The Commentariat -- August 1, 2016
Missy Ryan of the Washington Post: "The United States has conducted airstrikes on the Islamic State stronghold in Sirte, Libya, the Pentagon said on Monday, the first direct U.S. military involvement in Libyan forces' battle against militants there. In a statement, Pentagon press secretary Peter Cook said that Libya's Western-backed unity government had requested air support as forces under its command battle to reclaim the coastal city of Sirte, which has become an Islamic State stronghold since militants seized it last year." -- CW
Michael Wines of the New York Times: "...since the Supreme Court's 5-to-4 ruling in the voting-rights case, Shelby County v. Holder, critics argue, the blatant efforts to keep minorities from voting have been supplanted by a blizzard of more subtle changes. Most conspicuous have been state efforts like voter ID laws or cutbacks in early voting periods, which critics say disproportionately affect minorities and the poor. Less apparent, but often just as contentious, have been numerous voting changes enacted in counties and towns across the South and elsewhere around the country. They appear as Republican legislatures and election officials in the South and elsewhere have imposed statewide restrictions on voting that could depress turnout by minorities and other Democrat-leaning groups in a crucial presidential election year." ...
... CW: Wines couches his report in the "critics say" caveat, the go-to evasion of both-sides "journalism." He goes on to report instance after instance of actual voter suppression. So once again, the New York Times features journalistic malpractice on its front page. ...
... Oh, P.S. Driftglass highlights Chuck Todd's Luminous Contribution to Both-siderism. -- CW
Michael Rosenwald of the Washington Post: "The modern era of mass shootings began [in Austin, Texas,] on a searing summer day in 1966. Just before noon, from high atop the University of Texas Tower, an ex-Marine sharpshooter named Charles Whitman leveled his rifle over the railing ... and fired at will for 20 minutes -- the time it took for students and residents to fetch their own high-powered rifles and shoot back, helping an unprepared and outgunned police force.... On Monday, survivors will attend the unveiling of a memorial on the 50th anniversary of Whitman's rampage, which left 17 dead and more than 30 wounded. That same day, Texas becomes the nation's eighth state to allow students to brings guns onto university campuses and, in some cases, into classrooms and dorms.... Gun rights advocates are delighted." -- CW ...
... Rebecca Onion of Slate: "A graduate class at the University of Texas at Austin has put together a new website about the mass shooting at the [University of Texas].... The result is an intriguing suite of essays, accompanied by archival documents, biographies of the shooting victims, and a timeline of mass shootings." -- CW
Presidential Race
Alicia Parlapiano & Adam Pearce of the New York Times: "... half of the primary voters chose ... candidates [other than Clinton or Trump]. Just 14 percent of eligible adults -- 9 percent of the whole nation -- voted for either Mr. Trump or Mrs. Clinton." -- CW
Steve Coll of the New Yorker: "American Presidential elections reduce the country's complexity to a binary choice. This year's is admittedly not the happiest one. The revival, on the big screens at the Convention hall, of the Clinton family's political 'narrative' was at times exhausting, evocative of Argentina. Still, there can be no doubt that Hillary Clinton is deeply qualified to serve as President, whereas Donald Trump has proved himself a transparently serious threat to the Constitution. Attached to Clinton's candidacy are the futures of Supreme Court jurisprudence, European and Asian security, the health of American pluralism, and the rule of law. 'It truly is up to us,' Clinton observed. The worry is whether, in this hot summer of disequilibrium, her country is adequate to the task." -- CW ...
... Jill LePore of the New Yorker attended both conventions & talked to the people there, including, or especially, the protesters. -- CW
John Wagner of the Washington Post: "Hillary Clinton is heading to heavily Republican Nebraska on Monday in search of a single electoral vote. In a move that suggests the Democratic presidential nominee is taking nothing for granted against Republican Donald Trump, Clinton has scheduled a late afternoon rally in Omaha, a moderate pocket of an otherwise conservative state. Here's why: Nebraska is one of only two states that awards part of its electoral votes based on outcomes in congressional districts.... In 2008, then-Sen. Barack Obama (Ill.) edged out GOP nominee John McCain in the 2nd Congressional District, which includes Omaha, picking up exactly one of the 270 electoral votes needed to secure the presidency." -- CW ...
