The Commentariat -- January 29, 2018
It's kind of amazing that, with the plethora of news items on offer here in RC World, there are relatively few comments. I look forward every day to the ideas you all put forward. -- Akhilleus, at the end of Saturday's thread.
Ditto. Commenting on Reality Chex couldn't be easier. You can assume almost any pseudonym you like. I do suggest you keep a copy of your comment until it is published. To assure your comment has been published, just refresh the page; the comment should come up right away. The only rules are that (1) you don't attack other commenters -- disagree with their ideas, not with their characters or intelligence -- (2) you don't advocate ideas that shock the conscience, and (3) (which seems to be a difficult one) your comments stick to politics. -- Mrs. Bea McCrabbie ...
... P.S. re: Rule 1: Insulting or attacking me, Mrs. Bea McCrabbie, will not go well, as yesterday's thread attests.
Afternoon Update:
Adam Goldman & Matt Apuzzo of the New York Times: "Andrew G. McCabe has stepped down as the F.B.I.;s deputy director, a move that was widely expected as he has repeatedly come under fire from Republicans in Congress and from President Trump. Mr. McCabe made his intentions known to colleagues on Monday, an American official said. He will immediately go on leave and plans to retire when he becomes eligible in mid-March." Mrs. McC: Well, the Von Trump Family Shitslingers can dance around the campfire tonight carrying McCabe's head on the end of stake. They're such WINNERS! Uh, wait. The next story seems to present a problem. ...
... Susan Glasser of Politico Magazine: "Congress late last year received 'extraordinarily important new documents' in its investigation of ... Donald Trump and his campaign's possible collusion with the 2016 Russian election hacking, opening up significant new lines of inquiry in the Senate Intelligence Committee's probe of the president, Sen. Mark Warner (D-Va.) says in an exclusive new interview.... Warner calls out [Rep. Devin] Nunes [R-Calif.], the chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, in arguably more explicit terms than any Democrat has yet, saying he has read the underlying classified material used in the memo and that Nunes misrepresented it as part of a McCarthyite 'secret Star Chamber' effort to discredit the FBI probe of the president.... Warner offers a provocative rationale for why it is we are now seeing such a stepped-up campaign by Trump and his defenders against those who seek to provide us the answers. 'Mueller is getting closer and closer to the truth,' Warner tells me, and 'closer and closer to the truth is getting closer and closer to the president.'... The spectacle on Capitol Hill is sure to continue." ...
... Another Time Trump Lost It. Jennifer Jacobs of Bloomberg: "... Donald Trump's frustrations with the Russia investigation boiled over on Air Force One last week when he learned that a top Justice Department official had warned against releasing a memo that could undercut the probe, according to four people with knowledge of the matter. Trump erupted in anger while traveling to Davos after learning that Associate Attorney General Stephen Boyd warned that it would be 'extraordinarily reckless' to release a classified memo written by House Republican staffers.... For Trump, the letter was yet another example of the Justice Department undermining him and stymieing Republican efforts to expose what the president sees as the politically motivated agenda behind Special Counsel Robert Mueller's probe. Trump's outburst capped a week where Trump and senior White House officials personally reproached Attorney General Jeff Sessions and asked White House Chief of Staff John Kelly to speak to others -- episodes that illustrate Trump’s preoccupation with the Justice Department."
Another One Bites the Dust. Dave Weigel of the Washington Post: "Rep. Rodney Frelinghuysen (R-N.J.), the chairman of the House Appropriations Committee, will retire from Congress at the end of this term, giving a boost to Democratic hopes of winning back the House of Representatives with wins in fast-changing suburbs.... Frelinghuysen, first elected in 1994, represents suburbs and exurbs of New York City that had long voted solidly Republican.... Donald Trump won just 48.8 percent of the vote in Frelinghuysen's 11th Congressional District. Democrats piled into the 2018 campaign, with Mikie Sherrill, a Navy veteran and federal prosecutor, garnering the most attention and largely clearing the field."
Eric Levitz of New York: Rep. Beto O'Rourke (D-Texas), who is challenging Sen. Ted Cruz in 2018, outraised Cruz over the last three months. O'Rourke has not taken money from corporate superPACS. Cruz will probably win -- because Texas. But Levitz has written a fine remembrance of just in case:
Ted Cruz is living proof that the invention of high-school debate was a world-historic error on par with the Manhattan Project. He is a seething mass of smug self-regard; a 'populist' who, whilst at law school, refused to study with anyone who hadn't gotten their bachelor's degree at Harvard, Princeton, or Yale; an anti-Establishment gadfly who tried desperately to win a spot in George W. Bush's inner circle; a one-time #NeverTrump conservative who spent much of the past year licking the president's boots; and (almost certainly) a serial killer with a taste for cryptography....
