The Fault, Dear Brooks, Was in Your Star
How to write a David Brooks column: (1) read a book; (2) regurgitate the author's findings; (3) draw a conclusion that is completely inconsistent with the author's findings. This week, the title of Brooks' column is "Tom Joad Gave Up." Tom Joad is the protagonist in John Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath, the latter part of which is set in California.
Brooks read some stuff that told him California state government was a lean, clean, operating machine up through the administration of Gov. Pat Brown, after which it became dysfunctional. Brooks found this set of facts so compelling, he accepted it. The problem for Our Miss Brooks was that he could not bring himself to name the person responsible for the California disaster. Consequently, he blamed the fictional Tom Joad for "giving up" on California.
The Constant Weader fills in the blank:
Aren't you clever! You name the last "progressive" governor, Pat Brown, then you identify a "period" when California politics started to go south. But you never mention the movie star who destroyed the state's government. Bravo, you did one heck of a job of dancing around the unnamed anti-hero -- a fellow called Ronald Reagan who was governor from 1967 to 1975.
Reagan ran against, & beat, the admirable progressive Pat Brown (Jerry's dad) on a platform of "sending the welfare bums back to work" (very classy) & "cleaning up the mess at Berkeley" (where my messy husband was teaching at the time).
As governor, Reagan was so confrontational he sent in the California Highway Patrol to quell student demonstrations & the National Guard to literally occupy Berkeley. He also effectively declared war on the state university itself when he used J. Edgar Hoover's FBI to cook up charges of "ultra-liberalism" against professors, members of the Board of Regents & Clark Kerr, the chancellor at Berkeley & president of the UC system. Since Reagan was simultaneously hoping the Republicans would nominate him for the presidency, evidently he wanted to show them he would be a good war President.
As for his fiscal conservatism, Reagan raised California taxes more than any other governor of any U.S. state EVER. His budget was more than twice that of Pat Brown's. It was that tax increase that led to the backlash that produced Prop 13, which hobbled the state forevermore by severely limiting property tax revenues.
"Tom Joad gave up"? A fictional character had nothing to do with the end of good governance in California.
It was a real actor who was to blame -- Gov. Ronald Reagan. Funny you didn't mention him.