... Abby Phillip of the Washington Post: "As Hillary Clinton closed out her three-day bus tour with a stop in Columbus, Ohio, she had a dire warning for voters: ..."I don't want folks to be misled, to listen to the rhetoric and the demagoguery. I think Donald Trump poses a serious threat to our democracy, and it's going to be up to all of us to repudiate the hatefulness.'... The comments came at the tail end of her journey through two battleground states -- Ohio and Pennsylvania -- with stops focused on swing or Republican voters. Clinton traveled with her running mate, Sen. Tim Kaine (Va.), and his wife, Anne Holton. Former president Bill Clinton joined the group for several stops on the tour." -- CW
Director Comey said my answers were truthful, and what I've said is consistent with what I have told the American people, that there were decisions discussed and made to classify retroactively certain of the emails. -- Hillary Clinton, interview on "Fox News Sunday," July 31, 2016
As we have seen repeatedly in Clinton's explanations of the email controversy, she relies on excessively technical and legalistic answers to explain her actions. While Comey did say there was no evidence she lied to the FBI, that is not the same as saying she told the truth to the American public -- which was the point of [Chris] Wallace's question.... Although Comey did say many emails were retroactively classified, he also said that there were some emails that were already classified that should not have been sent on an unclassified, private server. That's the uncomfortable truth that Clinton has trouble admitting. -- Glenn Kessler, Washington Post
Jonathan Mahler of the New York Times: "During Tim Kaine's six years in Richmond's local government, he became known for his commitment to the city's African-Americans. But there were also stumbles as he began to fashion himself as the centrist conciliator that he is known as today, trying to steer a middle path in a majority-black city drenched in Confederate history." -- CW
Matea Gold of the Washington Post: "Charles Koch on Sunday forcefully shot down the possibility that he would support ... Hillary Clinton in this year's White House race, calling such an idea 'blood libel...,' comparing the notion to false accusations throughout history that Jews killed Christian children for ritualistic purposes. 'At this point, I can't support either candidate,' Koch said...." -- CW
Steve Benen: "On Monday, Sept. 26, the major-party candidates -- and any third-party candidate with more than 15% support in national polls -- will meet for the first of three ... [debates]. What's unclear is whether or not Donald Trump will agree to participate.... On 'Face the Nation' yesterday, Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort [said]..., '... He [Trump] said he wants to participate in it.... So, we're going to sit down with the commission in the next week or so and we're going to start talking to them.' In other words, it sounds as if Team Trump sees the existing schedule as the starting point for negotiations.... Hillary Clinton has already agreed to participate in the three scheduled debates." -- CW
She's a very dishonest person. I have one of the great temperaments. I have a winning temperament. She has a bad temperament. She's weak. -- Donald Trump, contrasting his "temperament" with Hillary Clinton's
David Sanger & Maggie Haberman of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump on Sunday offered a muddled explanation of his views about the 2014 annexation of Crimea by Russia and its continued efforts to undermine Ukraine's control of other parts of the country, and he amplified his earlier suggestion that, if elected president, he might recognize Russia's claim and end sanctions against it.... Not since 1976, when President Gerald Ford committed a major gaffe in one of his debates with Jimmy Carter, declaring that 'there is no Soviet domination of Eastern Europe,' has the issue of American support of Eastern European states, both those in NATO and those outside it, emerged as a major presidential campaign issue." -- CW ...
... Atlantic: ": Speaking to ABC's George Stephanopoulos, Trump said of Russian President Vladimir Putin, 'He's not going into Ukraine, OK? Just so you understand. He's not going to go into Ukraine, all right? You can mark it down and you can put it down, you can take it anywhere you want.' Stephanopoulos pointed out that Russia had already annexed Crimea. The response was classic Trump: This is all proof of how terrible Obama is, but also it's not really so bad. He confirmed that he would consider recognizing the annexation: 'But, you know, the people of Crimea, from what I've heard, would rather be with Russia than where they were.'... At first glance, this looks like a classic example of Trump just not really knowing what he's talking about.... But on closer glance..., in his worldview, Russia seizing sovereign territory in violation of international law is acceptable. He even parrots the Kremlin line that Crimeans have a right to self-determination -- further evidence of a close alignment between Putin and Trump." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Aaron Rupar of Think Progress: "Trump's line on Crimea is essentially the same one being pushed by Russian media. The New York Times reported that the referendum [on whether to annex Crimea to Russia] took place while the peninsula was being occupied by 'heavily armed Russian troops.' Western leaders denounced the vote as illegal." -- CW
#Trumpelthinskin, Ctd. Rebecca Savransky of the Hill: "... Donald Trump on Monday said the country needs to focus on radical Islamic terrorism following the candidate's attacks on Khizr Khan, the father of a Muslim U.S. soldier killed in Iraq. 'Mr. Khan, who does not know me, viciously attacked me from the stage of the DNC and is now all over T.V. doing the same - Nice!' Trump tweeted Monday. 'This story is not about Mr. Khan, who is all over the place doing interviews, but rather RADICAL ISLAMIC TERRORISM and the U.S. Get smart!'" -- CW ...