*****
Jeet Heer of the New Republic (Jan. 26) on the "paranoid style in American politics." Now, as it did in the era of Joe McCarthy, that paranoid style begins at the top & has quite a few prominent adherents. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... ** Speaking of Sinister Plots. Jonathan Chait: "It is possible that the deafening drumbeat of charges in the GOP-controlled media about alleged liberal bias in the Justice Department and the FBI is only designed to prepare the base to disregard evidence of President Trump's culpability in the Russia scandal.... It seems much more likely now that the conspiracy theories and charges serve a different purpose: to give Trump cover to shut down Robert Mueller's probe and remake the Justice Department into an organ of his personal protection. Several new reports have clarified the president's disturbing intent.... So, why hasn't Trump acted yet? Reports have also answered this question: because his lawyers keep stopping him.... The question is how long this unstable equilibrium will last.... Attorney General Jeff Sessions, who recused himself because he was a key member of the campaign that was being investigated, and who also lied about his interactions with Russians, has selectively un-recused himself." (Also, Trump, not usually known for his subtlety, has found an odd euphemism for reminding fans that Rosenstein is an untrustworthy Jew. Disgusting.) Mrs. McC: Color me paranoid. Chait's evidence, especially two stories we've previously linked, is convincing. ...
... Jonathan Swan of Axios: "I can't overstate the level of anxiety among sources close to Trump after the president told the NYT's Maggie Haberman last week he was willing and eager to submit himself to a live interview under oath with Special Counsel Robert Mueller.... One source, who knows Trump as well as anyone, told me he believes the president would be incapable of avoiding perjuring himself. ]Trump doesn't deal in reality,' the source said. 'He creates his own reality and he actually believes it.'"
... Nicholas Fandos, et al., of the New York Times: "A secret, highly contentious Republican memo reveals that Deputy Attorney General Rod J. Rosenstein approved an application to extend surveillance of a former Trump campaign associate shortly after taking office last spring, according to three people familiar with it. The renewal shows that the Justice Department under President Trump saw reason to believe that the associate, Carter Page, was acting as a Russian agent. But the reference to Mr. Rosenstein's actions in the memo -- a much-disputed document that paints the investigation into Russian election meddling as tainted from the start -- indicates that Republicans may be moving to seize on his role as they seek to undermine the inquiry.... No information has publicly emerged that the Justice Department or the F.B.I. did anything improper while seeking the surveillance warrant involving Mr. Page.... Mr. Trump considered firing Mr. Rosenstein last summer." ...
... MEANWHILE. Sheryl Stolberg & Nicholas Fandos of the New York Times: "Republican lawmakers warned President Trump on Sunday not to fire Robert S. Mueller III, but showed little sense of urgency to advance long-stalled legislation to protect the special counsel despite a report that Mr. Trump had tried to remove him last June. 'I don't think there's a need for legislation right now to protect Mueller,' Representative Kevin McCarthy of California, the House majority leader, said Sunday on NBC's 'Meet the Press.' 'Right now there's not an issue. So why create one when there isn't a place for it?'" ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: Right. Not an issue. Because Trump already has ordered the White House counsel to fire Mueller. So he would never do so again. ...
Ken Starr Thinks Trump Likely Should Be Impeached. Lois Beckett of the Guardian: 'If Donald Trump lied to the American people when he called reports he tried to fire Robert Mueller 'fake news', that would be grounds for impeachment, the independent counsel who investigated the Clinton White House said on Sunday. Ken Starr, who used Bill Clinton's false statements about his relationship with Monica Lewinsky as grounds for impeachment, told ABC's This Week: 'Lying to the American people is a serious issue that has to be explored. I take lying to the American people very, very seriously, so absolutely.' Starr said: 'That is something Bob Mueller should look at.'" ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: Of course the "fake news" shout-out was not the only time Trump lied to the public about firing Bob Mueller if the NYT is correct. According the the Times, Trump ordered Mueller's firing in June 2017. In August 2017, when asked by a reporter if he'd ever considered firing Mueller, Trump replied, "I haven't given it any thought." Worth noting also, as David Leonhardt does below, that an article of impeachment against Nixon is worded, "... made false or misleading public statements for the purpose of deceiving the people of the United States." ...
... David Leonhardt of the New York Times comes up with a list of Trump's publicly-known bad acts that should warrant an article of impeachment for obstruction of justice. Trump is unlikely to face impeachment anytime soon, or perhaps anytime at all. But it's time for all of us -- voters, members of Congress, Trump's own staff -- to be honest about what he's done. He has obstructed justice. He may not be finished doing so, either." ...
