The Commentariat -- August 20, 2017
... Julia Jacobo, et al., of ABC News: "One week after violent protests rattled Charlottesville, Virginia, a scheduled free speech rally in Boston today was met with thousands of counterprotesters, but the day went off mostly smoothly, police said, with 33 arrests but few injuries. The free speech rally was deemed 'officially over' by police ahead of its official end time, but thousands of counterprotesters continued to spread out in the city throughout the afternoon, with some protesting peacefully but others confronting officers and people. A total of 33 arrests were made today, mostly from disorderly conduct and a few assaults on police officers, the Boston Police Department announced. Police Commissioner William Evans said at a news conference this afternoon that some urine-filled bottles were thrown at officers, and police indicated on Twitter that some demonstrators were throwing rocks at police.... Evans said that '99.9 percent of the people here were for the right reasons -- that's to fight bigotry and hate.'" ...
... Tara Golshan of Vox: "The Boston Free Speech rally, which many feared would draw a violent crowd of white supremacists Saturday, was instead overshadowed by thousands of counter-protesters denouncing bigotry and racism. The dueling demonstrations on Boston Common showed a shocking disparity in size. As Vox’s Alex Ward reported from the scene, the Free Speech rally, scheduled to begin at noon, was only permitted for 100 participants.... Meanwhile, counter-demonstrators ... filled the grounds outside a security perimeter, drowning out the speeches at the Free Speech rally. More anti-racism protesters, led by the Black Lives Matter chapter, marched through Boston Saturday from the Reggie Lewis Track and Athletic Center to join the counter demonstration at Boston Common. Police are estimating roughly 15,000 people in the march, according to ABC News." ...
... Tyler Kingkade of BuzzFeed: "A right-wing event in Boston that billed itself a 'Free Speech Rally' attracted only a few dozen supporters on Saturday, while an estimated 40,000 counter-protesters turned up to demonstrate against racism." ...
... Brandon Patterson & Jamilah King of Mother Jones: "One week after a bitterly violent protest in Charlottesville, Va., that left one woman dead and 19 injured, tens of thousands of counter-protesters marched in at least 30 cities, including New York City, San Francisco, Chicago, Atlanta, and Washington, D.C. to demonstrate their opposition to white nationalism. The largest protest by far was in Boston, where an estimated 30,000-40,000 counter-protesters showed up, according to the Boston Globe. Only a handful of people attended the planned 'Free Speech' protest, and they were quickly overwhelmed." ...
... The New York Times report, by Katharine Seelye & others, is here. ...
Looks like many anti-police agitators in Boston. Police are looking tough and smart! Thank you. — Donald J. Trump August 19, 2017
... Then, "an abrupt shift in tone":
Our great country has been divided for decades. Sometimes you need protest in order to heal, & we will heal, & be stronger than ever before! -- Donald Trump, August 19
I want to applaud the many protestors in Boston who are speaking out against bigotry and hate. Our country will soon come together as one! -- Donald Trump, Aug 19, 2017 ...
... Sarah Betancourt of the Guardian: "Donald Trump described anti-fascist and anti-racist demonstrators who converged on Boston as 'anti-police agitators' on Saturday, in a tweet that seemed destined to revive the still simmering controversy over his remarks equating the far right and anti-Nazis in Charlottesville last weekend.... But he later seemed to back the right to demonstrate....” ...
... Kevin Drum: "Nonviolence isn’t the answer to everything, but it is here. The best way to fight these creeps is to take their oxygen away and suffocate them. Fighting and bloodshed get headlines, which is what they want. So shut them down with lots of people but no violence. Eventually they’ll go back to their caves and the press will get bored. Of course, all of this depends on our president not doing anything further to support their cause. If that happens, I reserve the right to revise and extend my remarks." ...
... AP: "Duke University removed a statue of Gen. Robert E. Lee early Saturday, days after it was vandalized amid a national debate about monuments to the Confederacy. The university said it removed the carved limestone likeness early Saturday from Duke Chapel where it stood among 10 historical figures depicted in the entryway.... '"I took this course of action to protect Duke Chapel, to ensure the vital safety of students and community members who worship there, and above all to express the deep and abiding values of our university,' [Duke President Vincent] Price said in the letter. Durham has been a focal point in the debate over Confederate statues after protesters tore down a bronze Confederate soldier in front of a government building downtown. Eight people have been charged with tearing down the statue during a protest on Monday. Hundreds marched on Friday through downtown Durham in a largely peaceful demonstration against racism, leading to an impromptu rally at the site where the bronze statue was toppled." ...