... Rebecca Savransky: "Families of fallen service U.S. members are demanding ... Donald Trump apologize for his 'offensive' and 'anti-American' comments. The group of Gold Star families on Monday wrote a letter to the billionaire condemning his treatment of the family of U.S. Army Capt. Humayun Khan, who was killed in Iraq. 'Ours is a sacrifice you will never know...,' the group said in a letter published Monday on VoteVets.org." -- CW ...
... Jennifer Steinhauer of the New York Times: "In a remarkable and lengthy rebuke of his party's nominee, Senator sharply criticized Donald J. Trump's comments about the family of a fallen Muslim Army captain, saying, 'While our party has bestowed upon him the nomination, it is not accompanied by unfettered license to defame those who are the best among us.'... 'In recent days, Donald Trump disparaged a fallen soldier's parents,' he wrote of the parents, Khizr and Ghazala Khan. 'He has suggested that the likes of their son should not be allowed in the United States -- to say nothing of entering its service. I cannot emphasize enough how deeply I disagree with Mr. Trump's statement.'" -- CW ...
... Katie Zezima of the Washington Post: "Donald Trump faced mounting criticism from leaders of his own party Sunday, as a confrontation between the Republican nominee and the Muslim American parents of a soldier killed in Iraq continued to consume the presidential race." -- CW ...
I've had a flawless campaign. -- Donald Trump, on ABC News
... Alexander Burns, et al., of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump reeled on Sunday amid a sustained campaign of criticism by the parents of a Muslim American soldier killed by a suicide bomber in Iraq and a rising outcry within his own party over his rough and racially charged dismissal of the couple. The confrontation between the parents, Khizr and Ghazala Khan, and Mr. Trump has emerged as an unexpected and potentially pivotal flash point in the general election. Mr. Trump ... has repeatedly answered the Khan family's criticism with harsh and defensive rhetoric.... He earned no reprieve with his complaints that Mr. Khan had been unfair to him or with his repeated attempts to change the subject to Islamic terrorism.... Mr. Trump on Sunday morning made a third attempt to deflect Mr. Khan's criticism, writing on Twitter that the real issue at stake in the election was terrorism. And he continued to complain that Mr. Khan had been unfair to him." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Noah Bierman of the Los Angeles Times: "Trump could have let the moment pass, or simply praised [the Kahn family's] sacrifice without confronting them, as other politicians have done when met by military families ... [as did Hillary Clinton on Fox "News" Sunday when asked about parents who faulted her for their sons' deaths in Benghazi, Libya]. On Sunday, as the controversy festered, Trump complained on Twitter that 'I was viciously attacked by Mr. Khan at the Democratic Convention. Am I not allowed to respond? Hillary voted for the Iraq war, not me!'" -- CW ...
... David Graham of the Atlantic: "In late 1953, Senator Joe McCarthy turned his red-baiting crusade toward the Army, accusing it of being stocked with Communists. McCarthy and his chief counsel, Roy Cohn, had miscalculated, and the reaction doomed McCarthy's crusade and career. Decades later, Cohn became a close friend of a young real-estate developer named Donald Trump. If Cohn's protégé learned anything about from him about why it's unwise for a politician to go to war with the U.S. Army, it isn't showing today." -- CW ...
