charities' in his coverage. He has also reported on Trump's businesses. Last summer, The New York Times reported that allies of the White House had compiled dossiers on hundreds of people who work for top news organizations. The White House's boasting of building a dossier on Fahrenthold and other journalists is jarring, but perhaps not surprising from an administration that has branded the press as 'the enemy of the people.' Trump and his allies have for years aimed to discredit journalists and news organizations, often through the use of lies and dishonest rhetoric." ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: Jarring? Compiling dossiers on reporters & warning them off negative stories about a "leader" & his cohort are exactly what repressive dictators & their henchmen do in repressive, non-democratic regimes. I don't of an American president* who has done so and admitted to it. Richard Nixon, infamously, did have an "enemies list" (or two) that included journalists, the purpose of which was to "screw" the "enemies" with tax audits & other means. But Nixon didn't kept his tactics secret. John Dean revealed it to the Senate Watergate Committee during hearings, & journalist Daniel Schorr -- who made the list -- obtained a copy of the original list "and read names from the list live on CBS television on this day." (Schorr didn't realize he was included until he read it on TV.)
Gangsta Rap. David Corn of Mother Jones: "On December 10, 2015, Donald Trump took time off from campaigning for the Republican presidential nomination to spend hours sitting for a videotaped deposition in a lawsuit alleging that he and Trump University had defrauded people who had plunked down thousands of dollars to learn the secrets of his financial success as a developer. During a break in the proceedings, the camera continued to roll. And Trump and his attorney, Daniel Petrocelli ... were captured discussing the case. In this 13-minute hot-mic video ... Trump boasted about how his company threatened the Better Business Bureau to change the D rating it had assigned Trump University to an A. He complained about the federal judge overseeing the suit, Gonzalo Curiel, elliptically talking about how to challenge him and referring to 'the Spanish thing.' Trump also griped that he had been sued personally in this case, and Petrocelli had to explain to Trump that he, not just Trump University itself, was in the legal crosshairs because Trump had been accused of making false statements to promote the venture. And Petrocelli pointed out that the case was not a lock for Trump because some of Trump's 'guys' had been 'sloppy.'"
~~~~~~~~~~
Presidential Race, Etc.
~~~ As NiskyGuy writes in today's Comments, "Colbert got it right last night. Again."
Matt Flegenheimer & Katie Glueck of the New York Times: "The America that many speakers described on Wednesday at the Republican National Convention did not sound like a desirable place: fractious, violent, functionally lawless in some pockets. But their case that only President Trump could shield Americans from this fate was complicated by a nettlesome fact. He is in charge, at present.... The third night of the Republican convention steered into a bit of messaging jujitsu that has become a dominant theme of the week: Mr. Trump's ability to turn back Trump-era ills that have, in this telling, been largely out of his hands to date.... 'You won't be safe,' [Mike Pence] said, 'in Joe Biden's America.' Even as president, Mr. Trump has often appeared most comfortable in the role of back-seat driver, jeering his own government like a common bystander, insisting that someone really ought to do something about all this.... Through it all, the intended takeaway has seemed clear: Mr. Trump is in control of the good but not responsible for the bad, worthy of praise for America's successes and exoneration for its struggles." ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: I can tell you right now why Republicans, especially evangelicals, will buy this paradox: it is exactly what they believe of the Hebrew God. Their god is almighty, but bad things befall believers because they -- or someone -- has succumbed to Satan. Trump and his disciples are presenting him as an earthly god, while Joe Biden and "Democrat mayors" are Satan and his band of evil-doers. Trump is no theologian, but he has -- perhaps intuitively -- recognized & adopted the structural core of Christianity & Judaism.
Seung Min Kim, et al., of the Washington Post: "Republicans used the third day of their national convention to portray President Trump as a strong defender of conservative principles on law enforcement, defense and the economy -- emphasizing his law-and-order credentials as social unrest flared again after another police shooting of a Black man.... None of the speakers specifically addressed the police shooting of Jacob Blake Jr., a Black man, in Kenosha, Wis., on Sunday...."
