The Commentariat -- May 8, 2016
David Nakamura of the Washington Post: "President Obama delivered an impassioned call to civic action and responsibility at Howard University's commencement Saturday, giving an upbeat assessment of the nation's trajectory...." -- CW (Also linked yesterday.) ...
... A pretty, pretty good address:
** Yes, You Can. Gretchen Morgenson of the New York Times: President "Obama could instruct officials at his Treasury Department to close the so-called carried interest tax loophole that allows managers of private equity and hedge funds to pay a substantially lower federal tax rate on much of their income. Forcing these managers to pay ordinary income taxes on the gains they reap in their funds would accomplish two things. It would take away an enormous benefit enjoyed almost exclusively by some of the country's wealthiest people. And, tax experts say, it would generate billions in revenue to the government each year.... Changing the carried interest loophole [does not] require an act of Congress," tax experts say. -- CW
Robert Barnes of the Washington Post: Chief Justice John Roberts is "a fierce defender of the judiciary's independence and a firm believer in judicial restraint -- albeit a kind that at times is apparent only to him." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Robert McCartney of the Washington Post: "The Federal Transit Administration, citing Metro's botched response to Thursday's fire at the Federal Center SW station, on Saturday issued a series of emergency directives to the transit agency and threatened to shut down all or parts of the nation's second-busiest subway unless it took 'urgent action' to ensure passenger safety. In its toughest measures since it took over direct safety oversight of Metro in October, the FTA ordered daily inspections for 'hot spots' and water leaks along tracks, as well as reductions in the number of railcars in service and slower speeds for trains so less power is used." -- CW
Dan Roberts of the Guardian: "Republicans have blamed the current president for so much that a satirical meme was born. Flat tire? Broken fingernail? 'Thanks, Obama.'...Yet one thing Trump supporters and Democrats agree on is the extent to which the party of Lincoln has been twisted out of recognition by its loathing for the current occupant of the White House. Amid bitter recriminations over Trump's successful exploitation of this mood, many are wondering if the president's greatest legacy may be the desolation of the Republican party, which did so much to frustrate his own time in office but may take decades to recover once he leaves." -- safari
Presidential Race
Gabriel Debenedetti of Politico: "Hillary Clinton won the Guam Democratic caucuses Saturday.... According to unofficial results announced by Guam Democratic Party chairman Joaquin Perez, Clinton won 60 percent to Sanders' 40 percent." -- CW (Also linked yesterday.)
Liz Kruetz of ABC News: "During a campaign event in Oakland, California..., [Hillary Clinton] prescribed a new name for the man who is being called the Republican presumptive nominee: The 'presumptuous nominee.'" -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
George Packer of the New Yorker: Donald Trump "thrashed his way to this summit by understanding ... the decline of American institutions and mores, from Wall Street and the Senate to cable news and the Twitterverse, made the candidacy of a celebrity proto-fascist with no impulse control not just possible but in some ways inevitable.... Conservative orthodoxy, already weakened by its own extremism - the latest, least appealing standard-bearer was Ted Cruz -- has suffered a stunning defeat from within. And Trump has replaced it with something more dangerous: white identity politics.... Bernie Sanders speaks to and for [the working class] -- not as being white but as being economically victimized.... He has ... outperformed Clinton with the white working class." -- CW
Evelyn Rupert of the Hill: "Donald Trump took a swing at Hillary Clinton at a Friday night rally, using President Bill Clinton's affair to counter Clinton's attacks on his standing on women's issues. 'Nobody in this country was was worse than Bill Clinton with women. He was a disaster,' Trump said at a rally in Eugene, Ore. 'I mean there's never been anybody like this and she was a total enabler. She would go after these women and destroy their lives. I mean have you ever read what Hillary Clinton did to the women that Bill Clinton had affairs with? And they're going after me with women. Give me a break, folks.'" ...
... Maggie Haberman of the New York Times: Trump made similar remarks in Eugene, Oregon, Saturday. ...
