A Perfect Libertarian Moment

Maureen Dowd segues from a brief riff on the misogyny of Kentucky's Republican senatorial nominee Rand Paul to an appreciation of Rolling Stones rock star Keith Richards, whom Dowd describes as "a consummate gentleman."

The Constant Weader stuck with Paul:

Let's talk about that other consummate gentleman -- Rand Paul -- with whom you began. It was one of Rand Paul's county campaign coordinators -- a man named Tim Profitt -- who stomped the head of a woman wearing glasses whom his colleagues had wrestled to the pavement.

One of those colleagues has tentatively been identified as also being associated with Paul's campaign.

Rand Paul himself knew Tim Profitt. The Huffington Post posted a picture of the two men arm-in-arm.

Paul boasted, in a full-page Lexington Herald-Leader ad that Profitt was among a group of people who had endorsed him.

The victim, Lauren Valle, said this to reporters: "The Rand Paul campaign knows me and they have expressed their distaste for my work before. They surrounded me. There were about five of them, they started motioning to each other, and they got behind me." Valle says her partner heard the men say, "We're here to do crowd control and we might have to take someone out."

Now, let's look at what candidate Paul had to say to Fox "News": "… And there was a bit of a crowd control problem." Paul didn’t condemn the violence. He didn't offer an apology to the victim. He didn't acknowledge that the man who stomped Valle’s head was one of his campaign coordinators. But he did volunteer that bit about crowd control.

 As a libertarian, Paul believes people should not just fend for themselves. They should also organize themselves socially to take care of problems. Instead of bringing federal money to Kentucky to help fund clinics to deal with serious drug problems, Paul has said local churches should counsel drug abusers. That’s a philosophy that well might spill over into "crowd control." Instead of depending on paid law enforcement, a campaign could "work together" to deal with "undesirables" – like MoveOn’s Lauren Valle.

I suspect that if some intrepid, fast-moving Kentucky reporters put their minds to it, they could uncover evidence -- before November 2 -- that Rand Paul or his campaign "deputized" Tim Profitt & perhaps others to handle "crowd control." This meant, to some in the Paul campaign, that they would muscle out MoveOn volunteers and other "liberal" demonstrators.

The evidence so far is that Tim Profitt did not act on his own. Sure, after Paul's disastrous interview, the campaign reversed course & disowned Profitt. But I'd guess Profitt is just a sacrificial bigfoot. I suspect Profitt did what he thought he was told to do, and he got carried away doing it. In the heat of the moment, that kind of thing will happen, especially when the deputies are overly-enthusiastic amateurs.

The stomping of Lauren Valle's head was a perfect libertarian moment. It was a perfect tea party moment. It is what you get when you "get the government off your back." You get vigilantism. And that is what the perfect gentleman Rand Paul proposes to promote if he goes to Washington.