Politico has a "highlights" report of Wednesday night's The New Trump Show, featuring women who said what a caring feminist Trump is. The fact-checking here is weak, though. For instance, one of Kayleigh McEnany's big points was that Trump would make sure people with pre-existing conditions were guaranteed coverage, even though Trump has fought throughout his presidency* to repeal the Affordable Care Act, the law that guarantees coverage for pre-existing conditions.
Mrs. Bea McCrabbie: One likely outcome of the Republican National Convention: it will become a coronavirus super-spreader. Besides a number of maskless people sitting together for Melanie's speech Tuesday night, there were even more maskless people sitting close together for pence's speech at Fort McHenry Wednesday. Then Donald Trump showed up. According to CNN, a number of audience members Wednesday said they were not tested for coronavirus, and at Tuesday's event, only the people sitting closest to Trump were tested. After pence's speech, Trump & the Mrs. stood around chatting with guests.
The New York Times' live updates of Wednesday's episode of Trump TV programming are here. The Washington Post's live updates are here. The Guardian's live updates are here. ~~~
~~~ Here's New York Times reporters' live snark chat about the convention's Wednesday session. Politico reporters' live analysis is here.
Gene Robinson of the Washington Post: "What country does Vice President Pence live in? During his acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention on Wednesday, Pence sounded as though he lived in some kind of fantasyland that perhaps had encountered a few tiny little bumps in the road. His party has spent the week claiming to represent 'the common man,' but Pence spoke as though he knew next to nothing about the daunting challenges that Americans are having to deal with every day. The most he could muster was an acknowledgement that 'we're passing through a time of testing,' as though he were consoling a motorist after a fender bender. He did offer 'our prayers' for victims of Hurricane Laura, and he acknowledged there had been deaths from the coronavirus pandemic, though not how many. But his only pointed and specific words were his attacks against the Democratic nominee -- 'You won't be safe in Joe Biden's America' -- and his full-throated endorsement of President Trump's 'law and order' rhetoric."
Abraham Lincoln once famously said, 'America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves.' -- Lara Trump, Wednesday at Republican convention, citing a right-wing meme which both PolitiFact and Snopes have debunked
At what point then is the approach of danger to be expected? I answer, if it ever reach us, it must spring up amongst us. It cannot come from abroad. If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher. As a nation of freemen, we must live through all time, or die by suicide. -- @Real Abraham Lincoln, January 1838
What would make anyone think Lara's "quote" reads anything like something Lincoln would have said? And yeah, if we Americans re-elect Lara's father-in-law we will ourselves be the authors & finishers of our own destruction. -- Mrs. Bea McCrabbie
** Rebecca Beitsch of the Hill: "The National Park Service (NPS) is in hot water with ethics watchdogs for a slickly produced video promoting President Trump along with its plans to host a fireworks spectacle after his acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention. Trump is slated to give his convention speech on Thursday from the White House South Lawn, followed by fireworks at the nearby Washington Monument on Park Service property. Those plans come on the heels of an NPS video publicly praising the president for his involvement in legislation providing more funding to parks. The two instances are leading to allegations that federal employees are engaging in political activity while at work -- a violation of the Hatch Act." --s
Yes, Donald Trump Can Go Lower. Tax Axelrod of the Hill: "President Trump is calling for drug tests to be administered before the first presidential debate between him and Democratic nominee Joe Biden next month. Trump made the demand in an Oval Office interview with The Washington Examiner Wednesday, saying he noted a sudden improvement in Biden's primary debate performance against Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) in March. He offered no evidence to support his suggestion that the improvement could have been the result of a drug.... The president said he was going solely based off of his own observations and not any inside knowledge into Biden's campaign. 'All I can tell you is that I'm pretty good at this stuff,' he said." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Mrs. McCrabbie: Remember the Taco Bowl! When considering Trump's "message" in pardoning a Black felon and in attending a naturalization ceremony for people of color at the White House yesterday, then playing back video of these events at the convention last night, we should bear in mind Trump's infamous May 2016 tweet in which he is pictured sticking a fork in a Trump Tower Grill taco bowl and declaring "I love Hispanics!" These White House events are not efforts to "soften" his image, as most in the media have asserted. Trump is a cruel person, and all of these "gestures" are, to put it as delicately as possible, mind-fucking exercises. He knows you know he is a racist xenophobe, and his intention is to mess with you.