... CW: In general, Trump is right -- Hillary was a "total enabler" who repeatedly dismissed the credibility of Bill's lovers & orchestrated the management of "bimbo eruptions" -- but I don't know that dredging up her egregious behavior of decades ago will help Trump much now.
Liar or Demented? Maggie Haberman: "Donald J. Trump said he was was 'blindsided' when Paul D. Ryan, the House speaker, withheld an endorsement from him this week, saying that Mr. Ryan had called to congratulate him after he won the New York primary on April 19.... On 'Meet the Press,' Mr. Trump said of the purported phone call: 'He called me to congratulate me. Couldn't have been nicer.'... But a spokesman for Mr. Ryan said Saturday that such a call never took place." CW: If wishes were fishes, Trump would be a truthful man. ...
... Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post: "... most politicians will drop a talking point if it gets labeled with Four Pinocchios by The Fact Checker or 'Pants on Fire' by PolitiFact.... Trump makes Four-Pinocchio statements over and over again, even though fact checkers have demonstrated them to be false. He appears to care little about the facts; his staff does not even bother to respond to fact-checking inquiries. But, astonishingly, television hosts rarely challenge Trump when he makes a claim that already has been found to be false." Kessler provides "a summary of recent Four-Pinocchio statements made by Trump." -- CW
Alexander Burns of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump will not rule out an effort to remove Paul D. Ryan as chairman of the Republican National Convention if he does not endorse Mr. Trump's candidacy. Mr. Trump stopped s hort of calling for Mr. Ryan, the speaker of the House, to step down from his convention role. But in an interview that aired Sunday on NBC's 'Meet the Press,' Mr. Trump said there could be consequences in the event that Mr. Ryan continues withholding his support." -- CW ...
... Nolan McCaskill & Nick Gass of Politico: "Donald Trump and his allies are lashing out at House Speaker Paul Ryan for his refusal to back -- for now -- the presumptive Republican nominee, with Trump's spokeswoman even declaring Ryan unfit for his job...The same sentiment was expressed Thursday evening by Fox News host Sean Hannity,who told viewers he is no longer 'ready to support Ryan as speaker. 'I'm thinking maybe we need a new speaker,' Hannity said during his show. 'Thoughts?'" --safari
Kristen East of Politico: "Gene Sperling -- a former top national economic adviser to Presidents Bill Clinton and Barack Obama who has been advising Hillary Clinton on economic policy -- said Trump's comments [about "making deals" to reduce payments to U.S. Treasury note holders] 'would risk a global financial meltdown, drive up interest rates for Americans for decades, and seriously harm middle-class families.'... 'For Donald Trump to casually announce he would consider defaulting on our debt for the first time in our history shows a stunning lack of responsibility and understanding of the global economy,' he said." -- CW
Jessie Hellmann of the Hill: "Former U.S. Sen. Gordon Humphrey (R-N.H.) called Donald Trump a sociopath Friday, saying he would never support the presumptive GOP nominee...." -- CW
Curtis Tate of The Wichita Eagle: "Former Kansas Sen. Bob Dole endorsed Donald Trump for president on Friday, becoming the only former Republican presidential nominee to do so. Dole, who was his party's nominee in 1996, will also attend the Republican convention in Cleveland in July, where Trump is expected to be nominated." --safari
When the KKK whines about PC culture, then adopts it. Asawin Suebsaeng of The Daily Beast: "'... We knew what would happen what the liberal media always does,' the (anonymous) Grand Dragon toldThe Daily Beast, before decrying 'political correctness' in America and reiterating that Trump would be 'best.' He alleged that the journalists selectively edited the long interview ['semi'-endorsing the Donald] tomake them look as loathsome and bigoted as possible. 'They wanted to make us seem as racist as [they] could,' the Dragon said." --safari
Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. CW: The top story in Saturday's New York Times is a longish piece on the rift in the GOP. The word "racist" or its derivatives never pops up once. Instead, it seems, Trump has an "outsider message." Right. ...
