The Commentariat -- July 26, 2016
Democratic National Convention & Presidential Race
See also yesterday's Afternoon Update.
Dan Roberts & Sabrina Siddiqui of the Guardian: "A stormy opening night of the Democratic convention battered the Philadelphia arena on Monday as defiant Bernie Sanders supporters resisted attempts to persuade them to embrace Hillary Clinton. Impassioned pleas for unity from a trio of Democratic women led by Michelle Obama raised hopes that the tumultuous first day of the convention may provide catharsis. But despite a direct plea for calm from Sanders, many of his 1,846 delegates in the arena repeatedly jeered at mentions of the party's presumptive nominee for the first hour or two of the evening." -- CW
Abby Phillip & Sean Sullivan of the Washington Post: "Bernie Sanders closed out the first day of the Democratic party's convention with a forceful plea for his supporters to get behind ... Hillary Clinton.... Sanders stood, taking in the adulation for several long minutes before launching into what would prove to be a challenging task: finally bringing his supporters into Clinton's fold. 'If you think you can sit it out, take a moment to think about the Supreme Court justices that Donald Trump would nominate and what that would mean to civil liberties, equal rights and the future of our country,' Sanders warned":
... Here's the text of Sanders' speech, as prepared, via Politico. -- CW ...
Paul Kane of the Washington Post: "... as she took the stage in prime time Monday night at the Democratic National Convention for perhaps the most anticipated speech of her career, [Sen. Elizabeth] Warren positioned herself to wield singular power over Democratic politics and the party's policy agenda from her perch in the Senate, no matter who wins the presidency":
Abby Phillip & Sean Sullivan: "First lady Michelle Obama delivered a powerful character witness on behalf of the Democratic Party's nominee, Hillary Clinton, and urged her party to not be complacent":
... CW: Copy that, Melania. ...
... Gail Collins: "O.K., Michelle Obama stole the show. It would be hard to beat an African-American first lady saying that she woke up every morning: 'in a house that was built by slaves. And I watch my daughters, two beautiful, intelligent black young women, playing with their dogs on the White House lawn. And because of Hillary Clinton, my daughters and all our sons and daughters now take for granted that a woman can be president of the United States.' But she went further than that -- further, really, in lambasting the opposition than is traditional for someone in the Official Wife position. And it worked very, very well." (CW: You may want to scroll on down the page; there are several other short takes on the convention, but there is no way to isolate them.) ...
... Rebecca Traister of New York: "... it was not an elected official, but one of the most brilliant and inspiring first ladies in American history, Michelle Obama, who lit up the room, silenced the booing throngs, and opened up a can of elegant whoop-ass on everyone who has been behaving poorly, all without mentioning any offenders by name." -- CW
Brian Beutler: "... by the end of the evening, the disarray story became impossible to credit.... The basic competence, and occasional brilliance, of the stagecraft left no room for anyone other than the most partisan operatives to pretend the two conventions and parties are equally broken.... Clinton's convention lineup wasn't designed to contrast with Trump's brigade of C-list celebrities and agitators, though it did do that. It was instead meant to serve as a demonstration that Clinton is widely respected in the Democratic Party, which is much less divided than a handful of Sanders delegates would have you believe. Where Trump insists to the public that Republicans are unified, Clinton and her supporters showed that they are." -- CW ...
... NEW. Greg Sargent: "What last night really showed is that there will be a profound, fundamental imbalance between the Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump campaigns when it comes to the wattage of surrogates out there making the case this fall.The biggest speeches of the night, from New Jersey Senator Cory Booker, Michelle Obama, Elizabeth Warren, and Bernie Sanders, projected a tone that seemed designed to contrast sharply with the hate-and-rage-fest otherwise known as the GOP convention.... this is also another way in which there is simply no equivalence between the degree of disunity that is afflicting the two parties." -- CW
The New York Times' "live briefing" of the convention is here. ...
... 6 pm ET: "Hundreds of Bernie Sanders supporters drowned out the Vermont senator with boos Monday as he tried to make the case that his fans would need to vote for Hillary Clinton to defeat Donald J. Trump." CW: I'd say they're not Sanders "supporters" if they booed him. More like brats & malcontents.