... Nathan Fenno of the Los Angeles Times: "... during a rally earlier this week to show solidarity in the aftermath of the violence in Charlottesville, Va., a [University of Southern California] campus group linked the name [of the university's mascot Traveler] to Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee, whose favorite horse was Traveller.... [Richard Saukko, who owned the first Traveler -- a movie horse -- & rode it in what was to be a one-off at a 1961 USC football game, has said the horse was already named when he purchased it.] The earliest mention of a connection between Lee and USC’s Traveler appears to have come in [Richard] Saukko’s four-paragraph obituary in The Times. 'Saukko's first horse was half Arabian, half Tennessee walker and was named Traveler I, after the horse of Civil War general Robert E. Lee,' the story said."
David Nakamura, et al., of the Washington Post: "President Trump and first lady Melania Trump have elected not to attend the annual Kennedy Center Honors in December amid a political backlash among those who will be feted at the event. The first family will not participate 'to allow the honorees to celebrate without any political distraction,' White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said in a statement Saturday morning. The announcement comes as three of the five honorees — television producer Norman Lear, singer Lionel Richie and dancer Carmen de Lavallade — said they would boycott the traditional White House reception related to the celebration. As for the other two, rapper LL Cool J had not said whether he would attend, and Cuban American singer Gloria Estefan said she would go to try to influence the president on immigration issues.... This is the first time in the awards' history that the White House portion of the festivities has been canceled."
David Remnick of the New Yorker: "During [a campaign] speech in Charlotte[, North Carolina, in early November 2016, President] Obama warned that no one really changes in the Presidency; rather, the office 'magnifies' who you already are. So if you 'accept the support of Klan sympathizers before you’re President, or you’re kind of slow in disowning it, saying, "Well, I don’t know," then that’s how you’ll be as President.'... [Afterwards, in a private conversation, Obama said,] 'We’ve seen this coming.... Donald Trump is not an outlier; he is a culmination, a logical conclusion of the rhetoric and tactics of the Republican Party for the past ten, fifteen, twenty years. What surprised me was the degree to which those tactics and rhetoric completely jumped the rails.' For half a century, in fact, the leaders of the G.O.P. have fanned the lingering embers of racial resentment in the United States. Through shrewd political calculation and rhetoric, from Richard Nixon’s “Southern strategy” to the latest charges of voter fraud in majority-African-American districts, doing so has paid off at the ballot box.... The imperative is to find ways to counteract and diminish his malignant influence not only in the overtly political realm but also in the social and cultural one.” ...
... New York Times Editors: Donald Trump has changed the subtext of the GOP's "Southern strategy" into text. "For reasons of ineptitude and ideological complicity, the [Republican] party’s leaders did almost nothing to counter the Trump phenomenon, nor did they seek in any sustained fashion to temper his worst excesses, beginning with his false claims about President Barack Obama’s birth and proceeding onward through his demagogic Inaugural Address."
Mike Allen of Axios: "At the end, Trump was beyond fed up, viewing Bannon as a self-aggrandizer who had built a personal narrative as the grand puppetmaster. 'Who the f[uc]k does this guy think he is?' Trump has said incredulously to associates." ...
... digby: "Bannon is a self-professed chaos agent who is happy to use Trump's simple-minded vacuousness for his own purposes, one of which is obviously to 'let Trump be Trump.' But they are not on the same page, not really, and the fact that people still think that Trump is some kind of an economic populist or an isolationist in any way is frustrating. He has no philosophy, he has domination impulses. That's it." ...
... Ryan Lizza: "... in the Trump White House there is no Trump agenda. There is a mercurial, highly emotional narcissist with no policy expertise who set up — or allowed his senior staffers to set up — competing ideological fiefdoms that fight semi-public wars to define the soul of Trumpism.... The lasting legacy of Bannonism is the xenophobia and hostility to nonwhites that emanates from the White House and has remained a political fire that this Administration is constantly fanning. But, as we learned this week, Trump doesn’t need Bannon to keep those flames alive." ...