Jonathan Easley of the Hill: "One of the GOP founders of the anti-Trump group The Lincoln Project said Wednesday that polls undercount the level of support that exists for President Trump. 'It is historically difficult to defeat an incumbent president, No. 1,' Steve Schmidt, a former adviser to Sen.& John McCain (R-Ariz.), told Andrea Mitchell on MSNBC. 'I suspect there is at least a point or two of undercount for Trump voters.'... [Joe] Biden has smaller leads in most of the six core battleground states, although recent surveys have found the race is tightening." --s
Julian Barnes of the New York Times: "Mail-in voting for the November presidential election is safe from foreign intervention, intelligence and election security officials said on Wednesday, saying that standard security measures and decentralization make the United States' election system extremely difficult for a foreign power to penetrate and change the results. The assessment contradicts President Trump's attacks on mail-in voting and comments by Attorney General William P. Barr that have also sowed doubt about its security.... 'You guys like to talk about Russia and China and other places,' Mr. Trump said in July. 'They'll be able to forge ballots. They'll forge them. They'll do whatever they have to do.'... Mr. Barr ... told NPR News in June that he did not think an election conducted by mail-in vote could be secure. Mr. Barr told lawmakers in July that ... mail-in voting increased the risk of fraud. And he defended Mr. Trump's claim that foreign governments could print fake mail-in ballots, saying that 'it is not disinformation.' The United States ... has no intelligence that any nation-state is making a coordinated attempt to undermine absentee voting or create fake mail-in ballots, a senior official from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence said."
Black Lives Matter, Ctd.
Here are the New York Times live updates of the police shooting of Jacob Blake and of the Trump supporter's killing of two protesters in Kenosha, Wisconsin: "Wisconsin's attorney general Josh Kaul on Wednesday identified the white police officer who shot Jacob Blake, a Black man, multiple times in Kenosha, Wis., as Rusten Sheskey, a seven-year veteran of the city's police force."
Julie Bosman of the New York Times: "An Illinois resident has been arrested in connection to a shooting that left two people dead and another person wounded during a chaotic night of demonstrations over the shooting of Jacob Blake in Kenosha, Wis., officials said on Wednesday. A court document from Lake County, Ill., shows that Kyle Rittenhouse, 17, was arrested in Antioch, Ill., on Wednesday morning after being charged with first degree intentional homicide in the fatal shooting that took place only hours earlier. Antioch is about 30 minutes southwest of Kenosha, just over the Illinois line." This is an update of a story linked yesterday. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
** Ellie Hall, et al., of BuzzFeed News: "The law enforcement-obsessed 17-year-old who was charged with shooting and killing two people and injuring another in Kenosha, Wisconsin, during protests for Jacob Blake appeared in the front row at a Donald Trump rally in January. Kyle Howard Rittenhouse's social media presence is filled with him posing with weapons, posting 'Blue Lives Matter,' and supporting Trump for president. Footage from the Des Moines, Iowa, rally on Jan. 30 shows Rittenhouse feet away from the president, in the front row, to the left of the podium. He posted a TikTok video from the event." Read on. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: If you wove this detail into a work of fiction, you (or your editor) would take it out as too trite.