... "American Hustler." Franklin Foer, in the Atlantic, pores through years of e-mails written by Paul Manafort's daughters. "When Paul Manafort officially joined the Trump campaign, on March 28, 2016, he represented a danger not only to himself but to the political organization he would ultimately run. A lifetime of foreign adventures didn't just contain scandalous stories, it evinced the character of a man who would very likely commandeer the campaign to serve his own interests, with little concern for the collective consequences." A long piece. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Donald Trump, Climate Scientist. Benjamin Hart of New York: "President Trump has a long history of mind-bogglingly foolish statements about climate change, the most notorious of which is probably his 2012 Twitter declaration that the phenomenon is merely a Chinese hoax. On Sunday, he added another whopper to his least-greatest hits collection. Speaking to kindred spirit Piers Morgan on the British network ITV, Trump said that, despite what you may have heard, the polar ice caps are actually thriving. 'The ice caps were going to melt, they were going to be gone by now, but now they're setting records,' he said.... [And he's been saying (& tweeting) it for years.] The president also told Morgan, sagely: 'Look, it used to not be climate change, it used to be global warming. That wasn't working too well because it was getting too cold all over the place.'" Mrs. McC: The worst part: he believes this. ...
... In case Daffy Duck wrote your science book, too, here's the Chicago Tribune's fact-check.
These next two stories are one atop the other in the Guardian:
Martin Farrer: "A round-up of some of the more eyebrow-raising statements in the US president's interview with Piers Morgan [begins with,] 'I think I'm very popular in your country.' Morgan interjects: 'Let's not be too hasty Mr President.' Trump continued: 'I know but I believe that, I really do. I get so much fan mail from people in your country. They love my sense of security, they love what I'm saying about many different things. 'We get tremendous support from people in the UK.'"
Nicola Swanson: "Protesters are readying themselves for the 'most incredible protest in our history' to coincide with Donald Trump's planned visit during the second half of the year. After a meeting between Theresa May and Trump at the World Economic Forum in Davos, it was confirmed that the US president would visit 'later this year'. A Facebook event set up to organise a large-scale protest already boasts of 20,000 attendees and a further 61,000 who are interested in attending."
Justin Bank of the New York Times: "President Trump bragged about lowering the black unemployment rate in a tweet directed at Jay-Z on Sunday morning. The message was seemingly a response to comments the hip-hop artist and businessman made during an interview with CNN on Saturday night.... Mr. Trump is right. Black unemployment in the United States reached its lowest level in December. But, as my colleague Linda Qiu reported two weeks ago, the record is the culmination of a longer trend, and there has been no shift in the larger racial unemployment gap[.]... Further, it's an open question whether a president can claim credit for economic outputs like unemployment." ...
... Mrs. McC: A friend sent me a thoughtful gift last week. Thanks, Trump! My neighbor has been ill, but she's feeling better. Thanks, Trump! The ice on my driveway from last week's icestorm finally melted. Thanks, Trump!
Preet Bharara & Christine Todd Whitman, in a USA Today op-ed: "One year into the Trump presidency, it's clear that the norms and boundaries traditionally guiding American political behavior have deeply eroded. That matters greatly. A workable democracy can thrive only when there are basic rules, often unwritten, that curb abuse and guide policymakers.... Now is the time to ensure the president and all our public officials adhere to basic rules of the road. It's time to turn soft norms into hard law. So far, President Trump has refused to divorce himself from his business interests, despite decades of tradition. He has repeatedly tried to influence federal criminal investigations. Policymaking processes have become haphazard. And we now see worrisome attacks on the independent press. All this shows just how easily a chief executive can ignore the unwritten rules that typically constrain presidents. We see similar erosion elsewhere in government, too. For example, a major tax bill, affecting the whole economy, enacted with no committee hearings.... Today, we're launching an independent democracy task force at the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University's School of Law to holistically review these informal rules, which ones should remain guidelines, and perhaps which ones should be enshrined into law."
** Julian Zelizer of the Atlantic: "Trump has proven to be a reflection of the nation's darkest political traditions.... Viewing the aggressive and socially divisive elements of President Trump's conservative populism as a deviation from the enlightened path of the nation romanticizes the American political tradition as being purely about cherished values such as liberty, freedom, equality, opportunity, representation, free markets, and justice. This view of America whitewashes away huge swaths of U.S. history in order to perpetuate the myth that at its essence America is a shining city on the hill." Thanks to PD Pepe for the link.