... Annals of Journalism, Ctd. Steve M. "In The New York Times, Patrick Healy and Jonathan Martin assess how we got to this Trump moment -- and go a wee bit overboard blaming it all on new media.... But Trump's primary means of transmitting his message is TV. In March, the Times reported that Trump had received nearly $1.9 billion in free TV time; that number, as of the end of April, is up to $2.8 billion." --safari...
... Rob Reiner gives the "journalists" at MSNBC a well-deserved dressing down. These people are clueless morons. --safari:
Beyond the Beltway
Beth Quimby, et al., of the Portland (Maine) Press Herald: "The Old Orchard Beach fire chief [Ricky Plummer] -- who has worked previously at numerous fire departments in Maine and elsewhere in New England and the U.S. -- was charged with arson early Saturday for allegedly setting the April 15 fire that burned 42 acres of the Jones Creek Marsh and forced the evacuation of a nearby condominium complex." -- CW
Bryce Covert of ThinkProgress: "Under current law, states aren't allowed to institute drug tests for unemployment benefits. But that hasn't kept Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker (R) from trying. In July, Walker approved legislation that would implement drug tests for both unemployment benefits and food stamps, neither of which are currently permissible. To get his way, he&'s suing the government to allow him to move forward with implementation...But in the meantime, he took steps this week to do as much as he can under his limited authority." --safari
Michelle Goldberg of Slate: "The long war over sex ed could provide a template for the current fight over trans people and public bathrooms, which is playing out both on the state level -- most notably in North Carolina -- and in local school districts. Both are volatile because they involve kids, schools, and sex...If the battle over sex heralded the beginning of the religious right, the battle over trans people in bathrooms will show us whether the religious right has any power left." --safari
Way Beyond
Ben Hubbard of the New York Times: "In a new wave of royal decrees, King Salman of Saudi Arabia on Saturday replaced a number of top ministers and restructured government bodies in a shake-up that paved the way for significant changes in how the state is run." -- CW (Also linked yesterday.)
Richard Smart of the Guardian: "North Korea will not use nuclear weapons against other nations unless its sovereignty is threatened, and will work toward nonproliferation and global stability, leader Kim Jong-un has said, according to state media.... In remarks apparently aimed at nations such as South Korea, Japan and the United States, Kim suggested that the nation will look to internationalise further, and 'improve and normalize the relations with those countries which respect the sovereignty of the DPRK and are friendly towards it, though they had been hostile toward it in the past'...But analysts took Kim's comments to congress with a pinch of salt." --safari
News Ledes
CBC (Canada): "A massive wildfire nicknamed 'the beast' has forced a work camp north of Fort McMurray housing first responders to evacuate Saturday night." ...
... New York: "The record-breaking wildfire that has engulfed the city of Fort McMurray in Alberta, Canada over the past week may yet still double in size, Alberta Premier Rachel Notley said on Friday night, warning that, 'in no way is this fire under control.' The Associated Press reports that due to bad weather conditions, including continued high temperatures, dry weather, and high winds, the fire grew on Friday from impacting around 100,000 hectares to more than 156,000 hectares, and another likely two-fold increase in size would encompass additional forested areas, possibly reaching the border of the neighboring province, Saskatchewan, some 90 kilometers east of Fort McMurray." ...
... AP Update: "Officials said Sunday they reached a turning point in fighting an enormous wildfire, hoping to get a 'death grip' on the blaze that devastated Canada's oil sands town of Fort McMurray amid cooler temperatures and light rain. Meanwhile, a massive evacuation of residents displaced by the blaze came to an end."
Reader Comments (6)
"In 1870, Julia Ward Howe responded to the horrors of the Civil War by issuing her “Mother’s Day Proclamation,” calling on women around the world to rise up and oppose war in all its forms....
It would be decades before Americans officially began celebrating Mother’s Day, and much of the original spirit of the proclamation has since been lost...
The Brave New Foundation, Code Pink and No More Victims are leading a movement to restore that spirit to the day, and for that we applaud them." Truthdig
Rob Reiner tried. One could say, after Trump gives another one of his equivocal (I'm being generous here) answers, "This does NOT answer my question" or "This makes no sense" and keep at it until... The slogan, "I need my Morning Joe", might well be changed by putting a comma after morning –––I'd be up chucking my shredded wheat after listening to that program.