Travis Gettys of the Raw Story, citing a tweet by Shannon Watts: "'Cell phone footage shows Kenosha police telling armed insurrectionists, 'We appreciate you guys. We really do,' and giving them bottles of water. Shortly after this video was taken, one of these men shot and killed two protesters and wounded another.' Another video shows Rittenhouse open fire with a rifle after he fell to the ground and then calmly walk toward police vehicles with his hands raised in surrender. Other people can be heard yelling that he had shot someone. However, no officers are seen getting out of the vehicles, which continue advancing toward protesters, to apprehend Rittenhouse -- who then fled the state and was considered a fugitive." Mrs. McC: An eyewitness told Anderson Cooper on CNN Wednesday that he saw the shooter talking to police, who were in their vehicle, and he heard a cop tell the shooter to clear away from the area. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Time to Fire the Kenosha Police Chief. Jeremy Stahl of Slate: "During the Kenosha Police Department's first press conference in response to the Blake shooting and subsequent protests, Chief Daniel Miskinis blamed the unidentified victims in Tuesday night';s shooting for their own deaths, saying the violence was the result of the 'persons; involved violating curfew[.]... 'It is the persons who were involved after the legal time, involved in illegal activity, that brought violence to this community,' Miskinis [said].... In describing the shooting of two protesters, Miskinis also declined to call it a homicide and instead referred to it by various euphemisms often used to describe killings by a police officer, which [Kyle] Rittenhouse is not. He said that the shooter 'was involved in the use of firearms to resolve whatever conflict was in place' and that there was a 'disturbance that led to the use of deadly force.' Additionally, Miskinis refused to comment on the video of [Jacob] Blake's shooting, but offered that there may have been a reasonable explanation for the man being shot seven times.... When asked about the vigilante groups, Miskinis defended them as civilians out to protect property and 'exercise their constitutional right.'"
Marc Stein of the New York Times: "The Milwaukee Bucks responded to the police shooting of Jacob Blake, a Black man in Wisconsin, by refusing to take the court Wednesday afternoon for their N.B.A. playoff game against the Orlando Magic. An hour later, the N.B.A. postponed two other playoff games scheduled for Wednesday night, thrusting its ambitious restart at Walt Disney World during the coronavirus pandemic into sudden chaos and doubt. The postponed games were first-round playoff matchups pitting the Houston Rockets against the Oklahoma City Thunder, and the Los Angeles Lakers against the Portland Trail Blazers. All three games will be rescheduled. Players from the N.B.A. and the W.N.B.A. have long been at the forefront of protests against racism and police brutality but especially this year, after the police killings of George Floyd, a Black man in Minnesota, and Breonna Taylor, a Black woman in Kentucky. Still, the boycott was an extraordinary escalation in the athletes' demonstrations, a move that had virtually no precedent in the league's history." A Deadline story is here. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ~~~
~~~ Carla Russo of the Huffington Post: "Several Major League Baseball teams postponed their games on Wednesday in an apparent show of protest against the police shooting of Jacob Blake, a Black man, in Kenosha, Wisconsin. The Milwaukee Brewers and the Cincinnati Reds were the first MLB teams to postpone their game, multiple sources reported. They made their decision not long after the NBA's Milwaukee Bucks staged a walkout during a playoff game against the Orlando Magic, also on Wednesday. Later Wednesday, the Seattle Mariners and San Diego Padres decided to postpone their Wednesday game as well, according to multiple reports." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
~~~ Scott Lemieux in LG&$: "Critically, the Reds decided to join the strike rather than undermine it by accepting a forfeit. This is a big deal.... I dunno, making a lifelong champion of arbitrary violence against Black people president of the United States seems like a bad idea in retrospect." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Russell Brandom of the Verge: "In the wake of an apparent double murder Tuesday night in Kenosha, Facebook has faced a wave of scrutiny over posts by a self-proclaimed militia group called Kenosha Guard, which issued a 'call to arms' to in advance of the protest. Facebook took down Kenosha Guard's Facebook page Wednesday morning, identifying the posts as violating community standards. But while the accounts were ultimately removed, new evidence suggests the platform had ample warning about the account before the shooting brought the group to prominence. At least two separate Facebook users reported the account for inciting violence prior to the shooting.... In each case, the group and its counter-protest event were examined by Facebook moderators and found not to be in violation of the platform's policies."