... Sean Sullivan & Anne Gearan of the Washington Post: "Debbie Wasserman Schultz excused herself from gaveling in the convention, bowing to heavy pressure from party activists. It was one of many dramatic developments during a day of discord that threatened to distract from high-profile speeches meant to convey Democratic unity on the first day of the convention.... The floor of the Democratic National Convention was awash with anti-Hillary Clinton sentiment and sporadic protests as it opened Monday afternoon. Every mention of her name drew boos from Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders's supporters, who toted signs railing against trade pacts and distracting from the speakers on stage. Televisions news cameras and anchors swarmed each uprising, broadcasting it live and furiously tweeting the latest chants. The barrage of activity and Klieg lights only seemed to encourage the rabble rousing, which continued on for more than an hour." -- CW ...
... "Mayhem Breaks Out"! Nick Gass of Politico: "Democrats on Monday struggled to contain the chaos that threatened to take hold in Philadelphia, as Debbie Wasserman Schultz bowed out of plans to gavel in the Democratic National Convention and restless Bernie Sanders' supporters lashed out.... Clinton's campaign insisted Monday that Sanders would 'double down' on his endorsement of Clinton weeks ago in New Hampshire, 'in contrast to Ted Cruz,' who caused an uproar in Cleveland by telling Americans to 'vote your conscience' rather than explicitly endorsing Trump." -- CW ...
... Ruby Kramer of BuzzFeed: "Bernie Sanders' campaign manager repudiated a fledgling grassroots effort by progressive activists at the Democratic National Convention to challenge Sen. Tim Kaine as the party's vice presidential nominee. 'It's very divisive,' said Jeff Weaver, the top strategist.... 'She's the presidential nominee. If Bernie were the nominee, would you want the conservatives trying to nominate our vice president?'" -- CW ...
... Liz Goodwin of Yahoo! News: "Sen. Bernie Sanders sent a text message to the leaders of his delegation pleading with them not to protest on the Democratic convention floor Monday night. 'I ask you as a personal courtesy to me to not engage in any kind of protest on the floor,' he wrote in the text message to his delegate whips. 'Its of utmost importance you explain this to your delegations.'" -- CW ...
... Jonathan Swan of the Hill: "Bernie Sanders supporters should stop calling for Hillary Clinton to be put in prison, Jeff Weaver said Monday ahead of the start of the Democratic National Convention. 'I know emotions are running high right now, but I think people really have to consider the implications of what a [Donald] Trump presidency would mean for those of us who support the kind of agenda that Bernie Sanders has laid out for the country,' Weaver, who served as campaign manager for Sanders's presidential bid, told The Hill.... On Sunday, immediately preceding the opening of the Democratic convention, supporters of the Vermont senator reportedly marched through the streets of Philadelphia, chanting, 'Lock her up.'" -- CW ...
... "Fart-in, Smoke-in and Actual Crowds Come to Philly After Boring RNC Protests." Steven Nelson of US News: "After surprisingly few people took to the streets of Cleveland last week to protest Donald Trump's nomination at the Republican National Convention, this week's Democratic convention will prove activism isn't dead.... The number of participants opposing or seeking to influence Hillary Clinton on Sunday alone -- before the convention began -- easily exceeded the number of protesters targeting Trump in an entire week.... Along for the ride will be at least one -- maybe two -- enormous fan-operated inflatable joints, which cannabis activists led by the D.C. Cannabis Campaign will march south toward the convention center.... Some Sanders delegates will participate in the anti-Clinton 'fart in.'..." CW: Let's feed 'em beans. ...
... Those Protesters (Including Some Delegates) Aren't Democrats. Paul Waldman: "The Democratic Party isn't being torn apart from the inside; it's being attacked from the outside.... For a certain kind of activist on the left, the real enemy is never the right; it's always the liberals who are insufficiently committed to their brand of revolution.... For some of [Sanders'] most ardent followers, joining the Democratic Party was never part of the deal. Many of the ones now protesting are quite open about the fact that their goal is to destroy the party.... This is a real contrast with the conflicts we saw highlighted in Cleveland...." -- CW ...
... Philip Bump of the Washington Post: "Pew asked ... consistent Sanders supporters whom they support in the general election. Ninety percent said they back Hillary Clinton.... Last week, as the Republican convention was going on, Pew offered similar research about the Republicans. Of the 44 percent of the party that never supported Donald Trump, 79 percent were planning on backing him in the general election -- lower than the percentage of Sanders supporters backing Clinton, but still nearly 8 in 10. So why so much outrage in Philadelphia? Delegates to party conventions are not normal members of political parties." -- CW ...