... Josh Marshall notes that Trump just fired the one guy who does not seem to have been implicated in the Russia scandal. But Marshall has a feeling Bannon knows a lot about Trump & other Friends of Vlad.
Maureen Dowd tells a story about the time her Irish cop father quashed the local KKK. "There will be a lot of pain while this president is in office and the clock will turn back on many things. But we will come out stronger, once this last shriek of white supremacy and grievance and fear of the future is out of the system. Every day, President Trump teaches us what values we cherish — and they’re the opposite of his.... He’s no tough guy if he can’t stand up to the scum of the earth. He followed the roar of the crowd to dark, violent places, becoming ever more crazed and isolated and self-destructive, egged on by the egotist and erstwhile White House strategist Steve Bannon but really led by his own puerile and insatiable ego."
John Wagner of the Washington Post: "Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, who faced calls from his Yale University classmates to resign in the wake of President Trump’s controversial comments about last weekend’s violence in Charlottesville, defended the president Saturday and said he intends to stay in office. 'While I find it hard to believe I should have to defend myself on this, or the president, I feel compelled to let you know that the president in no way, shape or form believes that neo-Nazi and other hate groups who endorse violence are equivalent to groups that demonstrate in peaceful and lawful ways,' Mnuchin, who is Jewish, said in a statement released by the Treasury Department."
Russ Feingold in the Guardian: "The lesson from Charlottesville is ... the unmasking of the Republican party leadership. In the wake of last weekend’s horror and tragedy, let us finally, finally rip off the veneer that Trump’s affinity for white supremacy is distinct from the Republican agenda of voter suppression, renewed mass incarceration and the expulsion of immigrants.... Words mean nothing if the Republican agenda doesn’t change.... Gerrymandering, strict voter ID laws, felon disenfranchisement are all aimed at one outcome: a voting class that is predominantly white, and in turn majority Republican.... Even if the entire Republican party rises up in self-professed outrage at white supremacists, if voter suppression and other such racist policies survive, the white supremacists are winning. And America is losing."
Juliet Eilperin of the Washington Post: "The Trump administration has decided to disband the federal advisory panel for the National Climate Assessment, a group aimed at helping policymakers and private-sector officials incorporate the government’s climate analysis into long-term planning. The charter for the 15-person Advisory Committee for the Sustained National Climate Assessment — which includes academics as well as local officials and corporate representatives — expires Sunday. On Friday, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s acting administrator, Ben Friedman, informed the committee’s chair that the agency would not renew the panel.... But NOAA communications director Julie Roberts said in an email Saturday that 'this action does not impact the completion of the Fourth National Climate Assessment, which remains a key priority.'”
Faith Karimi, et al., of CNN: "North Korea warned Sunday that the upcoming US-South Korea military exercises are 'reckless behavior driving the situation into the uncontrollable phase of a nuclear war.' Pyongyang also declared that its army can target the United States anytime, and neither Guam, Hawaii nor the US mainland can 'dodge the merciless strike.' The messages in Rodong Sinmun, the official government newspaper, come a day before the US starts the Ulchi Freedom Guardian military exercises with South Korea."
News Ledes
Washington Post: "Ten U.S. Navy sailors are missing and five have been injured after the USS John S. McCain destroyer collided with an oil tanker near Singapore early Monday morning. This is the second time in two months that a Navy destroyer based at the 7th Fleet’s home port of Yokosuka, Japan, has been involved in a collision. Seven sailors were killed when the USS Fitzgerald collided with a tanker south of Japan in June."
New York Times: "Jerry Lewis, the comedian and filmmaker who was adored by many, disdained by others, but unquestionably a defining figure of American entertainment in the 20th century, died on Sunday morning at his home in Las Vegas. He was 91."
New York Times: "... a team led by Paul G. Allen, the billionaire co-founder of Microsoft, announced that it had found unmistakable wreckage of the Indianapolis [-- a U.S. Navy cruiser sunk by the Japanese during World War II --] 18,000 feet deep in the Philippine Sea, rekindling memories of the Navy’s worst disaster at sea."