Minnesota. Michael Levenson of the New York Times: "A Black man who was wanted in a homicide fatally shot himself as the police closed in on a downtown Minneapolis street on Wednesday evening, prompting a fresh round of protests and looting, the authorities said, three months after the killing of George Floyd in the city set off global demonstrations against police violence. Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota said the State Patrol was headed to the city to help restore order, and that he had deployed the National Guard. Mayor Jacob Frey of Minneapolis said he had ordered an immediate curfew.... Wednesday evening, the police released video of the man shooting himself, saying it was important to quell rumors that he had been killed by the police."
The Trumpidemic, Ctd.
Fred Imbert of CNBC: "The number of Americans who filed for unemployment benefits for the first time came in above 1 million for a second consecutive week as the economy tries to recover from the coronavirus pandemic, the Labor Department said Thursday.... Last week marked the 22nd time in 23 weeks that initial claims were above 1 million."
The New York Times' live updates of coronavirus developments Thursday are here: "Over the past six months, about 1.5 billion children around the world have been told to stay home from school to help minimize transmission of the coronavirus. More than 30 percent of these students -- around 463 million -- were unable to gain access to remote learning opportunities when their schools closed, according to a report on Wednesday by Unicef, the United Nations agency for children.... Henrietta Fore, the executive director of Unicef, said in a statement. 'The repercussions could be felt in economies and societies for decades to come.'"
The Washington Post's live updates of coronavirus developments Wednesday are here. The New York Times live updates Wednesday are here: "The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was instructed by higher-ups in the Trump administration to modify its coronavirus testing guidelines this week to exclude people who do not have symptoms of Covid-19 -- even if they have been recently exposed to the virus, according to two federal health officials. One official said ... the guidelines were not written by the C.D.C. but were imposed." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ~~~
~~~ Nick Valencia, et al., of CNN: "A sudden change in federal guidelines on coronavirus testing came this week as a result of pressure from the upper ranks of the Trump administration, a federal health official close to the process tells CNN. 'It's coming from the top down,' the official said of the new directive from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The new guidelines raise the bar on who should get tested, advising that some people without symptoms probably don't need it -- even if they've been in close contact with an infected person. Previously, the CDC said viral testing was appropriate for people with recent or suspected exposure, even if they were asymptomatic.... A CDC spokesperson referred all questions to the Department of Health and Human Services.... The new directive also lines up with a trend in policy and rhetoric from the White House.... Donald Trump has repeatedly suggested the US should do less testing." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ~~~
~~~ Amy Goldstein & Lena Sun of the Washington Post: "An abrupt shift this week in government testing guidelines for Americans exposed to the novel coronavirus was directed by the White House's coronavirus task force, alarming outside public health experts who warn the change could hasten the disease's spread. The new guidance, introduced this week without any announcement on the website of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, replaces advice that everyone who has been in close contact with an infected person should get tested to find out whether they had caught the virus. Instead, it says that those without symptoms 'do not necessarily need a test.' Several leading infectious-disease experts predicted that, after months of public health exhortations encouraging people to get tested, the turnaround could heighten public confusion, impede contact tracing and lead to more cases. The CDC estimates that 40 percent of those who test positive for the coronavirus have no symptoms but may be highly infectious and spread it to other people.... On Wednesday, Brett Giroir, an assistant HHS secretary who oversees testing, denied the impetus for the shift came from the White House. He said the idea of altering the testing guidance originated with him and CDC Director Robert Redfield, based on concerns that people can have negative results if the test is given too early." ~~~
~~~ Then, this: "On a conference call with reporters, Giroir said they discussed the idea with all the physicians on the White House's coronavirus task force, including Anthony S. Fauci ... and Scott Atlas, a new member influential with Trump from his appearances on Fox News who is a fellow at Stanford University's conservative Hoover Institution. Atlas has said fewer people need tests for the virus, which has led to more than 5.7 million cases in the United States and at least 175,000 deaths. He is not an infectious-disease specialist. 'All the docs signed off on this ... before it got to a place where the political leadership would have ever seen it,' Giroir said." Emphasis added.