Stars auditioned for a Grammy for their Fire & Fury readings. Watch to the end:
"This Land Is Your Land." Guardian: "Amid dangers from the Trump administration and climate change, sites including the Grand Canyon and Zion national park are facing yet another threat: 'massive disrepair'[.]... A huge funding shortfall [for the U.S. National Park System] means that the strain ... is showing Trails are crumbling and buildings are rotting. In all there is an $11bn backlog of maintenance work that repair crews have been unable to perform, a number that has mostly increased every year in the past decade.... National parks are just one part of an unparalleled system, managed by the government and held in trust for the public, and spanning over 600m acres of forests, deserts, tundra and glacier-covered peaks, as well as historical sites such as the Lincoln Memorial and Washington Monument. They are integral to American life: an ancestral home for Native Americans; a retreat for vacationers, sportspeople and hunters; a source of grazing; and an economic engine. Yet their future is uncertain. Earlier this month 10 members of a National Park Service advisory board ... quit en masse, complaining that the new administration was unwilling to meet with them and was not prioritizing the parks.... Meanwhile advocates have raised concerns that the Department of Interior, which oversees many federal lands, is staffed with lobbyists for the energy industry. Even absent such issues, climate change, privatization and energy extraction risk changing the face of the country's public spaces forever."
Loveday Morris, et al., of the Washington Post: "The Trump administration's recent decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel's capital and the subsequent visit of the evangelical vice president [mike pence] to Israel mark the culmination of a long, complicated and sometimes uneasy alliance between Israeli leaders and Christian evangelicals that dates back to before the establishment of the state. But the high-water mark, ironically, comes just as younger American evangelicals are growing less attached to Israel. Recent polls have sparked anxiety among Israeli officials and Christian Zionist groups, which are trying to reverse the decline.... In the eyes of most Palestinians, however, the influence of evangelicalism on the White House has been disastrous for their relations with the United States.Saeb Erekat, the Palestinians' chief negotiator, slammed the 'messianic discourse' of Pence during his visit.... Many Jews, for their part, have long viewed the missionary work of evangelicals and their messianic, prophetic beliefs with suspicion." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: This worries me, not because I think the "messianic discourse" is a positive, but because I worry that anti-Semitism will become more powerful. It already is a driving force in the alt-right, of course. (And Trump seems to have caught the bug. See Rosenstein, Rod, above.)
Alex Hern of the Guardian: "Sensitive information about the location and staffing of military bases and spy outposts around the world has been revealed by a fitness tracking company. The details were released by Strava in a data visualisation map that shows all the activity tracked by users of its app, which allows people to record their exercise and share it with others. The map, released in November 2017, shows every single activity ever uploaded to Strava -- more than 3 trillion individual GPS data points, according to the company. The app can be used on various devices including smartphones and fitness trackers like Fitbit to see popular running routes in major cities, or spot individuals in more remote areas who have unusual exercise patterns. However, over the weekend military analysts noticed that the map is also detailed enough that it potentially gives away extremely sensitive information about a subset of Strava users: military personnel on active service."
A Secret Photo, Revealed. Esme Cribb of TPM (Jan. 25): "A journalist announced last week that he will publish a photograph of then-Illinois Sen. Barack Obama (D) and Nation of Islam leader Louis Farrakhan that he took in 2005 at a Congressional Black Caucus meeting, but did not make public because he believed it would have 'made a difference' to Obama's political future. The photographer, Askia Muhammad, told the Trice Edney News Wire that he 'gave the picture up at the time and basically swore secrecy.' 'But after the nomination was secured and all the way up until the inauguration; then for eight years after he was President, it was kept under cover,' Muhammad said. Asked whether he thought the photo's release would have affected Obama's presidential campaign, Muhammad said, 'I insist. It absolutely would have made a difference.'... TPM has published the photo above with Muhammad's permission." ...
... Vinson Cunningham of the New Yorker: "The latter months of Hillary Clinton's losing 2008 primary campaign were characterized by a Pyrrhically effective, subtly racialized populist appeal to the people she referred to, at one point, as 'hard-working Americans, white Americans,' in states such as Michigan and Ohio. As Clinton chugged beers and downed shots of whiskey at every notch along the Rust Belt, her campaign disseminated photos of Obama looking especially black or exotic, or standing next to figures of questionable repute.... When I saw a recently released photo, by Askia Muhammad, of Obama and a beaming Louis Farrakhan, I immediately thought of the Clinton campaign. What fun they could've had with this one!" ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: AND people chastize me for not being a big Hillary fan. One of a dozen reasons: Barack's so black.
** Cloak & Dagger One Step Ahead of Nixon. Eric Lichtblau in the New Yorker: Daniel "Ellsberg was aided [in his theft & distribution of the Pentagon Papers] by about a half-dozen volunteers whose identities have stayed secret for forty-six years, despite the intense interest of the Nixon Administration, thousands of articles, books, documentaries, plays, and now a major film, 'The Post.'... Ellsberg told me that the hidden role of this group was so critical to the operation that he gave them a code name -- 'The Lavender Hill Mob,' the name of a 1951 film about a ragtag group of amateur bank robbers. He has referred obliquely to his co-conspirators over the years. But he held back from identifying them because some in the group still feared repercussions. Now, [some of Ellsberg's team have] agreed to be revealed for the first time.... Several other members of the group told me that they still wished to remain anonymous, or declined interview requests."
Way Beyond the Beltway