... Wait, Wait! There's More. Ben Mathis-Lilley of Slate: "Trump adviser and friend Roger Stone escalated things way, way further than all but the most cynical/drug-addled among us could have imagined: [In a tweet, Stone writes,] 'Mr. Khan more than an aggrieved father of a Muslim son- he's Muslim Brotherhood agent helping Hillary'. The link [Stone provides] goes to an article on a low-budget conspiracy site.... Roger Stone ... appears to have been Donald Trump's primary political adviser for decades." -- CW ...
... Huh. A Muslim Brotherhood infiltrator? Not according to winger Charles Hurt, writing in the Hill. He says Hillary Clinton "duped" nice-guy Khizr Khan into "smearing Donald Trump," which was a neat trick because "it was was her vote that sent Capt. Khan to his death." (CW: See also my thanks to mike pence, below.) ...
... CW BTW: If you are looking for some context on Clinton's Iraq War vote, Fred Kaplan has it (Feb. 4, 2016). It wasn't exactly Bloody Hillary waving a sword & calling for Saddam's head. ...
... Greg Sargent: "Donald Trump's continuing war with the Khan family -- which Trump inexplicably continued to keep in the news this morning with a series of new tweets -- raises the specter of a brutal trap for Republicans.... If Republicans don't break off their support for Trump's candidacy now, they run the risk of having no choice but to do so after Trump sinks even further into wretchedness and depravity, to a point of true no return.... As Peter Wehner, a former speechwriter for George W. Bush, put it: 'Trump is a man of sadistic cruelty. With him there's no bottom.' If ... Republicans such as [Paul] Ryan will have [to cut Trump loose] not in defense of their own principles, but because events forced them to." -- CW ...
... Kim Soffen of the Washington Post: After Khizr Khan raised his pocket-copy of the Constitution, "sales of the little book are skyrocketing. A $1 edition of the pocket Constitution printed by the nonpartisan National Center for Constitutional Studies became the second-bestselling book on Amazon. It remains there today. It's not just sales; Google searches for the document increased more than tenfold on Friday compared to the daily average of the previous month." -- CW
Another Trump Conspiracy Theory. Connor O'Brien of Politico: "Donald Trump is slamming Michael Bloomberg's endorsement of Hillary Clinton, speculating that the former New York mayor cut a deal with the former secretary of state to get a job in any new Clinton administration. 'Personally, I think he made a deal with Hillary, where ... he gets a job,'... [Trump] said in an interview airing Sunday on ABC News' "This Week." CW: Dark, evil forces are conspiring against the noble mogul; there's no other possible explanation. Except paranoia.
Matthew Nussbaum of Politico: "With an imaginary letter, a disputed invitation and controversial comments about a fallen soldier's parents, Donald Trump's weekend was not going well even before he seemed to endorse the Russian annexation of Crimea, in opposition to U.S. policy and international law. This was a weekend ... [that] seemed to demonstrate all of the flaws -- trouble with the truth, an inability to let criticism go unanswered and a lack of knowledge of world affairs -- that Republicans fear Trump will be unable to put behind him and that Democrats hope will be the billionaire's undoing come November." CW: So being a lying, thin-skinned, ignorant bully is maybe not so presidential?
Rebecca Sinderbrand of the Washington Post: "... after [Donald Trump] and nine others were trapped in an elevator at the Mining Exchange Hotel [in Colorado springs,] 'The firefighters were able to secure the elevator, open the top elevator hatch, lower a ladder into the elevator, which allowed all individuals to self-evacuate, including Mr. Trump, onto the second-floor lobby area,' fire spokesman Steven Wilch told Colorado station KRDO in a Saturday report.... If you think that's the sort of thing that might prompt him to mention the fire department in his remarks at that event..., you're right! 'We have a fire marshal that said we can't allow more people,' Trump said, as the crowd booed. '... The reason they can't let them in is because they don't know what they're doing.' [He].. said that Fire Marshal Brett Lacey was "probably a Democrat, probably a guy that doesn't get it.'" -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Cyra Master of the Hill: "Indiana Gov. Mike Pence defended his running mate in a statement Sunday night, blaming President Obama and Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton for the 'disastrous decisions' that led to the death of Capt. Humayun Khan in Iraq.... 'Captain Khan gave his life to defend our country in the global war on terror. Due to the disastrous decisions of Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, a once stable Middle East has now been overrun by ISIS...,' Pence said." ...