** Why Are Sanders Delegates Such Jerks? Blame the Clinton Establishment. Matt Yglesias of Vox: "Sanders had little control over his delegates.... This was in part a matter of sloppiness on the part of Sanders's team in selecting delegates. But as one operative told me, there was another reason Sanders's delegation was so unruly: Everyone was so afraid to cross Clinton by serving as a Sanders delegate that he couldn't convince the kind of party loyalists who normally take the job to do it.... Many Sanders delegates come from the world of left-wing protest culture rather than party politics." -- CW
Lose the Air Quotes, Donald Donaldovich. Katherine Krueger of TPM: "Donald Trump on Monday attributed the Democratic National Committee hack that led to the ouster of its chair to 'one of our many, many "friends"' in Russia or China.... 'Little did [Wasserman Schultz] know, Russia, China, one of our many, many "friends"' -- Trump emphasized with air quotes -- 'came in and hacked the hell out of us.'" -- CW ...
... ** Thomas Rid in Vice: "The forensic evidence linking the DNC breach to known Russian operations is very strong. On June 20, two competing cybersecurity companies, Mandiant (part of FireEye) and Fidelis, confirmed CrowdStrike's initial findings that Russian intelligence indeed hacked Clinton's campaign.... The larger operation, with its manipulative traits, fits well into the wider framework of Russia's evolving military doctrine, known as New Generation Warfare or the 'Gerasimov Doctrine,' named after Valery Gerasimov, the current Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces.... The operation is not over." -- CW ...
... Shane Harris & Nancy Youssef of the Daily Beast: "The theory that Moscow orchestrated the leaks to help Trump, who has repeatedly praised Russian President Vladimir Putin and practically called for the end of NATO, is fast gaining currency within the Obama administration because of the timing of the leaks and Trump's own connections to the Russian government.... Two U.S. officials told The Daily Beast that while hacking is a crime, and therefore falls under the FBI's jurisdiction, trying to manipulate an election is not. That may limit what the FBI can investigate...." -- CW ...
Dana Houle in the New Republic: "The main problem with the notion that the DNC rigged the results for Clinton is that it requires one to assume the improbable. The DNC had no role or authority in primary contests, which are run by state governments. Clinton dominated the primaries. The DNC, through state parties, had a bit more influence over caucuses ... where Sanders dominated Clinton.... Furthermore, if it is true that last fall Clinton campaign chair John Podesta tried but failed to have DNC Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz sacked, the underlying premise of the entire WikiLeaks dump -- that Wasserman Schultz machinated to deliver Clinton the nomination -- is hard to believe." ...
... Houle identifies the real threat to the party that the Russian DNC hacks signalled: just as "Republican operatives jammed the phone lines of Democratic phone banks in New Hampshire, possibly costing them a seat in the U.S. Senate," so could Drumpovich-leaning hackers mess up "the digital and data infrastructure of the Democratic Party and its allies in organized labor and liberal interest groups." -- CW ...
... CW: Echoing what I wrote yesterday, Paul Waldman writes: "... the fact that Russia is trying to swing the outcome of an American presidential election is about a million times more important than the fact that some DNC staffers talked trash about Bernie Sanders in emails to one another."
Prognostications on the Trumpinproletariat: "How Rousseau Predicted Trump." Pankaj Mishra in the New Yorker: "No Enlightenment thinker observing our current predicament from the afterlife would be able to say 'I told you so' as confidently as Jean-Jacques Rousseau..., who was memorably described by Isaiah Berlin as the 'greatest militant lowbrow in history.' In his major writings, beginning in the seventeen-fifties, Rousseau thrived on his loathing of metropolitan vanity, his distrust of technocrats and of international trade, and his advocacy of traditional mores.... Against today's backdrop of political rage, however, Rousseau seems to have grasped, and embodied, better than anyone the incendiary appeal of victimhood in societies built around the pursuit of wealth and power." -- CW
Annals of "Journalism" & Journalism, Ctd. New York invites media luminaries to critique the media. -- CW
Beyond the Beltway
Patrick Marley of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (July 22): "Gov. Scott Walker on Friday named a little-known Waukesha lawyer with no judicial experience to the state Supreme Court, putting Daniel Kelly on the bench and keeping in place the high court's 5-2 conservative majority. Kelly -- who in his application called affirmative action and slavery the same morally -- will replace retiring Justice David Prosser on Aug. 1, the start of the court's new term. Kelly, 52, initially applied for the appointment in secret, but his name became public in June.... Kelly took just one question from reporters after Walker announced the appointment in the state Capitol, but he declined to discuss his writings opposing affirmative action and gay marriage." -- CW ...
... OR, as Charles Pierce put it, Walker "is hard at work still putting the bananas in his banana republic...." -- CW