My only quibble with Rob Reiner's critique of journalists is that he lets the Morning Joe crew talk him into say that not all Trump supporters are racists. Yes they are.
It is quite possible to find some of Trump's proposals appealing -- say, infrastructure investment (even if the proposals are impossible since he also says he's going to cut the deficit to zero) -- but his racist proposals far outweigh the benefits of his non-racist proposals. Since Democrats have made the same policy plans -- to focus on infrastructure -- the only reason to support Trump is that you like his racist policies, too.
All Donald Trump supporters are racists, not just the white supremacists & Confederate flag aficionados. What pisses me off is the way the media avoid the obvious, a la the NYT Martin & Healy story, linked above. Their piece is the prime example of the "normalization" of Trump-brand Racism that Steve M., Paul Krugman, David Roberts & others have warned would happen. It's here, & right on the front page of Krugman's paper.
Marie
Trump's proposal that the U.S. negotiate settlement of its debt, tossing promises of "full faith and credit" out the window, may be the most intriguing of his many off-the-cuff, whatever just bubbled to the surface of what passes for his mind, remarks.
As right as he is that debt does get negotiated and forgiven all the time in the world of private finance and even at the national level, politically it's a bombshell. Not only does the remark--I guess it doesn't really rise to the level of a proposal--strike at the root of real American exceptionalism, that is, America considered as the world's Daddy Many-Moneybucks, but it suggests that massive, unheard of redistribution, which I understand Republican elites don't much like, from individuals and nations who have (them) to those who don't (US).
How radical could a Republican get?
I'd think even floating that idea would give any wealthy Republican, not to mention other countries and their monied investors, anyone dumb enough to invest in the United States, real pause.
More in mangled Trump-speak!
" “The middle class has to be protected,” Trump told NBC. “The rich is probably going to end up paying more.” .
Our newest Orange Man, "He,Trump" frequently mentions that he went to the best schools. Apparently, he skipped class when it came to " Grammar. "
Yeh! What's the big deal? Using verbs correctly are so overrated.
Where are hackers when you need them? Can't someone download Mr.-I'm-soooo-Smart's college transcripts?
Also, on the Show-and-Tell list, when do we get to see the tax returns? Before Cleveland? After Cleveland? When hell freezes over!
@MAG: How bigly Trump mangles the language!
The thing is, I expect he's making these mistakes because he thinks they're "presidential."
Last Tuesday, he could have said, "We're gonna win big," which is what most of us would say. It isn't grammatical, but it's idiomatic. Some part of his brain must have told him -- correctly -- that an adverb was needed, and he made up "bigly."
Similarly, look at the construction of "the rich is" sentence. He begins with "the middle class," which is singular, so he probably thought, somewhere in the shallow folds of his brain, that it should follow that "the rich" is singular, too. It isn't.
The rich are not so very different from you and me. For instance, some of them try to put on airs. And all of them find the English language difficult. Because it is.
Marie
@Marie: F. Scott Fitzgerald begs to differ "Let me tell you about the very rich. They are different from you and me..." Though, if F. Scott had spent any time around a Donald-like character and based, "The Rich Boy" on him, the opening lines might well have been rewritten per your point. The Donald thinks everything he does is in the best taste, more stylish, more awesome, the 'biggler the better"—(and his dainty dining habits so much classier than Kasich's). Gatsby worked at self-improvement and to fit with a perceived higher social set, the Donald is a know-it-all, publicity hound who works full time at self-aggrandizement. Correct speech, not so much.
How can we forget the bigly endorsement episode in Iowa this past January? Where Trump appeared somewhat uncomfortable on the stage as the original Word-Salad-Shooter, Ms. Palin delivered one after another of her bewildering, un-diagrammable sentences.
Some media scribes (I believe) mistakenly assumed that Trump was embarrassed by her overlong, nonsensical rambling diatribe. Nope, he was probably thinking, "...damn, she took all my gooder words."