... CW: Thanks for putting everything in perspective, mike. When Kahn was killed in Iraq in 2004, Barack Obama was an Illinois state senator & Hillary Clinton was a U.S. senator. It's true Clinton voted to allow President Bush to go to war against Iraq, if necessary, but so did you, mike. Clinton has repeatedly called the vote a mistake; you have not. (Note: Clinton was also among the majority of Democratic senators who voted to fund the Iraq War; John Kerry, John Edwards & Teddy Kennedy were among the 12 [including one then-Independent] who voted nay.) In addition, David Graham of the Atlantic reminds us, "Trump supported the war in Iraq, though he has repeatedly claimed he did not." One thing I wish you would clear up: exactly when was the Middle East "stable"? As far as I know, war, unrest, & shifting borders have characterized the region since prehistoric times.
Steven Myers & Andrew Kramer of the New York Times: Trump campaign manager Paul "Manafort's influence in [Ukraine] was significant, and his political expertise deeply valued, according to Ukrainian politicians and officials who worked with him. He also had a voice in decisions about major American investments in Ukraine, said a former spokesman for Ukraine's foreign ministry, Oleg Voloshyn, who also ran as a candidate in the new bloc Mr. Manafort helped form.... It is not clear that Mr. Manafort's work in Ukraine ended with his work with Mr. Trump's campaign." -- CW
Show Us the Returns! New York Times Editors: No issue "is more important for voters to keep in mind than the failure of Mr. Trump to disclose his full income tax returns, something he is not likely to do by Election Day. He is the first major party candidate since 1976 -- since Watergate, essentially -- to deny voters that vital measure of credibility.... Mr. Trump has not hesitated to attack the I.R.S. as 'very unfair,' but now he stands before the voters using the agency as a shield against disclosure.... Mr. Trump's contention that there's nothing to learn from his tax returns should be a red alert to voters." -- CW
Driftglass codes Trump. -- CW
Paul Krugman: "... the great majority of ... not-crazy Republicans are still supporting Mr. Trump for president.... No non-crazy person, even on the right, thinks that this president is acting like a dictator, or that the woman he wants to succeed him would threaten basic liberty. On the other side, anyone watching her opponent has to be very, very worried about his authoritarian streak." ...
... CW: I hope Krugman is just pretending he has no idea what's going on. Congressional Republicans have been all about power & showed almost no interest in governance at least since Newt Gingrich rose to power within the GOP Congressional ranks.
The Stupid Party. Conservative Max Boot, in a New York Times op-ed: "The Republican embrace of anti-intellectualism was, to a large extent, a put-on. At least until now.... The trend has now culminated in the nomination of Donald J. Trump, a presidential candidate who truly is the know-nothing his Republican predecessors only pretended to be.... In a way, the joke's on the Republican Party: After decades of masquerading as the 'stupid party,' that's what it has become. But if an unapologetic ignoramus wins the presidency, the consequences will be no laughing matter." -- CW
Dave Weigel & John Wagner of the Washington Post: "Nina Turner, a former Ohio state senator who became one of Bernie Sanders's most passionate surrogates, confirmed Sunday night that she has been offered a spot on the Green Party's 2016 ticket. She hasn't decided whether to accept it.... Turner attended the Democratic National Convention as a Sanders surrogate, expecting to second his nomination for president. She was blocked by Clinton's campaign. That, and the roiling controversy over the Democratic National Committee's hacked emails, may have made Turner more receptive to the Green Party pitch." CW: Nice work, Clintonistas!
Way Beyond the Beltway
Yesim Dikmen & David Dolan of Reuters: "Turkey dismissed nearly 1,400 more members of its armed forces and stacked the top military council with government ministers on Sunday, moves designed by President Tayyip Erdogan to put him in full control of the military after a failed coup. The scale of Erdogan's crackdown - more than 60,000 people in the military, judiciary, civil service and schools have been either detained, suspended or placed under investigation since the July 15-16 coup - has unnerved Turkey's NATO allies, fuelling tension between Ankara and the West." ...
... CW: Not to dismiss the importance of Erdogan's takeover, but it's useful to view it in the context of U.S. politics. If you watch the video accompanying the Reuters story, you'll see that Erdogan & Donald Trump share not only the same autocratic bent but also the same interior decorator. Isn't Trump's preference for what contributor Patrick called the "Louis Farouk" style all the proof you need that Trump would become a repressive dictator?