~~~ Really, Brett? Jeremy Diamond, et al., of CNN: "White House Coronavirus Task Force member Dr. Anthony Fauci said he was undergoing surgery and not in the August 20 task force meeting for the discussion on updated US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines that suggest asymptomatic people may not need to be tested for Covid-19, even if they've been in close contact with an infected person. 'I was under general anesthesia in the operating room and was not part of any discussion or deliberation regarding the new testing recommendations' at that meeting, Fauci told ... Dr. Sanjay Gupta. 'I am concerned about the interpretation of these recommendations and worried it will give people the incorrect assumption that asymptomatic spread is not of great concern. In fact it is,' said Fauci.... Fauci's comments undercut claims by Adm. Brett Giroir.... Asked whether Fauci signed off on the guidelines, Giroir said, 'Yes, all the docs signed off on this before it even got to the task force level.' 'We worked on this all together to make sure that there was absolute consensus that reflected the best possible evidence, and the best public health for the American people,' Giroir also said earlier in the call...." ~~~
~~~ Conspiracy Theory Alert. Mrs. McCrabbie: The change in the guidelines sounds like it was organized by a conspiracy of task members to sabotage the guidelines in response to Trump's "asks" to reduce testing in order to keep the number of cases down. On August 20, Bill Chappell of NPR reported, "Dr. Anthony Fauci underwent surgery to remove a polyp from one of his vocal cords Thursday, according to the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, the agency Fauci has led for decades." This wasn't a scoop; Fauci's surgery was widely reported. Moreover, it's the type of surgery for which a patient makes an appointment. In one story I read, Fauci said he had been trying for a while to find a time to schedule the surgery. So you can bet people on the task force were forewarned Fauci would be unavailable on August 20, the day of their task force meeting. Scott Atlas, called the "anti-Fauci" in this headline, had joined the task force just ten days earlier. I know it seems unlikely that Trump could plan anything ten days in advance, but mike pence runs the task force, and mikey can plan. ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: By the way, Admiral Giroir isn't a "real" admiral who might have commanded a ship sailing the high seas or at least held a Pentagon post. Rather, Trump appointed him as a direct-commission officer with the rank of admiral in the U.S. Public Health Service Commissioned Corps, which has no enlisted ranks & reports to the Department of Health & Human Services.
Quoctrung Bui, et al., of the New York Times: "On March 15, as the novel coronavirus was beginning to surge in the United States, Dr. Anthony S. Fauci accomplished a rare Washington feat: He appeared on all five major Sunday talk shows. But the White House worried that Dr. Fauci might upstage (and sometimes contradict) President Trump, and soon his media handlers were no longer approving his high-profile interview requests. So Dr. Fauci found another way to get his message out: He said yes to pretty much every small offer that came his way: academic webinars, Instagram feeds and niche science podcasts, as well as a few celebrity interviews. That's how Dr. Fauci, the country's leading infectious disease scientist, found himself talking to the American Urological Association in June; the Economic Club of Chicago in July; and the 'Brazda Breakfast' briefing this month." Mrs. McC: I once heard a rabbi say, "Absent evil, there are no heroes." Covid-19 has given us many heroes, most of them unsung. There's a good chance you're one yourself.
Caitlin O'Kane of CBS News: "The annual Sturgis Motorcycle Rally in South Dakota drew hundreds of thousands of bikers to the small town earlier this month -- despite coronavirus concerns. Now, about three weeks after the rally kicked off, the repercussions are starting to become clear. More than 100 cases of COVID-19 connected to the rally have been reported in at least eight states, the Associated Press reports."
Another Gross Failure of Leadership. Tessa Stuart of Rolling Stone: "The National Hurricane Center has warned [Hurricane Laura] could bring with it an 'unsurvivable' surge -- waves up to 20 feet high that may cause 'catastrophic' damage up to 30 miles inland.... If those predictions bear out, Laura could be one of the most destructive Gulf hurricanes on record. It's particularly bad timing considering that, less than three weeks ago, instead of working with Congress to craft comprehensive legislation to address the ongoing crisis and deliver desperately-needed aid, President Trump looted FEMA's Disaster Relief Fund to the tune of $44 billion -- authorizing the agency to pay for a $300 per week supplement to regular unemployment benefits.... [In other words] because the Senate won't sign off on the House bill and Trump didn't work with lawmakers to reach a compromise, the unemployment supplement isn't coming from money appropriated by Congress. It's coming from the government account meant to cover natural disasters like the one presently bearing down on Mississippi, Louisiana and Texas." --s ~~~
~~~ Dana Milbank of the Washington Post: "Just before the election in 2012, Donald Trump scolded President Barack Obama for campaigning while victims of Hurricane Sandy were still reeling. 'Yesterday Obama campaigned with JayZ & Springsteen while Hurricane Sandy victims across NY & NJ are still decimated by Sandy. Wrong!' Trump tweeted eight days after the storm struck. Actually..., both Obama and Mitt Romney had suspended their campaigns for a while -- and now his old criticism of Obama makes Trump look ridiculous. On Wednesday, Hurricane Laura approached the Gulf Coast of Louisiana and Texas with a storm surge that the National Hurricane Center called 'unsurvivable' and 'catastrophic.' But Trump decreed that the show would go on.... Just two weeks earlier he signed an executive order stripping the Federal Emergency Management Agency of up to $44 billion from its Disaster Relief Fund. Before that, he did everything in his power to dismantle efforts to ameliorate climate change, which is fueling higher-intensity storms. It's another timely reminder that Trump is a man without a plan."
CPB Suggested Microwaving Asylum-Seekers. Michael Shear of the New York Times: "Fifteen days before the 2018 midterm elections, as President Trump sought to motivate Republicans with dark warnings about caravans heading to the U.S. border, he gathered his Homeland Security secretary and White House staff to deliver a message: 'extreme action' was needed to stop the migrants.... At a meeting with top leaders of the Department of Homeland Security, Customs and Border Protection officials suggested deploying a microwave weapon -- a 'heat-ray' designed by the military to make people's skin feel like it is burning when they get within range of its invisible beams. Developed by the military as a crowd dispersal tool two decades ago, the Active Denial System had been largely abandoned amid doubts over its effectiveness and morality. Two former officials who attended the afternoon meeting ..., said the suggestion that the device be installed at the border shocked attendees, even if it would have satisfied the president. Kirstjen Nielsen, then the secretary of Homeland Security told an aide after the meeting that she would not authorize the use of such a device, and it should never be brought up again in her presence, the officials said." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Beyond the Beltway
Missouri. Morgan Gstalter of the Hill: "The GOP-controlled Missouri House on Tuesday advanced a bill that would make it legal to give guns to children without their parents' permission. The bill comes after Gov. Mike Parson (R) called lawmakers back for a special summer session on crime and asked the legislature to penalize criminals who unlawfully use firearms, then pass them off on children to avoid detection. The legislation is the exact opposite of what Parson called for, according to The Associated Press." --s
News Ledes
New York Times: “Hurricane Laura pounded the Louisiana and Texas coasts as it made landfall near Cameron, La., as a Category 4 storm early Thursday, delivering a barrage of 150-mile-an-hour winds and a surge of water that was predicted to reach as high as 20 feet. The National Hurricane Center called the expected storm surge 'unsurvivable,' and said that it could push as far as 40 miles inland. Officials also said that low-lying areas facing the brunt of the storm, like Cameron Parish in Louisiana, would essentially be annexed by the Gulf of Mexico until floods receded. Landfall came after officials in both states issued the gravest of warnings, sounding the alarm about a storm that could be one of the worst to hit the region in decades." This is a live-update report. Access to the WashPo's live updates is free. ~~~
~~~ The AP's live updates of Hurricane Laura news are here. The Weather Channel's main report is here.